colder takes:
*the moms (jess and jill, mostly) massively bullied brynn. this is obviously a cold take because everybody and their mother knows this lol
*it’s lowkey bad parenting to not tell mackenzie that they were leaving, something that directly affects her (i am NOT calling melissa a bad parent, that would be stupid based on the fact that i don’t know her personally in the slightest, however it was a moment of poor parenting, or at the very least bad decision making)
*nia not getting picked for the trios was super upsetting, i wish she’d had a solo to make up for it (and don’t give me any of the “there wouldn’t be enough time to choreograph all of those numbers” shit, they’ve done several numbers in a short period of time dozens of times before). also…not a great look, even if not intentional (which i’m absolutely sure it wasn’t). don’t think i have to explain why
*i relate to mini peyton on a personal level, im so bad at remembering dances 😭 the fact that she and all the other minis (well, all the dancers in general) remembered so much in such a short period of time was super impressive
warmer(ish) takes:
*jessalynn was an instigator but im sorry i found her sooo funny 😭 in every single scene where there was an argument which didn’t involve her or jojo she was just laughing in the background and it made me laugh too
*the way kendall was propped up as abby’s number two girl all of a sudden was…confusing to me? naturally she improved a LOT over the show’s progression but i still found her veryyy lacking in the emotions department, kalani/brynn is an obvious choice for a “maddie backup” imo
*also. this is more of a jab at the producers for choosing to not air certain things but the way everybody was like “kendall and maddie have been duet partners for YEARS!!!” had me like ??? when ??? 😭 apparently they had a ton of duets together that just weren’t aired/weren’t competed but like. why not show some examples in an episode if you want to highlight them as duet partners? i guess you could just go online and try and find their duets together but it’s a little annoying to not be shown this information directly. i looked it up and apparently pre season 6 they only did two duets together (that were actually aired). just doesn’t scream CONTINUOUS duet partner to me idk i never really saw them as this really important dynamic, the bond between people like mackenzie and nia or chloe and maddie seemed much more genuine and compelling to me
*i didn’t care when they tried to bring christy and sarah back for an episode like im sorry i just dont give a shit, these are brynn storyline reheated nachos from only like. 5 episodes ago 😭
*i…don’t think grifters is thaaat bad. don’t get me wrong it’s still a very difficult watch, and also not nia’s fault that she forgot, the choreography was kind of shitty to start with and not to mention she only had a day to learn it. but i think i can probably name 5 duets from the show that were worse than it. also side note but i wonder if nia also messed up in the judged version or only the recorded version? if somebody knows please let me know!
*i have no idea if this is a hot take but jojo absolutely should have placed in her michael jackson solo, thought she was super fun. new york dance experience is always an odd competition anyway, sometimes the feedback they give doesn’t line up with how they place. like with the baseball group dance the judges were like “we LOVE IT!!!” only for it to not place 😭
*ashlee is a lot worse than i remember in terms of her behaviour. don’t get me wrong the moms never tried to make an effort with her, but she was always starting something particularly with kendall (though in case you couldn’t tell i’m also not kendall’s biggest fan). kendall’s “why are you so mean?” moment was…kind of valid? the social media comment was so unnecessary. according to ashlee that entire fight was scripted because jill and kendall had an audition to go to, and the producers told them to stage a fight so that she could leave early. but even so, the shit that ashlee said took it too far, you can’t convince me that kendall was purely putting on an act to leave early. idk, i just find ashlee incredibly polarising in general, especially because her political opinions are…definitely less than favourable, really don’t like her (her twitter is a MESS). body tea tho unfortunately.