Inspired by Ursula K. Le Guin’s short story “The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas”
Interdimensional beings make contact with you, and tell you that they have become curious about humans. They offer a deal. In exchange for the immediate uplifting of humanity, they want a child to take back with them to their dimension.
When you ask what they mean by uplifting, they say they will provide technology several centuries ahead of what we currently have. Medical technology, technology to improve agriculture, infrastructure, transportation, recycling. They will improve Earth itself to a pristine condition perfect for continued sustainability of existing flora and fauna for the next 3000 years, despite any destructive changes humans do to the planet during that timeframe. People will become healthier, live longer, more empathetic towards others, leaders will get inspired to actually work together and commit towards a better future, and cruelty itself lessens.
To show they are capable of these things they promised, the beings wave their limbs. Immediately you find yourself cured of any minor affliction you’re currently experiencing. Your runny nose clears, the shoulder you pulled yesterday no longer hurts, and you are no longer tired, and feel energized. The browning house plant you have in the corner becomes healthy and green. Your pet, if you have one, starts acting like it’s new and young again, clear eyed, alert, and healthy. Your electronics become fully charged, and any broken appliance you have gets fixed. The beings refuse to do more than this.
When you ask about the child they’re looking for, they specify what they want. It has to be a living child between the ages of 7-10. The child doesn’t need to be in tip top shape, doesn’t need to be completely healthy and free of any complications, so a child with asthma or allergies is fine, or a child with bad eyesight, or an overweight child, etc. The child, however, needs to have active brain waves, so it can’t be a brain dead child. They will also not accept a child with a terminal illness, or a child close to dying.
When asked what they will do with the child, the beings refuse to give any details, but admit that none of it will be good, and the child will most certainly be miserable and frightened.
If you accept and choose a child, the beings will handle it, and the child will vanish with no trace. No one will ever know you were behind all of this. The child will simply be declared missing, if they have people who care about them enough to report it.
They say they will only reveal themselves to the rest of humanity if you accept and they have received the child. They are quite confident that no one will believe you anyway if you try, but that they won’t stop you if you tell others about this choice to ask for advice or for help determining who to sacrifice
The beings reassure you, saying you can refuse with no consequences. They will simply leave, but warn you that this opportunity will never be offered ever again, to anyone else for the rest of humanity’s existence. They say they will stay in this dimension until they receive a clear answer, telling you to take your time.
Will you accept the offer or refuse?
If you accept, how will you choose which child to sacrifice?