I read the first prose novel in the Something is Killing the Children universe over the weekend, and found it to be an overall satisfying experience. I bought the hardcover and also the Audible version, which is how I read it this time.
This is the first iteration of SIKTC outside of the comic series. The series focuses on a young woman, Erica Slaughter, who is part of the Order of St. George, an organization that hunts and kills monsters created by children's imaginations.
My spoiler-free thoughts:
1. This is an excellent entryway for people who haven’t read the comics and don’t know anything about the SIKTC world. My wife, whose only exposure has been me unsuccessfully urging her to read the comics, loved the novel and had no difficulty tracking the story despite lack of foreknowledge.
2. The book is set prior to the Archer's Peak arc, so Erica is younger and newer in her time with the Order than in the main arcs of the series; she is hunting alone though, no longer traveling with Jessica.
3. While the comics are primarily from Erica's point of view, the novel focuses on her in some chapters and on several of the local characters in others. For the most part this works, but there were a few sections that dragged on longer than they needed to.
4. The town (Badwater, Idaho) is portrayed well, with its unique set of locals with secrets and anxieties. There is a satisfying twist near the end involving one of them and an aspect of their history that wasn't what Erica thought it would be.
5. There's a new kind of monster involved here, one that I don't think we've encountered yet in the comics, but I hope we will. What makes it distinctive has to do with an unusual aspect of the child who has manifested it.
6. The novel touches on the deeper lore of the Order and the House of Slaughter, but not in great detail. It explains what matters for the story and doesn't attempt to do more.
Overall, Hope is a Knife is a worthy addition to the SIKTC world, providing an engaging story for longtime fans and an accessible introduction to the universe for the uninitiated.
Hopefully it will motivate some non-comics readers to give the graphic series a try.
Rating: 4/5 or B+