Edit: The issue was definitely my tension! One is 34 stitches x 34 rows = 4 inches and the other is 31 stitches x 28 rows = 4 inches 🧎🏽♀️My tension is so perfect on non-colorwork projects I just couldn't believe it lol. Thank you everyone!! Gonna go reknit this thing 🧶
I am just completely confused right now. I've knit 5 pairs of socks and I have never had this issue, but this is my first time doing colorwork.
I followed the exact same instructions for both socks, and I take notes on literally everything I do on the 1st sock and follow those for the 2nd. I know I knit them in the same size, as the colorwork charts are different for each size and I would have noticed the change. And even if I didn't, I triple check the number of stitches after casting on, completing the heel turn, and starting the toe.
The only possible thing I can think of is that I used the wrong needle size but I can't imagine that being the case. I used a fixed size 1 needle for the cuff and an interchangeable size 2 for the rest of the sock, and I didn't even disassemble the size 2s before starting the second sock! Upon realizing how much bigger the 2nd was, I double checked and sure enough, the needle is the correct size. I used the exact same technique to knit both as well, just in case the issue is the length of floats being looser in the 2nd, I included a picture. I don't even think I accidentally knit the entirety of sock 1 on size 1 needles, because I've only knit socks on size 1s before and I remember being annoyed with how bulky the size 2s felt when I was getting used to them.
The gauge on the 2nd sock is definitely looser than the 1st, I just cannot figure out how this came to be. The issue isn't blocking either, I like to block my socks together once they're completed. Any help would be appreciated T-T
The pattern is Easy Peasy Socks by Karolina Adamczyk. The yarn is Cascade Heritage in the color Snow and WYS Signature 4 Ply in the color Summer Sunset.