I’ve been trying for two years and nothing. I live nearby so I can attempt it weekly. Am I doing something wrong or am I just super unlucky?

Hiii~ one of my friends is a big musical fan in general and I know she also really loves Hamilton. She is also a huge fan of DIY creative crafts, so I'd like to give a handmade present for her upcoming birthday. I would be happy to hear any ideas, even/especially inside-joke-like. Thank you in advance!