r/StraightPegging • u/A_Guy_Phightingback • 24m ago
I’m Too Scared To Ask My Wife To Peg Me Because… NSFW
First time posting here and brand new to the pegging community!
So I’ve been married to my wife for 8 years, together for 14, but I’m actually scared to ask her to peg me, regardless of how much my ass craves it. I suffer from Autogynephilia, or AGP, and my wife is well aware of this, and even supportive of it, to a point.
But here are the two issues holding me back from asking her:
- I’m already pretty sure she would be TOTALLY against it, and potentially even turned off if I asked her to. She had mentioned when we were last discussing my AGP, “You’re not going to surprise me with anything weird are you? Like come out and tell me you like men?” I responded, “Baby, I’m not gay. I just sometimes wish I was a beautiful woman and I like to cross dress every now and then!” Will she think that pegging me = I’m gay or don’t want her anymore? I hope not because I want her constantly, but my ass wants some company too, I just don’t know if that’s worth risking her being turned off of me.
2. And here’s the real issue that I’m sure you’ve figured out by now. I’m well trained after years of secret solo play. As I was behind my wife the other night pulling it all the way out and diving all the way back in again, I had a fantasy of her begging me to let her peg me and I came into her immediately. After we cleaned up I thought about it; if she were to peg me, there would be no way for me to hide how well trained my ass is. For a decade I’ve been secretly able to work my way up from taking something the size of a q-tip to a 9” dildo, and there would be zero way to hide how well my ass is at receiving penetration. What am I going to do? Fake that it hurts? Ooo! Owww! I’m a horrible actor! Hahaha
She’d quickly come to realize that I’ve been doing anal play behind her back for a while and if she somehow got past the fact that I asked to get pegged, she’d probably lose her mind once she realized how well trained my ass is because of secret play.
Or maybe I’m just being ultra paranoid because of how new I am to this pegging thing. I only ever done solo play and have considered buying a dildo machine a million times but ultimately, having a partner willing to fuck you in the ass is far better than having a machine that can do it.
I’ll update you if I ever build up the courage to ask her or if my fantasy of her asking me ever comes true.