Was a roadie for 5 years. Did occasional/casual MTB but never got super into it. I found it hard and liked the smooth cadence of the road.
Well, last few months I've been compelled to get off the road. Reasons:
- CARS. I hate them. They hate me. Shoulders are nonexistent or not wide enough. I live in the south where big trucks and coal rolling are commonplace. It's stressful always having someone up your ass.
-Dogs. Again, in the south, getting chased by aggressive dogs is not unusual.
-Heat. On the road you are just roasting in the hot sun pretty much the whole time. It wears on you during the summer.
-Grind. Road can be fun, dont get me wrong, but 80% of it is grind.
-Discomfort. Because you are sitting and pitched forward almost the whole time, road is tolerable at best and miserable after about 90 mins. Yeah I know---saddle, bike fit, blah blah blah. There is only so much comfort to be found from sitting on a saddle bent forward with your neck in extension for hours on end.
MTB has none of these. No cars, no dogs, you are out in the woods with plenty of shade, you ride upright and are out of the saddle constantly. Yeah it can be hard but the skills element adds a lot of progression and the hard stuff gets more fun.
The main drawback is that for most of us, we have to drive to get to trailheads. But it's worth it, IMO.