So.. figured i’d ask this question.

What are your thoughts on giving him an 3 year extension in the off season? Using the numbers after 6 games and a smaller share of snaps than the top 3, he would still be looking at like 500-700 yards, 6 TD without Terry out.

He’s shown to have heart and be a hard worker and is only 26.

Maybe our WR3 going forward? Antonio moves into WR2 and high draft pick (or trade) to be named later for WR1 (X)

Again this is all based on how the rest of the season goes. Just a thought experiment.

Antonio Williams is showing the same early signs as the Day 2 rookie WRs who broke out in past seasons, and he's coming out of our bye this week.

https://pigskinpal.app/pigskinpaper/next-rookie-wr-breakouts

The model looked at every WR drafted in Rounds 2 and 3 from 2020 to 2025. The ones getting 3+ targets a game early in the year went from 7.5 PPR points a game to 14.9 the rest of the way. That's the Jayden Reed, Ladd McConkey and Tank Dell group.

Williams is getting 4.3 targets a game, and his snaps went from 37 to 49% in the first three weeks to 67 to 69% in each of the last three. He's at 7.4 PPR points a game, right where those guys were before they took off.

Now McLaurin is out for the season. He had 27 targets in five games, Williams had 26, and only Diggs (38) had more. Those targets have to go somewhere, and Williams is the receiver whose role was already growing. The projection in the article has him around 12 PPR points a game after the bye, and that's before factoring in McLaurin being out.

First game back is Week 8 against the Eagles, be on the lookout for a huge game.

I feel like there are a lot of guys that have really looked solid all year and yet we are still giving up tons of points

If he’s really on the trade market, what are you giving up for him? We’re not in win now mode but this would be a building piece for the foreseeable future. Do we think a 3rd in 2027 and a 5th in 2028 could get it done?

He’s in a contract year, but I’d view this as a trade and extend situation. We know who he is and have the cap. Guys like this don’t often hit the market.

Imagine this line next year:

LT - Tunsil
LG - Nelson
C - FA pickup
RG - Cosmi
RT - Connerly

This would pretty quickly be one of the best lines in the league pending the center. I think trading for Nelson would solve our biggest issue on offense right now and the years coming.

I know this reddit tends to hate mid season trades because of Lattimore, but this is different imo. Nelson is in his prime at 30 and guys at his position tend to go through their mid to late thirties. Would lock down the left side of the line for the next few years.

Here’s a look at the current roster, practice squad, IR, and depth chart heading into the bye week!

Division is still easily up for grabs tbh

The emotions are a crazy roller coaster 😅

Gonna start with I’ve had a few beers, so this probably isn’t the most rational post.

But damn, watching Jayden get absolutely slaughtered and bashed these past two weeks has pissed me off. Especially while Caleb and Maye get praised beyond belief. Right now I am watching these dudes with competent defenses, great play calling (wide open guys), great O-line play, great/good run games, great/good weapons, and they still look mediocre for the most part. And they, still, make consistently bad/awful decisions that if JD5 made we’d lose by 75 points. I mean, have you ever seen him get bailed out by a WR screen on 3rd and 18 for a TD? Or have a 50 yard RB screen TD to end the half and get points?

Meanwhile, we have the worst coaching in the league, an awful defense, horrible play calling, a non existent run game, and mediocre - bad weapons, and I watch JD5 ball the fuck out and carry our shitty ass team again and again. Then he gets relentlessly shit on by the media for not being a “winner”, and honestly it’s just absolute bullshit. It’s incredible how bad our team is around him. Also, I gotta have Maye and Williams shoved down my throat like they are the next Messiah because they have all the help in the fucking world.

It just fucking pisses me off that we are putting JD5 in this position. He is so incredibly talented and rare, and I am watching us ruin him in real time. Yeah, we “ruined” RG3, but we had Snyder, and (most importantly) he had plenty of issues that made his game not translate well to the League. He wasn’t 50% of the NFL QB JD5 is. But now, even after Snyder, I have to listen “RG4” talks because our incompetent organization puts him in the worst possible position to succeed. We are bad or awful in every area that matters regarding supporting a young ascending QB. We put him in bad situations (Seahawks, Vikings). We give him no help, and never bail him out of anything. We have a terrible roster that is terribly coached.

I will always be a Redskins fan. Even if JD5 leaves and succeeds, I will support him, but I am a Redskins fan first and foremost. But it angers me that in 2026/2027, with a star QB, I am still deeply ashamed of our organization. We are ruining an amazing young QB and the national perception of him due to our arrogance and incompetence. It’s a joke.

After seeing him in person, I think he genuinely looks amazing. He gets great separation, clean routes, and awesome hands. I genuinely feel like the only thing holding him back is just not having enough targets. Am I crazy in thinking if he starts getting fed, he has enough juice to be our WR1? I am extremely high on him and think Adam Peters knocked it out of the park drafting him when we look at most other WRs that went before him in the draft.

The guy is a demon.

Still: fire Dan Quinn.

I was daydreaming earlier today. What if we win this shitter division and get tunsil back for the playoffs. Our o-line does a 180, all the sudden we can run the ball, teams don’t know what hit them because we’re just a different beast.

Been thinking about this during the bye. 2024 was amazing, obviously. Nobody expected a rookie QB and a new staff to get us all the way to the NFC Championship Game. But looking at the last two seasons, I wonder if that run made us think the rebuild was almost done when maybe it wasn’t. We made some win-now moves, but the roster still has a lot of holes and not much depth.

So do you think 2024 made Peters and Quinn rush things a little or was it still the right way to go?

Man I miss those days