I (20F) have been dating my boyfriend (20M) for around eight months. We are in a serious relationship and have discussed moving in together, getting married, and having children in the future.
However, for the past four months, we’ve been arguing constantly about his friends, especially a girl I’ll call Val, who has been his friend for five years.
I’m writing this because I genuinely need outside perspectives. I love my boyfriend, but I’m exhausted, confused, and starting to question whether our relationship is healthy.
The problems with his friends
My boyfriend has a close group of friends, including Val and another friend I’ll call Dylan.
Over the past few months, several incidents have made me feel deeply disrespected.
Dylan made racist and extremely offensive comments involving my deceased father. My father died when I was 13, so this was particularly hurtful.
Val has also insulted me multiple times, including after I suffered a miscarriage. She has called me toxic, made comments about me not having friends, mocked my past romantic experiences, and criticized me to my boyfriend.
She has also insulted one of my own friends.
I felt humiliated, especially because my boyfriend continued being close to these people.
To be completely transparent, I haven’t always behaved perfectly either. I’ve criticized his friends and said negative things about them, particularly when I was angry or hurt.
However, I did this privately. I didn’t directly contact them to insult them or attack them personally.
I understand that criticizing someone’s friends can still be hurtful, and I’m willing to acknowledge my responsibility in these conflicts.
Why his friendship with Val bothered me
Val and my boyfriend have been friends for approximately five years.
They regularly texted, spent time together, and went on outings.
At first, I tried to accept their friendship. I don’t believe that men and women can’t be friends, and I don’t want my boyfriend to have no female friends.
But after the insults and everything that happened, I became increasingly uncomfortable with their closeness.
For example, he continued spending time with her even after knowing how much the situation was affecting me.
He went to her horse-riding activities, and they continued communicating frequently.
At one point, I discovered messages between them where he complained about our relationship.
He told her things along the lines of:
“She controls my friendships.”
“I’m not happy, but I don’t want to leave her.”
Meanwhile, she was criticizing me too.
This was particularly painful because I felt that he was sharing our private relationship problems with someone who had repeatedly disrespected me.
There were also situations where I felt he wasn’t completely honest about their communication.
Over time, my trust started deteriorating.
Four months of arguments
For approximately four months, we repeatedly argued about Val.
I explained that I didn’t feel comfortable with how close they were, especially after the insults.
He kept defending their friendship and telling me that nothing inappropriate was happening.
He eventually promised to establish boundaries, but I didn’t feel that much changed.
I started feeling like I had to constantly explain why certain situations hurt me.
I also want to mention that he previously asked me to stop communicating with someone from my romantic past.
I respected his request, even though it was emotionally difficult.
Because of that, I struggled to understand why he considered my concerns about Val unreasonable.
His younger brother, his younger brother’s girlfriend, and his parents have also expressed concerns about the situation.
I know their opinions don’t automatically prove that my perspective is correct, but it reassured me that I wasn’t the only person finding the situation uncomfortable.
The incident that changed everything
A few days ago, I discovered a conversation between my boyfriend and Val.
Apparently, Val had gained weight and sent him a picture of her thighs to show him.
I didn’t read the entire conversation, so I don’t know every detail or exactly how the subject came up.
However, I saw his response.
He wrote in French:
“C’est incroyable les grosses cuisses vraiment.”
Which roughly translates to:
“Thick thighs are genuinely amazing.”
I was extremely upset.
I understand that discussing weight gain with a friend can be completely innocent.
However, considering their history, I felt that sending him a picture specifically of her thighs was inappropriate.
His response made me even more uncomfortable because it sounded like he was expressing physical appreciation for her body.
When I confronted him, he insisted that it wasn’t cheating and that he hadn’t done anything particularly serious.
I explained that even if he didn’t consider it cheating, I still felt betrayed.
We argued for approximately two hours.
Eventually, we called two mutual friends, a man and a woman, to ask for their opinions.
Both agreed that the interaction was strange and inappropriate, particularly given everything that had already happened between us.
The ultimatum
After months of arguments, I reached a point where I felt I couldn’t continue dealing with this situation.
I told him that if he wanted to remain friends with Val and keep her on social media, he was free to do so, but I wouldn’t be able to continue our romantic relationship.
I wasn’t trying to force him to stay with me.
I genuinely felt that I couldn’t remain in a relationship where I constantly felt disrespected and anxious about the same person.
However, I understand that giving someone an ultimatum about a friendship is a serious thing.
His reaction made me feel terrible.
He kept saying things like:
“We’ve been friends for five years.”
“My life is going to suck without Val.”
“I’m just going to stay locked inside my house.”
He explained that most of his outings involved Val and another friend, Ylan, and that without Val, he wouldn’t really go out anymore.
I felt incredibly guilty.
I started wondering whether I was ruining his social life and taking away someone important to him.
I was also upset because while I was trying to explain how much the previous months had hurt me, I felt that the conversation focused mainly on what he would lose.
Eventually, he decided to delete and block Val on every platform.
But things haven’t improved the way I expected.
Instead of feeling relieved, I feel guilty and emotionally exhausted.
I know that losing a five-year friendship can be painful.
I don’t expect him to celebrate losing someone who mattered to him.
But I also don’t think I should have to feel responsible for his entire social life.
His behavior afterward
Since blocking Val, my boyfriend has seemed noticeably colder toward me.
Normally, when we finish a phone call, he says something affectionate, like “kisses,” and we talk naturally about our days.
Now, he sometimes ends calls without saying anything affectionate.
When I called him after work, as I normally do, he barely seemed interested in talking.
He asked when I would arrive home, but didn’t really engage in our usual conversation.
I eventually told him that I felt like he was making me pay for what happened.
He replied:
“I’m not making you pay for anything, but I’m not going to jump for joy either.”
I understand that he’s sad.
But I feel like his sadness has turned into emotional distance toward me.
I reminded him that when he asked me to stop talking to someone from my past, I was also sad, but I tried not to let that affect the way I treated him.
I don’t want him to pretend everything is fine.
I just want to feel that we’re still partners rather than opponents.
The conversation with his friend
Recently, I looked through his tablet while he was away.
I know this was an invasion of privacy. I’m not proud of doing it, and I recognize that it reflects how much my trust has deteriorated.
I found out that he had spoken to one of his male friends on the phone for approximately 30 minutes about the situation.
I don’t know what they discussed during the call.
However, I saw some messages afterward.
My boyfriend apologized to his friend about the situation.
His friend responded with something like:
“I’m not the person you should be apologizing to.”
There was also another message along the lines of:
“You’re going to tell her, but what exactly are you going to say?”
I don’t know exactly who they were talking about, and I don’t want to assume something without evidence.
Still, discovering that conversation made me anxious.
I started worrying that my boyfriend might secretly contact Val again.
And that fear scares me because I don’t want to become someone who constantly checks her partner’s phone.
My own responsibility
I want to make it clear that I don’t believe I’ve handled everything perfectly.
I’ve criticized his friends.
I’ve become increasingly jealous and suspicious.
I gave him an ultimatum.
I looked through his private messages.
And sometimes, during arguments, I’ve let my emotions influence how I communicate.
I understand that these behaviors can damage a relationship too.
I also understand that my boyfriend has a right to friendships and that losing someone he’s known for five years can be genuinely upsetting.
I don’t want him to be isolated.
I don’t want to control who he talks to.
And I don’t want a relationship where either of us feels trapped.
At the same time, I don’t think being in a relationship means accepting repeated disrespect, dishonesty, or situations that make you uncomfortable.
Where we stand now
I still love him.
I still want a future with him.
And I genuinely believe that I could gradually rebuild my trust if we both made consistent efforts.
But I don’t know how to move forward.
For four months, we’ve been arguing about the same person.
Now that she’s blocked, I thought things might finally improve.
Instead, I feel guilty, he seems unhappy, and our relationship feels more fragile than before.
I’m afraid he resents me for losing Val.
I’m afraid he might eventually contact her behind my back.
And I’m afraid that even if he doesn’t, I’ll continue worrying about it.
I don’t want to spend my relationship investigating my boyfriend’s behavior.
I want to feel loved, respected, and emotionally secure.
I also want him to feel happy and free to have friendships.
I just don’t know whether we’ve reached a point where too much damage has already been done.
What I need advice on:
How can I tell the difference between setting a reasonable relationship boundary and being controlling?
How would you interpret the picture of Val’s thighs and my boyfriend’s response, considering their history?
How much time and emotional space should I give him to process losing this friendship, while also addressing the coldness I’m experiencing?
How can we rebuild trust without checking each other’s phones or constantly questioning each other’s intentions?
How should we handle the resentment and guilt that seem to have developed on both sides?
Based on everything I’ve described, what would a healthy attempt at repairing this relationship actually look like?
I’m not looking for people to automatically agree with me.
I genuinely want constructive criticism, including about my own behavior.
I love my boyfriend, but I don’t want either of us to stay in a relationship where we’re constantly hurting each other.
Any advice would be appreciated.