r/MLBTheShow • • 20h ago

The Dugout The Dugout! ⚾: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow - week of October 16, 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to The Dugout! ⚾

The Weekly Free-Talk Thread for r/MLBTheShow

Welcome to The Dugout, your weekly home for questions, gameplay advice, pack pulls, Community Market discussions, and everything else MLB The Show!

The Dugout also serves as a community resource hub, with helpful links to FAQs, technical support, and other useful information.

Please review the guidelines below before creating a dedicated post. Our goal is to encourage meaningful discussion while keeping repetitive and low-effort content in one convenient place.

What qualifies as a dedicated post in r/MLBTheShow?

Dedicated posts should encourage meaningful discussion, share original content, or showcase something noteworthy.

  • Diamond Dynasty: News, strategies, program updates, analysis, and meaningful discussions.
  • Player Cards: New card reveals, detailed reviews, comparisons, and discussions. Please search for existing posts before creating a new one.
  • Gameplay Screenshots and Videos: Interesting gameplay clips, screenshots, and highlights. Please use your console's built-in capture and sharing features only. Photos of television screens may be removed.
  • Franchise, RTTS, and Other Modes: Meaningful discussions, discoveries, guides, and original content.
  • Polls: Include sufficient context to encourage meaningful discussion rather than simple yes-or-no questions.
  • Memes and Humor: Keep content original, tasteful, and relevant to MLB The Show.
  • Appreciation Posts: Share your appreciation for favorite players, developers, memorable experiences, and even Ramone!
  • Significant Achievements: Flawless Battle Royale runs, first-time World Series rankings, exceptional discoveries, Top 50 placements, and other noteworthy accomplishments.

Please search for existing discussions before creating a new post about a recently covered topic.

Please use The Dugout for these types of posts:

  • Community Market and Stubs: Buying, selling, flipping, investments, pricing questions, and stub-making advice.
  • Pack Pulls and Routine Accomplishments: Show off your pulls, rewards, program completions, and everyday achievements.
  • Lineup and Player Advice: Ask for lineup recommendations, squad improvements, and player comparisons. Please include your lineup, available stubs, game mode, and what specifically you're looking to improve.
  • Simple Questions and Gameplay Help: Beginner questions, settings, tutorials, basic troubleshooting, and anything that doesn't warrant a dedicated discussion.
  • Rants and Complaints: Frustrated with an opponent, bad animation, or heartbreaking loss? Share your frustrations here, but keep discussions civil.
  • Custom League Advertisements: Share your league settings, requirements, and joining instructions here. You may also use r/findacustomleague. Standalone league advertisements are not permitted.
  • Finding Opponents and Teammates: Looking for someone to play against or team up with? Connect with other players here.
  • Self-Promotion: Have a blog, YouTube channel, or stream? Active community members may share relevant content here. Repeated promotions, spam, and unsolicited advertising are prohibited.
  • Concept Cards: Share your concepts here and follow the Concept Card Guidelines.
  • Custom Stadiums: Share your creations here or visit our affiliated subreddit, r/mlbtheshowstadiums.
  • Other Casual Discussion: Anything related to MLB The Show that doesn't require its own dedicated post.

A few additional reminders:

Helpful resources to use before posting

  1. Search First: Have you used Reddit Search or tried Google?
  2. Official FAQ: MLB The Show Frequently Asked Questions
  3. Community Resources: Our r/MLBTheShow FAQ and Guide.
  4. PlayStation Network Status: Check for outages HERE.
  5. Discord Community: Join our official r/MLBTheShow Discord.
  6. Technical Support: Visit the Technical and Server Issues Megathread.

Community Guidelines

Please treat other community members respectfully, including those who are new to the game. Disagreements are welcome, but personal attacks, harassment, and intentionally disruptive behavior are not.

These guidelines are not exhaustive and are subject to moderator discretion on a case-by-case basis. If you believe a post or comment requires moderator attention, please use Reddit's report function so the moderation team can review it.

Enjoy the discussion, and welcome to The Dugout! ⚾


r/MLBTheShow • • 6d ago

Comparison First Annual r/MLBTheShow Finest Awards: Vote for Your Top 3 Cards of 2026!

3 Upvotes

First Annual r/MLBTheShow 2026 Finest Awards

Which currently existing player cards from this year's game deserve to be remembered as this year’s finest?

Post your top 3 players in MLB The Show 26 in the comments in any order. Any position is eligible. Whether they carried your squad or always came through in the clutch, we want to hear your picks!

Please include the specific card version so we know exactly who you’re voting for.

Voting runs for 10 days, from October 10 through October 20. Once voting closes, I’ll tally the number of times a card is mentioned and announce the cards in order of most votes received. The results and awards will be permanently enshrined on the subreddit!

Early Finest Awards update 10/12/26: Andruw Jones and Nick Sogard are tied for first with 7 votes each! Jesus Made follows with 6, and Yordan Alvarez has 4. So far, 35 counted ballots have produced 99 player votes across 56 different players. Voting remains open through October 20, so there’s still plenty of time to get your top three in!


r/MLBTheShow • • 15h ago

First Look Brewers vs Dodgers Program Reward Attributes

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

Collect 32 Postseason cards to unlock Jake Bauers


r/MLBTheShow • • 13h ago

Question Why do a lot of the new negro league legends have such bad attributes?

13 Upvotes

I was hyped for 99 Suttles the whole year and he barely has over 100 contact to both sides and a lot less power than I expected. That's not even mentioning how they nuked Willard Brown from orbit. These Guys (and gal) are supposed to bring some hype to the game and yet their Diamond Dynasty attributes never seem to be good. It just doesn't make sense that you bring in all these new legends for franchise and DD and they just aren't good most the time


r/MLBTheShow • • 1h ago

RTTS Is your team nerfed in RTTS regardless of your performance?

• Upvotes

I have joined the Brewers roster after half a season in AA and a season in AAA. In the three teams I feel that while having good rosters (2nd best pitching and top10 defense in AAA, and 7th best team overall in the Brewers) once I join the team starts performing poorly.

With the Brewers we were 2nd in the conference, 30-26, since I joined we are now 32-31. My hitting is good, in just a couple weeks I have a bunch of RBIs, around 0.300 average, no fielding mistakes. But for the last 4 games we have conceded +7 runs on the first two innings, without me playing any defense, so it's not that I make fielding mistakes that lead to the AI scoring against us.

Last four games results:

7-9 (7 runs conceded in the first two innings, 1 more in the third inning)

3-12 (11 f*ing runs conceded in the first three innings)

2-8 (7 runs conceded in the first two innings, again)

4-11 (7 runs conceded in the first two innings, not only again but third time in four games we concede 3 in the first inning and 4 in the second inning)

It feels like the game is adjusting for my overall (72 at 19yo, 4th prospect overall) or something like that. Is this the regular experience?


r/MLBTheShow • • 15h ago

Question Your favorite card everyone says is bad?

Post image
9 Upvotes

I love switching it up every now and then and using cards that are underrated or hated. Val’s vision is low and got dumped on but when I used him and put a Contact/Contact mod on him I was going crazy with him hitting like .700 on HoF and Legend. I’m down to .619 with him right now but I still get excited every time it’s his turn to bat.


r/MLBTheShow • • 10h ago

Question How to be an utility player?

3 Upvotes

As the title says, how do I play as an utility player in rtts? I often get bored playing the same position, and would like to play multiple with the same player, is it possible?


r/MLBTheShow • • 7h ago

Discussion Any Chance they drop another king felix card

1 Upvotes

I love Felix but can’t afford the LS collection


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

News 99 Jake Bauers incoming. Your NLCS MVP.

80 Upvotes

The power on this is gonna be cracked...with probably 85 Vision because obviously.


r/MLBTheShow • • 20h ago

Question NLCS Program Release?

8 Upvotes

Do we think they get the NLCS Program out today at some point or likely next week since it’s end of the week?

EDIT: Program just dropped.

99 Evan Phillips
99 Kyle Tucker
99 David Hamilton
99 Aaron Ashby

99 Jake Bauers via Postseason Collection


r/MLBTheShow • • 19h ago

Discussion Do you guys thing they'll make a new program with deluxe packs???

7 Upvotes

Hey y'all I know the game is kinda dead player count wise but I still like doing the programs and mini seasons and all that fun stuff while watching shows in the background. Anyways I been terrible with opening packs but I'm currently sitting on 39 Regular Choose Deluxe Packs, 7 of the gold ones(forgot what they're called) and 4 ultras. I have most of the collections done only like 2 away from getting Zobrist but I was wondering should I cash these out or you think they'll make one last program utilizing the deluxe packs?


r/MLBTheShow • • 12h ago

Franchise I do not like Franchise this year

1 Upvotes

I have gotten MLB The Show pretty much every year and this has to be the worst Franchise in terms of trading players. Scouting is fine and roster management is good. But not being able to tell if a team likes my trade proposals just sucks. I hate having to wait a day or two to see if the trade makes sense for the AI. I like the untouchables additions as there are franchise players that shouldn’t be traded. But last year’s just made it easier and simpler for me.


r/MLBTheShow • • 10h ago

Question Getting nerfed by the AI

0 Upvotes

Probably been asked before, but does anybody else get the feeling that the AI on franchise mode just starts cheating when you’re in a streak. Like out of nowhere great pitchers will hang out breaking balls in early innings, fielders start botching routine balls, swings with good timing and contact either pop up or head directly to an opposing fielder. Am I crazy or is this game messing with me?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Funny I was throwing to first regardless 😂😂

61 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Meme Sometimes You Actually Feel Sorry For SDS

Post image
224 Upvotes

I bet now they wish they put better cards into the NLDS.


r/MLBTheShow • • 20h ago

Question Rtts baserunning messing up

1 Upvotes

In mlb 26 rtts, I am having a problem with base running. I’ll b holding the analog down, as if I’m running extra bases, and all the sudden my player will just stop and return to the past base. It’s caused me to get out multiple times. Idk what Im doing wrong. Nothing I’ve searched has talked about this


r/MLBTheShow • • 8h ago

PSA Why are the Division series + ranked players all pitching the same annoying way. Y’all should be ashamed…

0 Upvotes

I’m an average wildcard league player and I play the game casually, and I hate when I break into division series, because you all pitch the same way… inside sinker/outside fastball only! I’m just trying to enjoy playing and yall just suck the fun right out of the game. It can’t even be fun to pitch that way, there’s no challenge… change your ways please.

Sincerely,
Everyone in the wildcard league


r/MLBTheShow • • 13h ago

Comparison Which game out of the three is your favorite?

0 Upvotes

Which game between MLB 22,24, and 25 do you Ike the best?


r/MLBTheShow • • 11h ago

Question How is LS Ohtani a red diamond still?

0 Upvotes

Hurt or not dude has been straight buns for a while now and he’s not pitching. Now they’re adjusting him to a 97?! Tf is SDS smoking?


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

Discussion The drop rate for the new Bobby Witt Jr from a standard show pack is 0.007%

59 Upvotes

He is more rare than live series Ohtani (0.01%).

https://mlb26.theshow.com/drop_rates?pack_id=10222


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Funny This game is a master of trolling

8 Upvotes

Started a game at 770, thinking I was about to reach World Series the first time ever. I played against a real 99 and won on a walk off home run in the 10th. Legit the most hyped I’ve ever been after a win and…799.

I swear this game to be trolling, definitely losing my next game for sure 😂


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Should I just go ahead and open all my Ultra, Deluxe, and Choice Packs now? No more new programs coming, right?

2 Upvotes

Since we're pretty late into the game's lifecycle, I wanted to ask.
At this point, we aren't getting any more new programs or major content drops, right?
I’ve been hoarding my Ultra Packs, Deluxe Packs, and various Choice Packs for a while now... Is it safe to just rip them all open at this point? Or is there any reason to keep holding onto them?
Would love to hear your thoughts/advice!


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Franchise Franchise Mode Fantasy Draft

1 Upvotes

When did the computer become so good at drafting?

I thought the computer would draft strictly by overall meanwhile I was gonna draft strictly young guys in their early-mid 20s like Henderson, Caminero, Kurtz, PCA, etc but the computer seems to know it should draft younger guys also for franchise longevity.


r/MLBTheShow • • 23h ago

Suggestion For SDS Options for solving the Quitting "Problem"

0 Upvotes

1) Anyone quitting a H2H hame banned from the game for three years. Children and any future children banned from MLB the Show. Fined $100,000. Ramone comes to your house/apartment and breaks both your kneecaps with a ball peen hammer. Grandmother kidnapped by SDS and forced to spend a year playtesting.

2) Base H2H rewards overwhelmingly on winning individual games, not accumulating stats.


r/MLBTheShow • • 2d ago

PSA PSA - You can knock out the new programs with the same roster at once

72 Upvotes

I loaded up Moonshot mini season for easy pitchers and knocked the programs out really fast even just on All Star but play whatever you want

  • ASG Mcgonigle - 3B
  • Basallo - c
  • ASG Witt - SS
  • Spotlight Bryce Eldridge - RF
  • ASG Sal Stewart - 1B
  • Wetherholt - 2B
  • Spotlight Konnor Griffin - LF
  • WBC Julio r - CF

And then just pitch Skenes, Chase Burns, and Yesavage