r/Colts • • 2d ago

Discussion GM Random Thoughts Thread

20 Upvotes

This thread is intended to serve as a place to write out your random thoughts about who should be our next GM. Please do not clog up the main channel with short thoughts that don’t warrant an entire post—this thread is the proper outlet for that.

Important news updates and long-form, well-thought-out posts are still permitted, as always.


r/Colts • • 19h ago

Free Talk Friday

2 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 11h ago

So what? Just makes me want to start him even more

Post image
259 Upvotes

So you can be an NFL player in a legal state and have weed but when you do it in an illegal state it’s a problem. No one cares about weed except cops trying to get paid dude.


r/Colts • • 15h ago

Anything to avoid QB1

Post image
280 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 17h ago

Docs: Colts’ Anthony Richardson Sr. charged with marijuana possession in Carmel

Thumbnail
fox59.com
335 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 13h ago

News Sauce and Warren out

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 16h ago

News [James Boyd] #Colts QB Anthony Richardson Sr. has been charged with possession of marijuana, per online records. The charge was filed Monday and stem from a traffic stop one week earlier on Oct. 12. @FOX59 was first to report.

Thumbnail x.com
129 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 12h ago

News [Kevin Bowen] CJ Allen (ankle) in a boot after getting hurt yesterday in practice.

Thumbnail x.com
42 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 17h ago

Discussion If Shane Steichen wants to save his job, beating the Vikings would be a good start

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
44 Upvotes

Chris Ballard is out, and Shane Steichen could be next if the Colts can't turn their season around. Indianapolis has lost 10 straight games against teams that finished .500 or better. Can Steichen's team pull off an upset against the undefeated Vikings and their league-best defense?

Read for free.


r/Colts • • 7h ago

The colts will win on Sunday

8 Upvotes

I think we can all agree that the team wasn’t given nearly enough time before they moved on from the GM

The team will be pissed off and motivated. They’ve responded really well to adversity in the past, and I think they do again this time as well.

The Vikings also might be the worst 5-0 team ever. They’ve beat up on bad offenses and their own offense can’t move the ball.

Colts win 27-6


r/Colts • • 40m ago

Discussion What deal would you be okay with teams offerering for Jonathan Taylor?

Post image
• Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

[🎥 James Boyd] Jonathan Taylor on if he’s thought about his future on the Colts: “I think it would be a disservice to my teammates and this whole organization to think about what could be.”

103 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

Former Colt Marshall Faulk reveals Parkinson's diagnosis

Thumbnail
theadvocate.com
242 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

🤣🤣🤣

Post image
706 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

Quality Post Yo this man edgerrin is crazy!!

76 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

Without a 1st round pick there is ZERO reason to trade JT. Even with a first it should be something that’s only entertained if he is the one asking for it.

89 Upvotes

We can’t lose the plot just because Ballard is gone. JT is 27 and has A LOT left in the tank. If he isn’t asking to be traded then why do it? Our roster has a fundamental problem as is, talent that nobody outside of Indianapolis knows that is filling up key positions. Trading JT just adds to that. Let him be the guy that sets the standard for the change that is to come.


r/Colts • • 1d ago

Just a matter of time

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

r/Colts Picasso Indianapolis Colts Week 7 Matchup Doodle!

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

[Highlight] Jonathan Taylor is asked on the recent trade rumors regarding him and if he’s thought about such ahead of their Sunday match-up against the Minnesota Vikings.

59 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

Shit post Look, my name is Bris Challard, and I’m here to interview for the General Manager position

Post image
177 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 1d ago

Statistics Trade Deadline and What to Possibly Expect

49 Upvotes

With the obvious firing of Chris Ballard, looking to the trade deadline is probably the hottest talking point among the fanbase. I wanted to do some digging and see what could be reasonably expected, and what previous trades have amounted to.

My criteria was I wanted to find a trade in last 5 years, that would be the closes to mimick what a potential deadline would look like. I also took i to account pedigree, age, and time of trade (in-season vs offseason). Also their accolades are only from before they were traded.

Keep this in mind that this is more of an exercise. I am not predicting anything or advocating against or for these trades. If anyone has any other trades they think would compare better than I am open to some opinions! Without futher ado.

Quenton Nelson: Joe Thuney to the Bears

Compensation: Chiefs trade Joe Thuney to the Bears for 2026 4th round draft pick.

Joe Thuney: 3x first team all pro, 2x second team all pro, 4x pro bowler. Age when traded, 32.

Quenton Nelson: 3x first team all pro, 3x second team all pro, 8x pro bowler Age, 30.

DeForest Buckner: Leonard Williams to the Seahawks.

Compensation: Giants trade Leonard Williams to the Seahawks for 2024 2nd round pick, and 2025 5th round pick.

Leonard Williams: 1x pro bowler. Age when traded, 29.

38sacks, 224tkls, 6FF, 4FR

DeForest Buckner: 1x first team all pro, 1x second team all pro, 3x pro bowler Age, 32.

75.5sacks, 395tkls, 9FF, 11FR

Jonathan Taylor: Christian McCaffery to the 49ers.

Compensation: Panthers trade Christian McCaffery to the 49ers for 2023 2nd, 3rd, and 4th round pick, and 2024 5th round pick.

Christian McCaffery: 1x first team all pro, 2x pro bowler. Age when traded, 26.

4726rush yds, 38rush tds, 3756rec yds, 22rec tds

Jonathan Taylor: 1x first team all pro, 3x pro bowler Age, 27

8090rush yds, 76tds, 1632rec yds, 7rec tds

Grover Stewart: Jordan Philips to the Cowboys

Compensation: Giants trade Jordan Philips and a 2026 7th round pick to the Cowboys for conditional 2026 6th round pick

Jordan Philips: 24sacks, 124tkls. Age when traded, 32.

Grover Stewart: 13.5sacks, 221tkls. Age, 33.

Josh Downs: Donovan Peoples-Jones to Lions

Compensation: Browns trade Donovan Peoples-Jones to the Lions for 2025 6th round pick

Donovan Peoples-Jones: 1895yds, 8tds. Age when traded, 24.

Josh Downs: 2429yds, 11tds. Age, 25.


r/Colts • • 1d ago

News [Nathan Brown] Colts back at practice after missing Wednesday: -LB Bryce Boettcher (groin) -G Matt Goncalves (ankle) -TE Drew Ogletree (ankle) -DT Jerry Tillery (personal) -CB Justin Walley (knee) -WR Keenan Allen (rest) -CB Charvarius Ward (rest)

Thumbnail x.com
28 Upvotes

Good news. Note: Anthony Gould in concussion protocol


r/Colts • • 1d ago

If it was up to you, is Downs on the market ?

Post image
29 Upvotes

Would you be reluctant to trade anyone on this team?


r/Colts • • 3h ago

Skattebo and a first for Jonathan Taylor?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Colts • • 10h ago

Discussion Non-Colts Fan Here, Was Chris Ballard Really That Bad?

0 Upvotes

Okay so I’m not super plugged into what’s up with you guys week to week, but it’s always seemed to me like Indy has had some really good players/pieces but underachieved, and that they‘ve mainly just been a franchise QB and really good HC away from being a real contender. I’ve heard people wanting Ballard’s head on a stick for a long time, but never thought lack of overall talent was the main issue post-Luck.

I might sound like an idiot here, but it’s a genuine question: Are the rosters just horribly top-heavy past first glance? Is the Richardson pick just a fireable offense despite the surrounding track record? One area I can see where frustration would grow over a period of years is its seemed from the outside looking in that he’s had a bit of a “add surrounding pieces first, find a QB to drive it later” philosophy that Pittsburgh has had post-Roethlisberger for example.