Hi all,
I’ve had black beard algae (BBA) and hair algae in my planted tank for about a year now. I’m trying to decide whether to fight it in place or do a full restart, and I’d love your opinion on both options.
Tank
- 150 x 50 x 50 cm (about 375 L), open top, set up for about 2 years
- Filter: Eheim 2217 canister, cleaned every 2 months
- Substrate: organic potting soil capped with 5 cm of basalt split
- Flow: good as far as I can tell, but I don’t know if there are dead spots
- Livestock: Neocaridina red shrimp, Amano shrimp, kuhli loaches, hillstream loaches, galaxy rasbora, Pseudomugil luminatus and harlequin rasbora. I have a second, smaller tank where I can house them while I clean the main tank.
Plants
Blyxa japonica, Rotala indica ‘Bonsai’, Alternanthera reineckii ‘Mini’, Hygrophila pinnatifida, Staurogyne repens, Pogostemon helferi, Anubias (unknown species), Anubias barteri ‘Mini Coin’, Bucephalandra diabolica ‘Kedagang’, Bolbitis heudelotii, Hydrocotyle tripartita and Monte Carlo (which grows vertically instead of carpeting).
Lighting
3 cheap LED floodlights (not aquarium lights), 6000 K, non-dimmable. Photoperiod is 5 hours. I suspect they’re not ideal for a 50 cm deep tank.
CO2 / ferts / maintenance
- CO2: 5 hours a day, starting 1 hour before the lights come on and stopping 1 hour before they go off. My drop checker is usually a little blue.
- Fertilizing: none at the moment
- Water changes: 40% once a month
The problem
BBA and hair algae on the glass, plants and hardscape, for about a year now. I wipe it off the glass but it keeps coming back. A blackout did not help. I haven’t used any algae treatments. Photos attached.
My questions
- Is this tank still salvageable, or would I be better off starting over?
- If I restart, how should I clean and sterilise everything: hardscape, substrate, filter media, canister, tubing and glass? Which methods actually kill BBA and hair algae, and how long should things dry or soak?
- Which plants are worth keeping and dipping, and which are better replaced? Do the Anubias, Bucephalandra and Bolbitis with BBA on the leaves have a chance?
- What is the most likely root cause (nutrients, CO2, light, flow), so I don’t get the same algae again after a restart?
- Any tips for moving the fish and shrimp to the small tank and back, without exposing them to treatments?
Thanks in advance for any advice!