No Bad Memories is very good!
Saying that means a lot to someone who wasn't super keen on We Will Always Love You. I thought that record had a handful of very strong moments, but overall I found it slow, morose, and "homogenous" in a style that I found a departure from what I liked about the Avalanches. Not that they aren't allowed to experiment, nor that they can't try something more ambient or sad, the way they did it just wasn't for me. I don't want to cause any trouble saying that, I'm just speaking as someone who thinks Since I Left You is the best album ever made (and Wildflower a not-far-off contender).
Meanwhile, this album is the opposite of my thoughts on WWALY: it's fast, frantic, chaotic, silly, colorful fun, with occasional dips into the wistful and melancholy. Even while sharing WWALY's modern and sleek production style, those elements felt like they're reigniting the spirit I fell in love with.
The production is interesting in how it calls back to that, too. While SILY/WF's samples are densely packed and placed in a way that you endlessly explore, this is like if you splayed that same DNA out directly in front of you, pulling it as thinly as it can stretch. You then experience everything in linear order, hurdling at lightning speed as it crashes from one proverbial memory bank to the next. Not AS amazing in idea or execution as the first two albums, mind, but a very admirable twist on the formula. And I can't blame them for taking a route like this if it means an album doesn't take 10-15 years to make, lol.
I do hope they someday try one more ultra-sampledelic masterpiece, but if the future of this group looks like experiments more in this vein, I'm interested. Consider my faith rejuvenated.
I do have my critiques though. Which are:
- The songs are extremely short. Which can be both a positive and a negative, but it sometimes leaves me wanting more. Maybe that'll be a benefit for how "superfun" this record's replay value is, just jumping in and popping a few fast tracks and hopping out whenever you want, but I do wish at least half of the better tracks were at least a minute longer. There's 31-ish tracks and it doesn't even break an hour!
- The album's concept / themes aren't very clear if you don't have the visual components or knowledge about the metanarrative walking in. I knew it all, sure, but I imagine someone who didn't will probably be a bit confused. There's one or two tracks that try to piece it together, but that leads to the next part...
- BIG grievance: For some reason Evergreen Altar is physical exclusive, and Total Recall (as well as He Lives In the Old World & El Dorado TV Spot) are digital exclusive. The former is one of the best songs on the record, and the latter tracks are some of the most thematically important (which harms the already flimsy concept!). So I find it really frustrating that there is no version of the record with every track included. I had to makeshift my own, and even that required some Audacity surgery to make sure it doesn't have any redundant parts, since they'd cut tracks but keep some of their transitions. Eugh.
- I'm not a huge fan of the "Final Credits" theme. Not that it isn't good, I love the Avvies putting some heat on a soul flip just like anyone else. But it is a little bit basic compared to the other version of I Give Everything I Have 2 U. It also gets between Total Recall and The Pavements Light, which I think together make a really resonant ending. Should have been after Pavements Light instead of before imo, like a proper bonus track I can choose to listen to on my own time. Idk.
Overall Rating: 7.5/10. Maybe an 8/10 if time makes me fonder for it.
Fav tracks: All The Time In the World, Evergreen Altar, Vida, I Give Everything I Have 2 U, The Pavements Light