EDIT: Since a few people seem to think I'm taking this frustration out on my sister, let me clarify: I don't mock her, control what she wears, or make her feel bad about her costume. I actually help her put it together every year, and I make sure she's safe while trick-or-treating.
I'm venting here because I don't understand the pattern, not because I'm trying to stop her from enjoying Halloween. I can find something baffling without treating someone badly over it. She's free to wear whatever she wants. I just genuinely don't understand the appeal, and apparently that's being interpreted as a personal attack on her joy.
Before you read this entire fucking thesis, please keep one question in mind: WHERE IS THE FUN IN WHAT SHE'S DOING?
I need to vent about something that probably sounds stupid and like I'm being overdramatic, but it genuinely drives me fucking insane.
1. The crime
My sister turns 15 this December, and for the THIRD YEAR IN A ROW, she's chosen a Halloween costume based on a character she knows absolutely nothing about.
Two years ago, she dressed up as Emily from the Corpse Bride. Had she watched the movie? No. Did she even know the character's name? Apparently not. I asked her, “So, do you know how Emily died?” and she went, “Who?”
WHO???? THE WOMAN YOU ARE CURRENTLY DRESSED AS?????
Last year, she dressed up as some video game character despite not playing video games or knowing anything about the character.
And this year? Clawdeen from Monster High with her friends. Has she watched the movies? No. Does she know anything about the character? Also no. So I asked her, “Okay, what's Clawdeen's brother's name?” And she went, “She has a brother?”
I'M SORRY, WHAT THE FUCK ARE WE DOING HERE?
THREE YEARS. THREE CHARACTERS. THREE YEARS OF COSPLAYING AS A WALKING WIKIPEDIA PAGE WITH ALL THE INFORMATION DELETED.
WHERE IS THE FUN IN THIS? WHAT ARE YOU ENJOYING WHEN YOU DON'T KNOW WHO YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE BEYOND THE CLOTHES AND WHATEVER APPEARED ON YOUR TIKTOK FOR YOU PAGE THAT WEEK?
2. The Evil Dead case study and my proposed solution
Before anyone assumes I'm against people getting into things they're unfamiliar with, let me introduce some evidence to the contrary.
My sister's friends persuaded her to watch Evil Dead Burn at the cinema. Now, Sam Raimi, Evil Dead, and the entire franchise are incredibly important to me, so naturally I was like, ABSOLUTELY NOT. YOU CANNOT JUST WALK INTO THIS CINEMATIC UNIVERSE WITHOUT ACKNOWLEDGING ITS ANCESTORS.
She loved the movie and eventually agreed to watch all the previous films with me. I then proceeded to yap about every movie, characters, actors, directors, behind-the-scenes details and games for approximately 700 years.
She actually enjoyed it and developed a little obsession of her own, even if hers eventually passed.
And THAT'S why I suggested Ash Williams as a Halloween costume. We watched the movies together. She liked them. It was a character connected to something we'd shared.
But apparently, “I can't do a boy costume” was enough to disqualify him.
So she'd rather dress up as Clawdeen, a character she apparently doesn't even know has a brother, than dress up as someone she actually watched and enjoyed because he's male.
MAKE IT MAKE SENSE.
Because apparently group costumes take priority and fun is irrelevant.
3. Why does this bother me so much
For me, the fun of dressing up as a character is getting to embody someone I love for a night. It's a way to express something I genuinely care about.
Honestly, I'd respect someone with the shittiest, least accurate costume imaginable if they were genuinely the biggest fan of that character. You could show up with a cardboard sword, a bedsheet and a dream, and I'd respect you more than someone wearing a flawless costume of a character they couldn't identify without checking TikTok.
The connection matters more to me than the execution.
And I'm absolutely fine with beginners. If someone discovers a character and wants to learn more, I'd probably be thrilled to tell them everything I know. There's a difference between being new to something and having no interest in learning about it.
That's what I mean when I talk about poser behaviour. I don't expect people to know every album or obscure piece of lore. Listen to whatever you want. Just don't pretend to love something you know nothing about because you want the image that comes with it.
A character is more than their appearance. A scar, a hairstyle, a necklace or a pair of Converse might have a story behind it. Even the aesthetic people are attracted to can have meaning beyond looking cool.
That's what I love about cinema. There's so much to discover beyond what's on the screen: the characters, the directing, the performances, the production and the history behind the work.
Reducing a character to an outfit feels like throwing away everything that makes them interesting and keeping the packaging.
I'm not saying my way of enjoying things is objectively better. I'm saying I could never approach something I love that superficially, and I struggle to understand the appeal.
I don't mind that my sister likes Clawdeen's appearance. It's the lack of curiosity that bothers me. And when I try to suggest she choose someone she actually likes, she tells me to shut up. I'm trying to show her an alternative, not confiscate her wig and ban her from Halloween.
4. My own Halloween experience
Maybe part of why this gets under my skin is that I never really got the Halloween experience I wanted.
I didn't have childhood friends to go trick-or-treating with. When I was around 17, a friend invited me to a Halloween sleepover (I've never been to a sleepover before) , but my mother refused because it was her Birthday and we have a National holiday the next day and told me I could go the following week.
Because apparently Halloween is a subscription service that lets you reschedule your booking.
The opportunity never happened again.
I'd love to put together a proper costume of a character I adore and go somewhere with people who are equally excited about Halloween. I want to put effort into a costume because the character means something to me and share that enthusiasm with other people.
I'm not angry that my sister gets to participate when I missed out. I just wish she'd use the opportunity in a way that feels personally meaningful to her, rather than choosing something because her friends are doing it or because it's popular online.
To me, the point is to become someone you love for a night. I can't imagine having that opportunity and not caring who I'm supposed to be.
5. So, WHERE IS THE FUN?
I know people enjoy Halloween differently. Some love crafting, some want to look cool, and others just want matching costumes with their friends. I understand that.
But I still don't understand the appeal of dressing up as a character you know absolutely nothing about and have no interest in learning about.
Is it purely the aesthetic? Is it the attention? Is it having a matching costume with your friends? Is it knowing people will recognize the look?
I'm genuinely asking because I want to understand, not because I expect everyone to approach fictional characters the way I do.
Maybe I'm a gatekeeper. Call me whatever. But I don't think wanting people to show some curiosity about the things they choose to represent is unreasonable.
I don't need you to know everything. I just want to understand why you wouldn't WANT to know anything.
WHERE IS THE FUN IN WHAT SHE'S DOING? PLEASE, SOMEBODY SHOW ME THE FUN.