I've been considering getting EMDR treatment for several years now. For full disclosure, I have not been to counseling or done any professional talk therapy. I have read and listened to several self-help resources and done a lot of writing which has helped me sort through many of my issues and achieve some progress. My reasons for postponing formal treatment include both cost and feeling a bit lost in terms of finding a good, experienced therapist - I might be completely wrong in thinking this, but many of the counseling/therapy/EMDR places in my area have incredibly woo-woo names like "Whispering Rivers Therapy" or "Astrology Sisters Counseling" (these aren't real names, just sort of the gist of what the places in my area are called, and maybe I'm wrong to think this way, but it's hard for me to take anything with a name like that seriously).
As for my background, I grew up in a family with enmeshment and narcissism. My immediate family was very dysfunctional yet close-knit - anyway, plenty of issues from my past involving them, and although I am employed, married, and moved away on my own and approaching 40 years old (and taken steps to set some boundaries and move on from things, though I could probably use guidance and outside input in this area), I still struggle with a few things:
Unconscious or subconscious stress. I'm not sure if that's the correct terminology here, but in essence, I often find myself holding onto physical tension, and experiences from my past frequently show up in my mind out of nowhere, even though it seems like those things should be resolved or behind me. Despite feeling like I "should" be over something, I still find myself with constant tension, unable to relax. One part of this that causes major problems for me is when I get some time off to relax, or when it's time to sleep, some part of my brain decides, "oh, we're not busy and stressed right now, now is the time to deal with those pesky ruminating stressful past experiences!" So my "relaxing time" never ends up helping me recover or feel truly rested, if that makes any sense.
Frequent rumination and what feels like intrusive thoughts about experiences from my past. Fortunately or unfortunately, I have a job that is mentally passive enough that I frequently find my mind wandering. Much of the time, my mind lands on processing my past. I've come to accept that I'll never get closure or my desired outcome for many things that happened in my past, but despite that it feels like some part of my brain latches onto that possibility, hence the intrusive rumination. I find it difficult to focus on building a better, productive future in my life because the past tends to live rent free in my mind, despite me knowing that there's nothing I can do to change that, and ruminating is counterproductive and a waste of my energy and time, at best.
Delayed processing of trauma. I used to experience depersonalization in childhood and adolescence and luckily this is something that rarely happens to me anymore, unless I find myself in an exceptionally intense situation. Most recently with the loss of one of my parents, I got into an argument with another family member, who brandished a firearm in my presence and implied a threat to both of our lives - in this instance, I briefly experienced depersonalization but quickly came out of it. Shortly after the experience, I found myself basically shoving down the actual trauma of this situation so I could function throughout the day, and then not being able to sleep at all that night since I had "pretended to be okay" right after that experience. I honestly don't know how else to deal with things like that at this point in my life since I don't really have a choice in "forcing myself to be okay" to function, go to work, pay bills, be responsible, etc. but I feel that this "coping mechanism" I have is taking its toll on me in other ways and will catch up to me later on.
For anxiety, I have tried breathing exercises with very limited success. I have not tried any prescription medications and would prefer to avoid that route. I have found a bit of help with some supplements such as L-Theanine or Holy Basil.
As stated before, I have not yet tried talk therapy as I'm very skeptical of places with names like "Flower Child Mental Health Services" or whatever (again, maybe I'm wrong to feel this way). I also worry that talk therapy might have the potential to go on for long periods of time without being especially productive, which is why I'm a bit more inclined to try EMDR.
My question is, with the above symptoms, is it advisable for me to try to go straight to EMDR? Or is it more advisable to go through some talk therapy first? And if so, around what duration of talk therapy is recommended before trying EMDR?
I'm also interested to know the experiences of those who have had success with EMDR, or those who wished they hadn't had it. I appreciate all perspectives on this. Thank you in advance for any advice!