I’ve had this friend with benefits / situationship since late last year that’s become emotionally overcomplicated (many such cases). This guy and I both caught feelings but were both too neurotic to actually cross the border into dating.
Further complicated by the fact that he’s been seeing another woman since a bit before we met and I’ve been watching their relationship develop via the accumulation of feminine detritus in his apartment. He’s always maintained that he’s just seeing other people but my suspicion is I’ve become the other woman in someone’s serious relationship. Unfortunately this activates the biologically humiliating side of my brain that wonders what she has that I don’t, or if I just got there a little too late.
Over the past two months we’ve broken things off and resumed contact a couple of times, first time he texted me a few hours after I’d left his apartment saying he just wanted to end things. A few weeks later he messaged me asking to talk. I agreed, and when we saw each other he confessed he couldn’t stop thinking about me, wants to fully commit to being with me and only broke things off because he figured I didn’t want the same thing. I admitted I felt the same way and we agreed next time we saw each other we would figure out to do about our relationship.
During this conversation there was still a pair of some bitch’s ballet flats in his entryway and an entire clean-girl skincare regimen in his medicine cabinet. Which I chose to overlook because apparently I am willing to believe a man describing our hypothetical life together while sitting among the evidence of his actual life.
We talk again the next week and he does a full 180, has feelings for me but basically isn’t willing to commit to anything. So we had breakup sex and then I told him I can’t do this anymore. Being stuck in a casual relationship where we were both openly pining for each other was killing me.
We didn’t talk for a few weeks, then last week he messages me again. Against my better judgement I agreed to see him. I went over to his apartment yesterday and I’m fairly certain this woman has moved in. Bunch of new furniture and art up on the walls. We didn’t talk about where things go from here but it felt so good to see him again that I was willing to pretend this reunion wasn’t happening in what increasingly resembles a shared domestic space. Then I lay awake half the night thinking about it.
All my friends have told me repeatedly to cut this off because it’s a waste of my time and he’s stringing me along because I’ve allowed him to for the past ten months. Unfortunately I have a weak moral constitution and poor impulse control so if left to my own devices I fear I will resign myself to other womaning and squirting a bunch of this girl’s facial cleanser down the drain every time I shower at his apartment.
Anyway please bully me out of this before I become the kind of woman who gets cheated on by proxy and takes it out on a stranger’s toiletries.