😭😭

So according to this narration, ummar knows better that the prophet pbuh!!!

What kind of Muslim would accept that a regular guy knows more than the prophet!!!

And what's worse is the shia are always the ones defending Islam when it is their narrations that gives it a bad rep!!!

The rest or the comments are non-muslims just ridiculing such narrations!

Got pissed off and needed to vent.

This is going to be a bit of a rant, so pardon me in advance.

Every time I go to school it's packed with people who know NOTHING about Islam, they are either Murtads repeating their Murtad slop arguments, the rest are so uneducated its saddening. Almost no one pray their Salaht, reads the Holy Quran, knows Hadiths, but Prise Be To God all of them are qualified to give Fatwa! Everyone follows unfaithful ideologies, everyone fights about useless things that doesn't matter, its honestly just noise pollution.

Okay... Maybe that's just school, yeah! After all, they are young and whatever, let's go in Mosque, same thing... Okay, Okay... mabey a family gathering? Same thing! Everyone is either racist, Fascist, Ba'athist, anti Iran anti Palestine, etc. old and young their opinions and values are mold by what the midea says, not what Allah (SWT) says!

And what am I in the middle of all lf this? The "mental guy" the "grumpy one" the "stupid backwarded kid", like, Im sorry I take my orders only from Allah and not from ideologies based merely on feelings! I follow truth instead of giving Fatwa merely based on my mood and what is seen as "niche" and "smart", if that upsets you so much mabey you should reconsider your faith.

And I live in a "Muslim" community, so I wonder what is it like for our faithful brotheren and sisteren in places where Islam is not accepted?

Note: While I do sound radical or extreme in this post, I am not, I usually ignore people (vast majority of people) and go on about my day, but I felt like I needed to share this with you all.

[باللغة العربية]

الآية الكريمة: ﴿أَتَىٰ أَمْرُ اللَّهِ فَلَا تَسْتَعْجِلُوهُ﴾ (النحل: ١).

عن الإمام الصادق (عليه السلام) في تأويل الآية، وبيان أن أمر الله هو ظهور الإمام المهدي (عجل الله فرجه)، وأن الله يؤيده بثلاثة أجناد:

«هُوَ أَمْرُنَا، أَمَرَ اللَّهُ (عَزَّ وَجَلَّ) أَنْ لَا يُسْتَعْجَلَ بِهِ حَتَّى يُؤَيِّدَهُ اللَّهُ بِثَلَاثَةِ أَجْنَادٍ: الْمَلَائِكَةِ، وَالْمُؤْمِنِينَ، وَالرُّعْبِ».

المصدر: الغيبة للنعماني، ص ١٩٨

[English Translation]

The holy verse: "The command of Allah has come, so do not hasten it" (An-Nahl: 1).

From Imam Al-Sadiq (as) regarding the interpretation of the verse, explaining that the 'command of Allah' is the reappearance of Imam Al-Mahdi (may Allah hasten his reappearance), and that Allah will support it with three armies:

"It is our matter. Allah, the Almighty and Majestic, has commanded that it not be hastened until Allah supports it with three armies: the angels, the believers, and fear (cast into the hearts of the enemies)."

Source: Al-Ghaybah by Al-Nu'mani, Page 198

Note: Translation assisted by AI and verified by the poster. Please gently correct me if there are any unintended errors.

Salam. I've been studying Shiism for quite a while. I'm a born Sunni Muslim and I've been thinking about doing research and getting to know more about the Shia community.

One of my friends felt betrayed and said it was basically like exiting Islam when my revert friend turned into a Shia Muslim.

It's very looked down upon in my household too. My parents don't even want me to bring the word up. I don't understand why people have have reactions. Do you think it'd be wrong for me to become a Shia Muslim? My friends have been trying to convince me not to and saying it's the wrong thing to do and it will lead me astray. I'm confused by everyone reactions because Shia Muslims are still Muslims so why do a lot of people act like they aren't?

Assalamu alaikum everyone. Im sorry if its a long read but i really need advice because im running out of patience, I’m posting because our family is dealing with a severe inheritance and property injustice, and I want to understand how this stands from both an Islamic perspective and general advice.

For context, the market (around 40 or so shops) was owned by my great grandfather from my mothers side. He had seven sons. The market is on the ground floor, and all of their houses are built on the top floor, every one has a personal house. After his death it went to his wife, who before she died entrusted the eldest son to divide it equally among his brother. For some reason he never did that was the whole market was entrusted to one of the younger brother (lets name him W) because none of the other brothers lived in that town, this was about 20-30 years ago. During this duration, the eldest one and my grandfather(2nd eldest) passed away.

Now from the past three years our family has been in great turmoil, facing debts,diseases,frequently losing jobs and much more i truly cant even say. So about one year ago, we moved back to our grandfathers house, initially Ws family was very welcoming because they taught we were just visiting and would leave soon, but once they got to know we werent leaving they started getting hostile, they would cut off power to our house, wont let us use the water pump and other things that would make our lives miserable. We didnt said a thing and kept being patient. Then Ws wife and Sons started spreading rumours about our family specifically about my mother,sister and little brother whos about 8. They started calling the other uncles and told them made up stories about how were destroying the house and how my sisters ordering food worth 1000rs everyday, or how my brother uses slang and disrespects them for being poor. Once again we stayed patienced.

Ws wife and sons, who still lives in the town has been completely controlling the market, pocketing all the rent, and refusing to give us our share. Whenever we brought it up, they always dismissed us and claimed "it's not that much" or brushed it off. While that uncle technically owns his own share, the market is still not divided. To put things into perspective, there were days in the past where we literally went hungry, hardships that our rightful rental income could have easily helped prevent.

They are now marrying off their 2nd daughter. To fund the wedding, they recently sold one of the shops in the market. hey consulted another surviving brother, but completely bypassed my mother, who is a direct legal owner/heir. On top of that, the market has never been formally distributed or divided yet.

My questions are:

1. Under Shia/Ja'fari Fiqh, is it Halal for them to sell a jointly-owned property/shop without my mother's consent, especially when the estate has never been formally divided?
2. Is the money they raised from selling that shop Halal to spend on a wedding, knowing it involves usurping an heir's property?
3. What are my mother's rights regarding this unauthorized sale and the decades of withheld rent that rightfully belonged to us when we were struggling?
4. Whats their punishment in the court of allah and the other brothers who hid the sale from us untill now?

Question for the brothers on the sub.

If you’re seeing someone for marriage (the halal way, chaperoned meetings and so on) and then u find out from external sources (90% chance they’re true) that the girl’s family owes money to people (keeping in mind they don’t have a breadwinner at the moment). And that your own family has had bad experience with debt (in terms of not being paid by the person who took loan and it caused multiple big fights in the family since the debtor was a relative of one of the spouses and the creditor was the other spouse. So a big trauma in general)

And the fact that they’ve lied/been unclear about things in the past and come clean but not until few days after the first meeting. And even then hidden a few things.

And in the midst of all this you have to consider that Istikhara (taken out 3 times, once by maulana twice by family themselves) came positive each time.

The girl seems to be a nice woman. Good values and feminine. No fault of her own in anything besides hiding some relevant information.

What would you do? Would you consider giving the girls family a chance tk explain themselves and guarantee that they won’t hold you responsible for their debts and that after marriage you’re only responsible for your wife and her upkeep and not fkr her family (not that your averse to helping but you’re not open to it becoming a fixed arrangement where they start expecting fixed deposit each month). Or would the string of lies and trauma from the past make u try to find a less complicated match?

Forgive me for the incoherency. I know it’s a bit of a ramble and very poorly structured. Just wanted honest opinions.