r/mystery • u/One-Advantage2148 • 17h ago
Disappearance The Halloween Disappearance of Penn State Student Cindy Song
On the night of October 31, 2001, Cindy went out with friends Stacy Paik and Lisa Kim to The Players, a bar located just minutes from her apartment. The trio danced, drank, and mingled until last call at 2:00 a.m. After the bar closed, they went to a friend’s apartment to play video games.
Shortly before 4:00 a.m., Stacy dropped Cindy off at the steps of her apartment.
Stacy Paik, who will later tell police that she “watched her go up to the apartment, but not in the door,” before driving away. This is the last confirmed sighting of Cindy Song.
Before she disappeared, Cindy had made arrangements to spend time catching up with her roommate, Younjoo Kim — who went by her American name, Catherine. Catherine returned to their apartment on Thursday, November 1, in the early afternoon after an extended visit with family in Philadelphia. The front door was locked from the outside. Inside, the apartment was empty.
There were no signs of forced entry. No indication of a struggle. Nothing obviously disturbed.
Catherine assumed Cindy had stepped out briefly. They had plans that evening. They were supposed to go out with friends the following night. But Cindy never came back.
By Sunday, Catherine and Cindy’s friend Stacy went to the Ferguson Township Police Department. Police would not enter Cindy’s apartment until Monday November 5, 2001, four long days after she was last seen. What they found suggested she had made it home that night. Her bookbag was inside, along with her cell phone. Her false eyelashes were resting on the bathroom sink. But they could not account for her wallet, keys or debit card.
Within weeks, Cindy’s disappearance gained international attention. The FBI became involved due to her status as an international student. The Korean Consulate stepped in. The investigative team briefly expanded from two officers to six. As the search intensified, Cindy’s mother, Bansoon Song, and her brother, Kiho Song, traveled from Seoul to Pennsylvania.
Cindy’s rent had been prepaid through the beginning of the fall semester and was covered through December. Her brother publicly stated that the family intended to continue paying it. They wanted the apartment preserved exactly as Cindy left it. Not emptied. Not reassigned. Not closed.
At some point in December, Bansoon discovered she could not access her daughter’s apartment. The locks had been changed. The family says they were not notified in advance. The apartment complex then known as State College Park Apartments, now Alight State College would not disclose the identity of the co-signer on Cindy’s lease.
Adding to the unease: Cindy’s bedroom door which reportedly had holes in it prior to her disappearance had been replaced. Some possessions were removed from the apartment. It is unclear what was taken, by whom, or under what authority. Forensic processing of the apartment did not occur until March 2002. Nothing of evidentiary value was publicly reported.
In early November, a woman in Philadelphia reported hearing a woman crying from inside a car:
“Help me. Please help me.”
When she approached, the driver told her to get away. She later believed the woman in the car was Cindy Song. On December 5, 2001 (35 days after Cindy vanished) Ferguson police learned of the claim and traveled to Philadelphia. It was the first promising lead.
But inconsistencies in the witness’s statements weakened its credibility. The tip was eventually deemed unreliable. Months later, the witness was placed under controlled hypnosis in an attempt to recover additional detail. Nothing useful emerged. The case quickly became cold.
In early June 2003, in a quiet backyard in Luzerne County, preparations were underway for a graduation party. Then police arrived, looking for a missing pharmacist, Michael Kerkowski. What they uncovered would ripple across Pennsylvania Five bodies buried in a yard. By mid-June, four were publicly identified.
Before March 2003, Detective Lieutenant Gary Capitano had never heard the name Hugo Selenski. That changed when a friend of Selenski’s asked authorities to look into a robbery. An informant emerged. That informant, Paul Weakley, led Capitano and other Luzerne County detectives to what would soon be described as a backyard graveyard.
Paul Weakley began cooperating with police in exchange for a reduced sentence — reduced meaning life imprisonment instead of something worse. Throughout the summer and early fall, he provided details about crimes involving himself and Hugo Selenski. He said he knew what happened to Cindy Song.
According to Weakley, in 2002 Hugo Selenski and Michael Kerkowski drove to State College. They encountered a young woman he described as a prostitute. They abducted her. Kerkowski sexually assaulted her. She was taken to Selenski’s home in Hunlock Creek and held there until she died. Weakley claimed Kerkowski kept a trophy: a pair of bunny ears.
Cindy’s reward posters described her Halloween costume. The early public descriptions were inconsistent about whether the ears were specifically listed. To this day, public documentation is unclear on whether law enforcement definitively confirmed that the ears were left inside the apartment.
On October 8, 2003, Ferguson Township Police met with Weakley and began examining his claims. He identified locations where bodies were allegedly buried. Those searches yielded nothing. Investigators turned their focus to Weakley. They searched his apartment. On his computer, they found extensive material related to Cindy’s disappearance.
At the suggestion of the Penn State Paranormal Research Society, psychic Carla Baron was brought in. Baron was nationally known at the time and had gained visibility through appearances connected to MTV’s Fear.
Much of her involvement was not publicly detailed.
In April 2004, Baron and Detective Brian Sprinkle appeared on ABC’s Primetime Live. During the segment, Baron laid out tarot cards and claimed to communicate with Cindy’s spirit. She suggested the killer was “somebody obsessed with her” and referenced a third person connected to Selenski and Kerkowski. She also stated she felt Cindy’s presence in Luzerne County. But at the end of the day there is still no solid information to tie Cindy to Luzerne County.
As of today, her disappearance remains unsolved.
If you have credible information related to Cindy Song’s case, please contact the Ferguson Township Police Department directly at (814) 237-1172 or (800) 479-0050.