r/teslore • u/jenkind1 • 1h ago
Vignar Gray-Mane is a much more interesting character than I thought.
I like reading into various characters backstories and motivations. I recently restarted Skyrim after the new update, and I'm going through the normal beginner stuff like running to Whiterun. I passed by Olfina Gray-Mane on my way to Jorrvaskr, and noticed for the first time that she had a similar name to Olfrid Battle-Born. Given the clans past friendship, I wondered if she had been named in honor of him.
If you ask Vignar Gray-Mane about the Companions he will say this:
"They used to be something. Nowadays they just squabble amongst themselves. Take my advice and keep away. You look too smart to get caught up with this bunch."
Brill will tell you that Vignar is just an old man that likes to complain. But it seems like he's actively warning you away from the Companions due to the current internal debate over lycanthropy. Kodlak is desperate about finding the cure, so he can escape Hircine and go to Sovngarde, while the devoutly religious Vignar apparently doesn't need the cure (suggesting that he didn't partake in the beast blood ritual).
When asked about the Battle-Borns, Vignar has a few lines that show he still respects the Battle-Borns and laments their lost friendship.
"We Gray-Manes have been feuding with the Battle-Borns for years. There's no more bitter enemy than an old friend."
"Aye, they're an old clan like ours, but they cast their lot with the Empire when the uprising began. Olfrid Battle-Born made his money from farming, an' got himself some new friends among the Empire's nobles. Now he's in the Emperor's pocket like the rest of 'em, with no regard for honor an' tradition."
"Aye, we used to be fast friends, though it was long ago. We were two of the city's oldest an' most-respected clans, an' we could trace our histories all the way back to Ysgramor's companions. But then Olfrid got rich an' decided he an his kin were too good for us simple, backwards Nord folk. When the troubles began, he took the Empire's side. We haven't spoken much since then."
Notice how Vignar's lines are much more respectful than Olfrid's explanation of the feud. Olfrid is much more dismissive of the Gray-Manes. He also claims that Vignar is jealous of his wealth. However, the Gray-Manes only criticize their wealth in terms of being corrupt and snobbish, which they are on both accounts (Olfrid is a Thieves Guild contact).
"Uncivilized, pelt-wearing axe-draggers. It's a wonder they don't still live in a cave like those ancestors they keep boasting about. It's true the Vignar Gray-Mane and his lot are one of Whiterun's oldest and, depending on who you ask, most respected clans. I don't dispute that. But it's one thing to take pride in your lineage, and another to cling blindly to the past. What they call honor and tradition, I call ignorance."
"Money, you laggard! What else? It always comes down to coin. The Gray-Manes have deep roots in Whiterun, but so do we. Difference is, we're rich, and Vignar hates it. Oh, and they hate it, too. All their big talk of pride and honor, and what have they got to show for it? Beggar's rags and stale bread. We've got the same pride, the same honor, and we've got wealth. No wonder they envy us."
If you ask Olfrid about Thorald's disappearance, he is mostly dismissive.
"What's there to say? You go against the Empire, you wind up dead. Thorald got what was coming to him. Best not to ask too many questions about it. People might get the wrong idea about you."
Meanwhile, his son actually has this to say:
"Between the two of us, his family is better off thinking he's dead. Thorald and I have a history, all right? We used to be friends. So I looked into it when he disappeared. I found out the Thalmor have him. And they don't let anyone go. So I've kept my mouth shut. Like I said, his family is better off believing he's gone, because he's never coming back"
Both of them harass Thorald's poor mother and taunt her about her son never coming back, but only one of them has any justification for it.
Additionally, none of the Battle-Born children appear to be named after the Gray-Manes.
I think this would suggest that Vignar and Eorlund valued the friendship with the Battle-Borns much more than Olfrid did.