r/WarCollege • • 22h ago

Question Modern destroyers vs cruisers: The Arleigh Burkes (USA), Zumwalts (USA) Maya-class (Japanese), Sejong the Great (South Korea) and Type 55 (China) destroyers - what is the thinking with labelling them as destroyers and not as cruisers - these ones are either close to or over 10,000 tons?

81 Upvotes

For example, the Arleigh Burkes are close enough to the same weight as a Ticonderoga class cruiser.

I guess some of it could be the nitpicking of what's a "heavy destroyer" versus a "light cruiser".


r/WarCollege • • 8h ago

Question Why was the theoretical advance limit of Germany the A-A line, instead of the Urals?

34 Upvotes

In planning for Operation Barbarossa, the Germans planned for the limit of their advance to be the A-A line, roughly from Arkhangelsk to Astrakhan. While part of this line was defended by the Volga River, much of this line was not anchored on any geographic features of significance

However, "just" a few hundred kilometers further East was such a feature that would cover almost the entire front, with the exception of the semi-desert of the Kazak steppe - the Ural Mountains. An eventual line based on the Urals would also capture significant Soviet industrial centers, and put many others within bomber range

Obviously none of this ended up mattering - but why was the furthest limit of the Nazi advance expected to be the fairly arbitrary A-A line, vs the Urals?


r/WarCollege • • 11h ago

Question What made it so that sailor landing parties as infantry, despite still being common through the interwar in smaller ones, didn't just become a secondary element of but were absent from the major amphibious assaults of WW2?

25 Upvotes

I understand why normal infantry in dedicated ships took the lead, amphibious assaults became a lot larger and needed a lot more specialised equipment, while sailor landing parties couldn't really sustain themselves for more than a few days on land and lacked heavy equipment.

but what was the downside in having a few extra battalions or regiments of infantry to help with the first few days of a landing when integrated within the combined arms systems of larger army/marine dominated landing force that meant they seemingly very suddenly just stopped being a thing?


r/WarCollege • • 18h ago

Question Why didn't the ROK Marines create their own Commando units after the Royal Marine 41st Commando?

4 Upvotes

Since the 41st was the only Royal Marine that fought during the Korean War, where they raided the North Korean coast with the Republic of Korea Marine Corps, I wonder what prevented the ROKMC forming a unit similar to the commandos?

I do know that they were base on the USMC but surely there would have been an attempt.


r/WarCollege • • 21h ago

Question Does tactical doctrine influence the direction of technological developments in war or vice versa?

0 Upvotes

It is probably both but which influences the other one more substantially? For example in WW2 trench warfare is much less dominant than WW1, this is a result of developments in mechanised forces with radios, airborne forces, and artillery. However are these advancements made with the goal of counteracting trench warfare in mind, or are they natural results of increased productivity and scientific findings which caused trench warfare to be outdated?