I am currently in London, and I have around a week where I am free. I am looking to travel somewhere in Scotland from the dates of November 9th through the 14th.
I really want to visit a unique place, with a cool landscape, but also a small town(s) to hang out in as well. I will be traveling by myself. Orkney (staying in Kirkwall) has really caught my attention, because it seems like such a special and unique place, both historically (neolithic sites) and nature-wise. If I go, I would plan on flying in from London to Kirkwall on Monday evening (via Aberdeen) and flying out on Saturday from Kirkwall at 11:30 am. I would do this because it is roughly the same price (maybe slightly pricier) than boat + train, but also takes way less time and also more reliable. On the island, I would plan on renting (hiring?) a cycle (probably electric) to get around the island (in addition to buses), as I am from the US and 20 years old so I am not comfortable driving.
I really want to go to Orkney, but I also understand the weather. A lot of people have told me the weather is going to suck, and daylight is hard, which I understand and I am ready to cope with and I think will also be part of the experience. I am a little bit more worried about the weather impacting my travel to and from Orkney, as well as going in the winter season.
I understand some things may also be closed, such as the Skaill House and Bishop's Palace, but I am hoping that it is still worth it to go. Additionally, I understand that, while rare, plane cancellations are rare, and have built in an extra day in case I get stuck on the islands (I don't need to be back in London until Monday evening).
However, this has also made me consider other options, specifically Avimore & Carigorms, as well as Glasgow. For Glasgow, I have thought about basing myself there then exploring the city, as well as taking day trips to places like Isle of Arran and Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park. While these seem like great places to visit, my impression is that Orkney is a step above. But, I am looking for advice.
Ideally, I just stay in one place for all five nights, so I would likely just do one of these. I am looking for advice: is it better to go to the "higher risk" option and go to Orkney, or the safer option of somewhere on the UK mainland and not have to worry about being stuck? Or is going to Scotland as a whole not feasible at all and I should look at a different destination entirely?
Thank you all for your help. I really appreciate it.