r/writing • • 22d ago

Monthly "Would You Read This?" Thread

21 Upvotes

Welcome to Would You Read This (WYRT), our monthly feedback and brainstorming thread. Share your work in progress below and let other readers tell you if they'd read it. Top level posts should follow this template:

  • Title:
    • If you don't have a title yet, feel free to say UNTITLED.
  • Genre:
    • Please include at least Fiction, Nonfiction, Poetry, or another recognizable medium. You may also include more specific genres with a hyphen. Ex. Fiction - Romance, or Nonfiction - Memoir. Genre will help users find the specific kinds of posts they'd like to give feedback on.
  • Premise:
    • A few sentences about the project. Try your best to keep this short. Crafting an expert elevator pitch is all part of becoming a successful working writer. Please do not post an entire plot summary or query letter (those are better suited for r/pubtips)
  • Sample (Optional):
    • You may share up to 500 words(ish) of sample material, or one poem for those working in the poetry medium. This is optional, so if you only have a premise, you can post just the premise for feedback.

If you post for feedback, please take the time to give feedback to at least 2-3 other users. Replies should follow this template.

  • Would Read / Might Read / Wouldn't Read
    • You must begin your reply with one of those. You are then encouraged to add additional thoughts on why you choose your answer.

Rules:

  • Please post no more than two WYRT top-level posts. There is no limit on the number of feedback replies you can make.
  • Do not link to any offsite materials. All materials must be in the body of the post. This includes "click here to read more" or "DM me for the rest" types of posts.
  • Rule 3 is in effect in this thread - No generative AI. Do not post material generated by an AI platform in your premise or sample. Do not use generative AI to respond to user's work.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Stay constructive. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, their writing, or their genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • Sep 01 '26

Monthly "Promote Yo' Self" Thread

35 Upvotes

Welcome to our monthly Promote Yo' Self thread! Show the community what you put out into the world. Please follow this template:

  • Choose what you're promoting from the below options:
    • [Published Book]
    • [Article / Video / Project]
    • [Newsletter / Substack]
    • [Writing Community]
    • [Software / App]
    • [Call for Submissions]
    • [Milestone / Accomplishment]
  • Project Title
    • The title of your book, the name/title of your project, the name of your newsletter, the name of your writing community, the name of your software, or the title of your collection for which you are calling for submissions.
  • Description
    • A short premise or elevator pitch of your book, the subject matter of your newsletter, the purpose of your writing community, the purpose of your app, or the nature of your milestone.
      • Call for Submissions additionally require the following: Legal name of the entity calling for submissions, deadlines, fees, prizes, and rights requested.
  • Call to Action
    • What would you like r/writing to do? Buy your book? Subscribe to your newsletter? Submit a piece to your lit mag?
  • Discount for r/writing?
    • Share if/how the community can get a discount.

Rules:

  • Post no more than one top-level reply in the Promote Yo' Self thread each month, but you are allowed to post each month.
  • Rule 3 is in effect - No generative AI. You may not post projects generated by an AI platform, nor apps that use generative AI or expose writers' work to generative AI, nor may you post a Call for Submissions from an outlet that does not have a clear policy against publishing material produced by a generative AI platform.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, other readers, or other genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • 12h ago

Discussion When DOES a story deserve to be longer?

59 Upvotes

This is going to seem like an overwriter trying to cope with being an overwriter (mind your business!) but mostly this is from the much-given advice that a story can “always” be cut no matter what.

At risk of sounding inflammatory, I can’t imagine a world in which this is true. I can’t imagine every publishable story needing to absolutely be under 110k, keeping in mind genre conventions such as the fast paced nature of psych thrillers.

I’ve seen the defense of publishers not wanting to take on extra production costs (fair) but to me that doesn’t mean every story can or should be whittled down to make it fit. There seems to be an assumption that with stories 110k+ that there is ALWAYS bloat or you can ALWAYS condense two scenes into one or there must be some other itch that can be scratched but I can’t help wondering when that becomes a disservice. I am admittedly partial to longer books because it gives more room to deepen a world/setting and would be so sad if some of my favorites had been half their length.

Obviously there are newbies that are deadset on keeping their 2 page description of a lake, but I mean 130k after seven solid revisions. This brings me to my question of what allows a story to deserve to be longer? Does it just come down to excellent writing and ability to keep hold on attention and never let go?


r/writing • • 21h ago

Advice Should I address a test reader's 'tiffany problem' in my historical novel?

81 Upvotes

How serious should I take a test reader having a Tiffany problem with details in my novel draft?

For those who don't know the term:

"The Tiffany problem or Tiffany effect refers to the issue where a historical or realistic fact seems anachronistic or unrealistic to modern audiences of historical fiction, despite being accurate." (source: wikipedia)

It's a historical novel, setting is early Medieval Europe and I'm concerned about overexplaining minor details because a test reader/alpha reader (a writing group buddy of mine, normally very perceptive, but not someone used to reading very detail-rich historical fiction) doesn't understand them.

I already make sure to write brief explainations in the story for a lot of complex terms/words that I know for sure 99% of readers wouldn't get. I'm striving for historical accuracy but don't want to overexplain or infodump unless absolutely necessary.

I'm still in early editing stages - should I listen to my test reader/alpha reader or leave as is until I'm further in the editing stage and can run by beta readers and get more reactions? With the risk that beta readers won't comment because they do more superficial readings and feedback than my alpha reader does? He's extremely thorough in his reading and feedback, but sometimes I don't know if he's nitpicking or he's pointing out actual problems.

Or should I just wait until I can run it by an editor?

EDIT: Thanks for the comments, some good advice here. I'll wait and see what my beta readers think. For those who asked: it was a mix of the test reader not understanding certain words and not buying into certain cultural practices and types of weapons in use in that time period.

As for the suggestions about using footnotes or end notes - I would caution anyone against that in fiction writing unless it's meant to be part of the story (e.g. Terry Pratchett or Susanna Clarke). I'm using a glossary instead. But of course everyone is free to do whatever they feel works in their novel. I just don't have a novel structure where that would make sense/not be annoying or distracting.


r/writing • • 16h ago

Discussion What Was The Notable/Favorite "Eureka/NOW It Clicks!" Instances Of Your Writing And Why/How?

15 Upvotes

So you're writing the story you've had in mind for some time, but something doesn't... quite... click. You know the fundamentals of it like the plot, characters, certain scenes, etc. yet it's still missing something just out of mental reach and you're not quite sure what and/or how to get to it, so it eats away at you whether you keep writing and/or stop in frustration.

Then it hits, whether it takes, days, months, or even years until inspiration, whether suddenly and/or in a gradual process, finally hits and you finally have the story you wanted, if not better than originally intended.

I have two notable cases both of which coincidentally involve female protagonists with identity crises:

1) In the first series of my fantasy epic series, the heroine was originally just a heroine rather than The heroine as it was about the team she was a part of. Even then, she was originally the most uptight, hostile and otherwise toxic member of the team (think Vegeta during the "Frieza Saga" of "DBZ," more on him in a bit,) as despite her sympathetic reason for such behavior being clear (ex. besides the sudden fall of their homeland, she had a massive chip on her shoulder in idolizing her mother and feeling inadequate,) she still came off unlikeable, meant to get shown up by the "cooler" members of the team and prone to leaving the team to either join a lesser villain against the greater ones or be manipulated by the main villain, plus had an especially toxic relationship with the unrelated team leader (she hated him despite knowing he's innocent of what his father did as an enemy of her mother's in the past that she comes off ungrateful for all his help while he also was obsessed with her mother as a fan and out of guilt projected onto the heroine with whom she strongly resembles). And it was like this for years, if not a decade or so.

Then by around 2017 or so, I thought back on Korra's character in "The Legend of Korra," specifically about how the second season, "Book 2: Spirits," brutally gets into her head in deconstructing her upbringing as an identity crisis from realizing she was The Avatar so early in her life (when Avatars are supposed to find out at 16 to better balance their previous identity and their new one,) that she puts all self-worth in that identity/occupation, which in turn makes her feel worthless without it and takes it more personally from the villains claiming said occupation is obsolete. Thus, learning from Wan's story and the symbolism of her becoming a giant spirit reflect her valuing herself as herself instead of only The Avatar.

So I applied the same "challenge"/introspection to my heroine, where it was a close relationship with her grandmother from being personally trained/favored by her to her abrupt murder causing the identity crisis of her torn between the persona/image she "should" be per the upbringing and her actual self to the extent it affects her powers and fighting style. Speaking of which, she wasn't favored for simply being the oldest and most obedient, but now because she was the only one of her siblings that genetically inherited a specific finishing move that's a variation of mother and grandmother's that had been gifted by the gods to the latter. Said finisher not simply being powerful/unique (inspired by the elemental heads of the Orochi from "Okami," plus another for an even 10 and fired like Vegeta's Final Flash,) but complex in its uses, drawbacks and how opponents can counter/withstand it, so she feels uniquely pressured in inheriting it and mastering it (and unnerved against one enemy that can temporarily change them). She also lost her previous toxicity while being more endearingly uptight (like Hank Hill,) clear soft spots for younger people like a big sister and far more civil, platonic relationship with the team leader to have no issue with his family and more tactful argument with him when they do disagree. The tweaking continued until I felt she was The heroine of the story with the identity crisis being so strong that it caused a ripple effect throughout the story with allies and enemies, old and new characters, alike as a central theme.

2) While in the second case was the unrelated erotica series. Originally just one definite chapter then a few vague, typical porn scenarios with her coworkers and/or customers until ending at Chapter 10 in encountering her old uptight, businesswoman friend, it hit after I thought up/emphasized the heroine's own corporate past and that the old friend wasn't just uptight, but controlling towards her. Inspired by my own stressful past in middle management customer service, it now became clear that the heroine wasn't motivated by typical lust, but in freedom and living her life on her terms. The old friend controlled her life from her corporate job to being engaged to an older man she didn't love, (he's nice, but it felt like another business agreement,) that it led to a nervous breakdown and new life away from it all. Now, the initial hookup with a customer had deeper meaning because it was both passionate and especially since she chose to do so on her own and NOW chapters were organized as a character arc of building confidence, connections with other people and living life to the fullest. Now something like her first time with another woman isn't just a typical porn premise, but about her unpacking decades of baggage from simply admitted aloud that she's bisexual to the battle of wills against a younger yet ironically more experienced and confident partner (that's also her own employee.) Now she had more specific, intimate dynamics with certain partners than others in aiding this arc and now the world was getting built and themes being established of "good" characters with similar mentalities vs. "evil" characters with the opposite to the point of being exploitive to hide their own insecurities. Speaking of which, the old friend would eventually become less a "final boss" and more a starter villain at worse whose perspective gets explored to both be more complex and clearly a smaller fish to the point of being a victim, herself in the grand scheme of things. Now I didn't see this as just another "fad" story/series I'd get bored of since it now had the substance and framework of a mainstream story as it's grown the last couple years, still feels manageable/organized and substantial enough that I could legit see it as a full-blown published book. Now it wasn't just "a bunch of porn stories," but erotica.

So what about your own writing?


r/writing • • 1h ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - October 23, 2026

• Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Advice How to keep up the momentum if you've got limited time to write?

26 Upvotes

For those of you who have limited time/options to write, how do you make sure that you get the most out of those precious moments? Are there small things you do on the other non-writing days to prepare? Are there any related non-writing activities you do on those days?

Due to personal circumstances, I will have two (consecutive) mornings available for writing per week in between a day job and other commitments, and I was wondering how I could keep the momentum going in between.

I'm obviously not the first to have limited time available, so I was wondering if any fellow writers would like to share what they are doing.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Advice Do you use beta readers one at a time, or have many readers at the same time?

10 Upvotes

Hi- My draft is almost ready for a beta reader. I have a few in mind, and was wondering if I should get feedback one at a time (which seems like it would take a long time) or have them all read at the same time and try to collate the feedback?

Thanks!


r/writing • • 12h ago

Advice What do you do when you have a lot of dialogue, and do you break it up?

0 Upvotes

Sometimes I run into an issue when there's a lengthy but important conversation between two people, and I end up writing line after line of quotes, with some "s/he said", an action beat, etc. However, I still think that's a lot of talking and not a lot of doing.

Do you write some expository paragraphs to break up the dialogue? Do you think anything is wrong with having a lot of back and forth dialogue (more than 4)? What is your strategy or approach to these types of chapters?


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - October 22, 2026

3 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 22h ago

Advice Typos

0 Upvotes

So I submitted a piece of flash fiction. I proofread it twice. After submitting I read it again and found 4 small typos. (Missing some articles and though instead of through). How bad is this? Also, what are some proofreading techniques you use?


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion Revision Tips

49 Upvotes

So, I'm an aspiring author and have been working on the same project since 2017 (I also work full-time and was doing my masters on the side so it has taken me embarrassingly long). I have drafted and re-drafted the manuscript 6 times because the first few versions were god awful. Well, now I'm finally at a point where I can say it's in a decent shape and my voice is good. Of course, there is still room for improvement and I want to make small changes to plot, deepen characters etc.

I was wondering what everyone’s revision process is like. I've heard people say do revise in passes, and the concept seems very foreign to me, but then doing everything all at once feels overwhelming too (I'm writing a YA dystopian fantasy). Any tips would be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance!


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - October 21, 2026

14 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Beginner Question What exactly counts as a manuscript for a novel?

0 Upvotes

I understand that a manuscript is basically the full text of the novel before publication, but what does that mean in practice?

Does it just need to be the complete story in a standard docx file? Or are there specific formatting rules, front matter, etc. that make something a “proper” manuscript for querying/submission? Thanks!!


r/writing • • 2d ago

Advice Looking for words of wisdom (anxiety after reading first draft)

59 Upvotes

I finished the first draft of my novel. I took a month off, and then I read/edited the first draft. I went in with the goal of only paying attention to the high-level (the structure, if some scenes seem too long or are missing, etc).

When I was writing most scenes in my first draft, I was just trying to get the ideas down, and not trying to make the writing itself as amazing as possible.

Despite all that... I still ​freaked out when reading it.

I know it needs work, and I enjoy the work, but part of me is still like, "What if I fix all the problems and make the writing flow AND IT'S STILL BAD AND I WASTED ALL MY TIME AND I SHOULD'VE BEEN WRITING SOMETHING ELSE INSTEAD?!?!?!?!?!"

I'm just not used to taking on such a long-term project. I've written shorter things (essays, articles) that turned out well, but it's easier to "trust the process," when the process is over in a couple of weeks. I'd like to stop freaking out about it. 🙂

edit: Thanks for your comments and perspective! It was a relatively short freak-out, and now I'm back to editing and I'm feeling OK about it again.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Beginner Question I'm almost embarrassed to ask but: when is it "correct" to drop to a new line of text for dialogue that comes after action or description?

85 Upvotes

For example, here's how I might format text:

Nancy stormed through the building, scanning its inhabitants. Ogres, trolls, goblins met her gaze, mugs tilted lower, mouths were frozen in shock. Then, a shock of gray hair shifted towards the bathrooms. "Gerald!" Nancy screamed, jabbing a finger.

But here's how I've seen others format it:

Nancy stormed through the building, scanning its inhabitants. Ogres, trolls, goblins met her gaze, mugs tilted lower, mouths were frozen in shock. Then, a shock of gray hair shifted towards the bathrooms.

"Gerald!" Nancy screamed, jabbing a finger.

I literally just like the presentation of the dialogue on a new line less, 99/100 times - unless the paragraph has gotten quite lengthy to my sensibilities. But I don't know if I'm literally just messing up some rule of dialogue/action/paragraphing in work.

Furthering my confusion, sometimes I see authors doing either or, or a mix of both, so I don't know what rules are being engaged with to decide when to drop to a new line (if there is any).

Any help here?


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion Really Need to Stop Getting the Urge to Write at Work But Losing it When I Get Home

422 Upvotes

I find it so incredibly frustrating that I will get the urge to write while I’m working and need to be doing other things but when I get home that urge is completely gone and then I have to make myself feel like writing. Why does this happen? Is it an ADHD thing? Boredom? Just poor timing? Are there ways people have found to trick their brain into getting this urge at a time that is more reasonable for them?


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - October 20, 2026

9 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 2d ago

Advice Do any of you use boldface?

4 Upvotes

So my work has some internal turmoil. First person POV. I have the character argue within herself. I use italics to show thoughts, and sometimes I do italics and then normal to show that internal dialogue taking place.

If I want to emphasize a word within the italics, it seems boldface would work but I don't know if I've actually seen that done that I can think of.

Thoughts?


EDIT: I realized I was overdoing italics due to my work previously being third person omni. I was using italics for inner thoughts and when I moved to rotating first I didn't think about it being unneeded.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Beginner Question Bland main character?

43 Upvotes

Have you had a situation where your main character was bland and side characters seemed more interesting than him/her?

What to do then? Abandon the story? Switch the main character? Try to develop him? Something else?

EDIT: to give more context, I think that my MCs come out as bland because I tend to give them my own character traits and decisions. And as I'm rather a quiet nice guy they wound up being nice and pretty boring xD

Unfortunately more interesting are characters full of flaws: authoritative, rude, egoist, cynical, psychopathic etc. etc.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Other When trying to get back into writing, are five minute increments beneficial or a waste of time?

16 Upvotes

I used to love letting my imagination loose on paper. Though perfectionism would be my mortal enemy. Had to take a break from the pen. I am trying to get back into it, however hitting mental blocks in my process. Are smaller workloads better to build habit?


r/writing • • 4d ago

Discussion Anyone else feel like, that when you have an idea for a novel or even short story, it starts out as a small flame inside of you until you can no longer ignore it and have to write it out?

270 Upvotes

Currently experiencing this with my first novel I'm working on. What started out as a small thought has now grown into a raging fire inside of me, almost dying to be written. I'd always intended on writing it out, but it's now all I can think about. I don't even have the outline done yet, but there are scenes I keep thinking about that constantly replay inside of my head. Scenes that I KNOW I need to write out.

I fully intend on publishing the book myself too. I don't care if it doesn't do well. I just need to write this shit and then make it known lol.

But this is going to be my first actual novel and I'm trying to do it right. That said, I know I'm going to fuck some shit up just because it's my first novel. I've written and published short stories and novellas before, but those are so much easier than an actual series of books.

Anyways, anyone else feel like this?


r/writing • • 4d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - October 19, 2026

9 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 4d ago

Discussion Narrative forms/types?

31 Upvotes

I'm not quite sure if it has one, but is there a name for the way a novel is written? Not it's prose or plot structure, but its actual form? Like an epistolary novel, or any other form in which a novel exists. I can't find a name for this idea, or many examples of it. I apologize if this is a moronic question and I'm missing something obvious here, but I'm rather confused.


r/writing • • 5d ago

Discussion Since when was exposition a bad thing?

176 Upvotes

I’m seeing it more and more on critique subs when a reader what see the tiniest bit of exposition and label the next as bad because of it.

One critic said they avoid it all together! How is that possible? Exposition is necessary to provide information to your reader that enables them to piece together your story.

I feel like somewhere along the warning against bad exposition has been lost in translation and now a bunch of people see any exposition and consider a no no, even when it’s done properly.

Yes, dropping pages of pages or lore drop is a tough read that even top authors can do but that doesn’t exposition can’t be carefully woven into the story through dialogue and observation.

I feel this fits a general trend in writing circles where people warn against doing certain things (like show don’t tell) and then that gets warped to the extreme where all telling is bad and if you do it even once no one will ever ever read your story.

It becomes difficult to source genuinely good critique because nobody follows any of the rules to fault yet it seems critical readers expect that of you.

As I said, there is definitely such a thing a bad exposition. But that doesn’t mean all exposition is wrong