Title: My nanny is very loving with my baby, but she’s disrespectful of boundaries, doesn’t follow instructions, and I no longer trust her. Am I overreacting?
I’ve had a nanny for the past two months. She came recommended by a friend’s nanny, and she’s originally from the same country as me, although we currently live in the US.
She’s very sweet, loving, and affectionate with my 1-year-old daughter, which is why I’m struggling so much with this situation.
However, there are several things that have been bothering me.
First, she’s extremely disorganized and messy. She leaves hair everywhere (I shed hair too, so I understand, but she doesn’t bother cleaning it up). She’ll even fold my baby’s clean clothes with hairs stuck between them. When she prepares meals for my daughter, she leaves the kitchen a complete mess for hours. Her excuse is always that she’s busy taking care of the baby, but I’m a stay-at-home mom and spend a significant amount of time with my daughter throughout the day, including after meals. So it’s not like she’s constantly watching the baby with no opportunity to clean up.
But honestly, the mess isn’t even my biggest concern. I feel like that’s something I could address.
My biggest issue is her lack of manners, professionalism, and respect for personal boundaries.
She has a very strong, loud personality, and while I have absolutely nothing against someone being outgoing or cheerful, I feel like she has no sense of what’s appropriate when working in someone else’s home.
She’s constantly dancing around the apartment, even when my husband, my mother, or my in-laws are around. She plays loud music while cooking, despite us living in a small apartment. If I’m FaceTiming my parents, she’ll start FaceTiming her daughter right next to me, speaking extremely loudly, or she’ll put on music without considering that I’m on a call.
She also constantly interrupts conversations I’m having with my husband, inserts herself into private discussions, and sometimes behaves as though she’s part of conversations that have absolutely nothing to do with her.
I feel like she doesn’t understand basic social boundaries or professional etiquette. There’s a level of familiarity she assumes with me and my family that I’m simply not comfortable with.
I want to have a warm, friendly relationship with the person caring for my daughter, but I also expect a certain level of respect, discretion, and professionalism in my own home.
I don’t think she’s intentionally trying to be disrespectful, but I do think she lacks basic manners and social awareness. I genuinely don’t know how to bring this up without making her feel like I’m attacking who she is as a person. And unlike cleaning or organization, I don’t know if these are things you can really teach someone.
But here’s what worries me the most: she doesn’t always follow my instructions regarding my daughter.
For example, the other day I specifically told her NOT to bathe my baby and to give her 4 mL of medicine. I stepped out, and my husband called to tell me she was bathing her anyway and had almost given her 8 mL of medicine. DOUBLE the amount I had instructed.
Thankfully, my husband was right there and stopped her. He had actually been keeping a closer eye on things because he knows I’ve been unhappy with her performance.
And that’s where I feel like I’ve reached my limit.
I hired a nanny to make my life easier and give me some peace of mind, but instead, I feel more stressed than ever. I constantly have to supervise her, repeat instructions, correct things, and double-check everything. I don’t feel comfortable leaving her alone with my daughter anymore.
It’s gotten to the point where I’m losing sleep over this. I feel uncomfortable in my own home, and every day feels mentally exhausting because I can’t fully relax or trust her to handle things independently.
She’s affectionate and loving toward my daughter, and I know how important that is. But I also believe that being loving isn’t enough if someone doesn’t respect your boundaries, follow instructions, or demonstrate good judgment.
Am I being too demanding? Is it reasonable to expect a nanny to have a certain level of manners, discretion, and professionalism, or am I expecting too much?
Would you sit her down and try to address these issues, or would you accept that she’s simply not the right fit for your family?
I’d really appreciate some honest opinions from other parents, especially those who have dealt with something similar.