So yeah, they both love those big fuzz sounds and play guitar very well, and they’re both from around the same time when their music started and got popular, but… how did all the comparisons/collaborations/conflations start?
I don’t see them as that similar of guitarists; Dinosaur Jr and J’s stuff in general, while extremely loud and fuzzed out, especially early on, isn’t shoegaze-y at all, imo, it’s much more about structures, dividng chords and precise leads than MBV. Kevin Shields is his own genre of guitarist (which, don’t get me wrong, J is too, he’s my favorite player ever), so much so that like 90% of dudes who play shoegaze-y guitar are kinda just ripping off his techniques and gear and stuff lol.
Again, I get that J is that same level of icon, but they were across the Earth from each other as they developed their sounds, which are very different. So how/why do people always kinda lump or talk about them together? I’ve seen stuff of them meeting and talking irl, I don’t know to what degree (if it’s just like promotional gear stuff or if they’re really genuinely good friends) they interact, but does anyone know how this whole thing started?
Sorry if this is some super well-known story i J Mascis/Dinosaur lore, I know a lot about the band but as far as the members interacting with other artists, I just kinda know J’s relationship with Sonic Youth…