r/AITApod • u/Green_Discussion_172 • 16h ago
AITA for telling my SIL her new bridesmaid can have my dress once someone pays me for it?
So my sister-in-law took me out of her bridal party last Sunday, less than a month before her wedding, and now she wants my dress for the girl who’s replacing me.
She asked me to be a bridesmaid back in April and I said yes right away, we’ve always gotten along fine. In June the other girls and I went to the bridal shop together and I paid $230 for the dress, which is this burnt orange color because the wedding’s Halloween weekend.
On Sunday she called and said she was “going in a different direction” with the bridal party. Her fiancé’s sister wanted to be in it and they needed even numbers with the groomsmen for the pictures, so somebody had to go and apparently it was me. I was hurt but I told her okay, it’s her wedding.
Since the shop can’t order another one in time and her fiancé’s sister is “basically your size,” she texted me Monday asking me to drop my dress off at her place this weekend because I “won’t need it anymore anyway.” I texted back that the new bridesmaid can have it once I’m paid back. I bought that dress with MY money for a spot I don’t have anymore.
She offered me $100 for it instead, because I’d “already gotten some use out of it” at the fittings. I’ve worn that dress exactly twice, both times standing on a little box while a lady pinned the hem.
On Wednesday night her fiancé’s sister messaged me herself and she was really sweet about it. She said nobody had told her I paid for the dress myself. She sent me the full $230 before I even answered, and she came by for the dress yesterday after work.
Last night my SIL found out and texted me to send the $230 back to her fiancé’s sister. She says she’ll pay me herself “after the honeymoon.”
AITA?