When people ask whether 3w lasts as long as weathertech, I think a useful comparison starts well before someone says, mine still looks good. And for a real 4x4, I’d want the same rig and the same kind of use, then follow one wear point through an actual season. Repeated muddy boots, embedded grit, pulling the liners out to clean them, temperature swings, and flexing the edges every time they’re removed all seem more informative than how either set feels on day one. Even then, one winter or trail season would only show what happened with that exact fitment, not settle the question of brand durability forever. I’d rather see a boring before-and-after record than twenty quick ownership comments with no mileage or conditions. If you tracked one thing for a full off-road season, which wear point would tell you the most about long-term liner durability?