r/JETProgramme • u/Valuable-Custard-890 • 8h ago
Is it unreasonable to deny a class a game/activity because of their behavior?
I teach first-year JHS students, and the English classes are split into two groups based on proficiency (higher and lower level). Personally, I have mixed feelings about this system because I feel like the additional workload involved in preparing separate lessons doesn’t always translate into meaningful progress for the students, especially when some seem to remain at the same level. However, I still try to personalize my lessons and make them engaging since the smaller class sizes give me more opportunities to work with the students individually.
The problem is that one of these groups has been particularly difficult to manage. Some students frequently talk over me, make rude comments (in Japanese and they think I don’t understand), and generally struggle to follow instructions. I’ve had to stop lessons and address their behavior a few times. I’m not particularly harsh with them, but I have told them that their behavior is immature and that I’m not going to continue speaking over them if they refuse to listen.
Recently, my JTE asked me to prepare a Halloween game for the class. Honestly, I’m reluctant to do so because I don’t feel that the class has been making an effort to participate respectfully during regular lessons. Part of me feels that giving them a fun activity regardless of how they behave sends the message that they can disrupt lessons and still expect a reward afterward.
At the same time, I understand that games can be useful for language learning, and I know not every student in the class is necessarily responsible for the behavior of their classmates. I also realize that I’m the ALT, so there may be cultural and professional considerations I’m not fully accounting for.
I’m curious about a few things:
•Is it unreasonable to feel that a class should demonstrate basic respect and cooperation before getting a special game or activity?
•Would you consider withholding a Halloween game a reasonable consequence, or would you approach the situation differently?
•How do you handle classes that are disruptive during regular lessons but are suddenly expected to participate in fun seasonal activities?
•If you were in my position, would you still run the game as planned, modify it, or discuss an alternative with the JTE?
I’m not trying to be overly strict or punish students just for being teenagers. I just don’t want to feel like I’m rewarding behavior that makes it difficult for everyone else to learn.
I’d appreciate hearing how others would handle this, especially those with experience teaching JHS students