r/instructionaldesign • u/Sir-weasel • 1h ago
Artcraft: an opportunity or the enemy?
I posted last week excited about these new clean room versions of the Adobe suite. I found it interesting that many instantly dismissed the project as vibe coded slop.
It turns out that's not quite true, yes they used REA and ghidra for the early build. But they are now fine tuning and the github activity is eye opening in regards to the speed they fix issues. Plus there are now a lot of human devs doing the work (such is the joy of open source). Using this hybrid method they have closed thousands of bugs, that alone is impressive considering the major players have bugs which are decades old ( cough articulate)
Another major factor that doesn't seem to be getting through the hype cycle is that these tools feature MCP so any AI can be brought to the party (avoiding Adobes token scalping)
In my mind this presents our industry with a significant opportunity. We know we are the unloved ginger step kid of the corporate world. Even our primary tool (articulate) has decided that we are all absolutely expendable and have ignored fix requests for up to a decade. Articulates pricing makes Adobes predatory pricing almost cute in comparison.
So I reached out to them on discord and they surprisingly responded. It turns out they are willing to discuss the idea of creating a multi platform open source elearning tool (they develop for mac windows and Linux by default). They had clearly considered the idea before my message. The bit I think it's genuinely exciting is the speed the tool could evolve. If they match the current bug patching pace of the other tools it wouldnt take long for the tool tool exceed articulate.
I would like to say that normally i don't talk to devs as most of the time they are trying to replace us for a quick cash in. This is where i feel this project may be fundamentally different. They are familiar with creative roles and the underlying vibe is they want to support creatives first. Yes they want people to use AI (ideally their option) but uniquely allows the user of any AI. This gives davinci resolve vibes, where the software is free but the hardware is where they make money.
So why this post? Well as with all development requests popularity pushes the project priority up.
If you dont hate this they have the discord and an app request section.