As an Original Series Trekkie, who discovered Star Trek as a kid through reruns of TOS in the 80s, I didn’t expect to like Starfleet Academy; both the poster and trailer confirmed this, as did the first episode. It wasn’t until the end of the third episode that Academy clicked for me, but from the fourth episode onwards, it began to surprise and delight me.
With so much of the talk around Starfleet Academy centered on whether it is or isn’t Star Trek, I have found myself trying to break down exactly why it works for me as a TOS Trekkie. I can not speak for other TOS Trekkies, but there are quantifiable traits of Starfleet Academy that I find resonate with similar traits I found and loved in The Original Series.
Creative Use of Camera and Lighting
While I recognise there are many in our fanbase who prefer the more unobtrusive shooting style of the Berman Era, I love the creative use of camera and lighting in The Original Series. This creative approach is reflected throughout the first season of Starfleet Academy, translated for a modern audience through use of contemporary technique; the cadets are cast in silhouette against backdrops of vivid color; fever dream accelerations and a tapestry of graphics place us in the photonic world of SAM; and lofi textures of subspace feeds trade contrasting blows with higher concept renderings.
All The Tools in The Actor’s Toolbox
Television and Cinema represent a barren landscape for the wealth of tools readily available at an Actor’s disposal. I have always loved that Star Trek is so often an exception to this. The acting in evidence within the episodes of The Original Series, drew upon an exceptional range of acting techniques. In this too, Starfleet Academy delivers. From Paul Giamatti's chaotic rage-fest space pirate and weird wordsmith, Nus Braka, to Holly Hunter’s wondrously organic physical flow and seasoned cosmic hippy, rebel-spirit-undiminished, Nahla Ake.
Theatricality and Surrealism
One of the aspects of The Original Series I love the most, is the striking and unhinged theatricality, and disquieting surrealism. Once again Starfleet Academy successfully augments these two aspects into its fundamental DNA. This is most in evidence in the breathtakingly beautiful, ‘The Life of Stars’, where the play ‘Our Town’ is woven into the fabric of the episode, and the characters arcs of Tarima, SAM, and The Doctor; the episode rendered in sweeping lyrical passages, by tastefully judged use of surrealist colour, light, and frame.
It Doesn’t Take Itself Too Seriously
I am of the opinion that Star Trek is a pretentious show. It is, after all, trying to make the world a better place and us, its audience, better people. Equally, I am of the opinion that The Original Series (and TNG for that matter) understood very well the great value of comedy in lightening the load of that pretension. Starfleet Academy understands this too. Not to say that every joke lands for me (I don’t understand how a cadet swallows a combadge either), but that Academy understands the necessity of comedy in its methodology.
Science-Based Worldview
The worldview of The Original Series is consistently science-based throughout and I feel very strongly that this is how Star Trek should always be. A show that places morality at its heart while maintaining a science-based worldview is rare. To my mind, it is this rarity that makes up much of Star Trek’s value within our social cultural landscape. Starfleet Academy maintains a science-based worldview throughout its first season, from Bajoran Wormhole Aliens to the color Strontium burns.
Morality Play First
I want ‘the morality play’ that talks about today to take precedence over ‘the utopian future’ that inspires us for tomorrow. While I recognize it is entirely legitimate for Star Trek fans to prefer the contrary, I would venture that The Original Series consistently does just this, and that Starfleet Academy does too. It is an indecent galaxy in which the cadets must strive to be a beacon of decency. No lesson comes easily and no victory comes without cost. Solutions are often messy and imperfect, as they must be in a messy and imperfect world.
*This piece is also available on the Trekkies for Academy Substack, if you'd prefer to read it there, but the texts are identical.
https://trekkiesforacademy.substack.com/p/why-i-love-starfleet-academy-as-an