r/vegan • u/TechnicalRock8045 • 7h ago
Disturbing I'm a passionate angler, help me with my moral dilemma
Hi everyone, I want to preface this by saying that I'm not vegan yet, but I'm extremely troubled with my choices.
I'm a passionate angler. Fishing is one of the biggest passions in my life, and I genuinely don't know what I'd do without it. To be completely honest, fishing saved me from suicide. It gave me something to look forward to, a reason to get outside, something to work towards, and something that made life feel worth living again. I'm not exaggerating when I say that it's had that much of an impact on me.
But lately, I've been struggling with the ethics of eating animals, and I've pretty much been sold on veganism. The more I think about it, the harder it becomes to justify killing animals for something as trivial as taste, especially when we have perfectly viable alternatives.
And here's where my dilemma begins.
I love fishing. I love everything about it, from researching species and learning their behaviour to choosing the right tackle, reading the conditions, working a lure, and finally getting that bite. There's something incredibly special about being out on the water, connecting with nature, and putting your knowledge and skills to the test. It's not just a way to get food for me. It's a huge part of my life.
But I can't help wondering how much of that enjoyment comes at the expense of the fish. They don't choose to participate in this. They experience stress, injury, and potentially pain, all for my enjoyment. Even if I practise catch and release, I'm still deliberately putting a living animal through that experience purely because I find it fun. And if I keep the fish, I'm ending its life for something I don't actually need.
I've tried to think of ways to justify it. Fishing is more sustainable than industrial fishing, I can eat what I catch rather than buy meat from factory farms, fish are killed by predators in nature all the time, and I can do my best to minimise suffering. But the more I think about these arguments, the more I feel like I'm just looking for excuses to keep doing something I love.
The fact that fishing has helped me so much makes this even harder. I don't want to give up something that has genuinely helped me stay alive, but I also don't want to use that as an excuse to disregard the interests of other sentient beings. My own suffering matters, but surely theirs does too?
I'm not looking for people to tell me what I want to hear, and I'm not here to argue against veganism. I genuinely want to understand how other vegans would approach this situation.
Are there any anglers here who have made the transition to veganism? How did you reconcile your love for fishing with your ethics? Did you give it up entirely, switch to catch and release, or find another way to engage with the hobby?
And for those of you who aren't anglers, how would you approach this dilemma? Is there a morally defensible way to continue fishing, or am I kidding myself by trying to find one?
I really want to do the right thing here. I just wish the right thing didn't seem to involve giving up something that has meant so much to me.