I've seen this movie listed everywhere, like it's in every top 4, top 5, greatest movies of all time. Now I see the appeal. It's just a one POV. In a room full of 12 ordinary citizen chosen as a standard criminal trial jury, to serve as a body of peers to decide the fate of an 18-year-old defendant.
This movie doesn't have any cinematic appeal for "some" or casual modern audiences. It's just a bunch of people talking, arguing inside a jury room. Now where does the appeal came from and why people calling it a perfect film?
Just imagine this, or maybe observe your daily routine. You're at work, talking to your office mates bout what happened the other day, somebody got fired, or maybe someone involved into a fight, probably from a manager who knows. This is what happened in this film, they talk, sharing things, and importantly, discussing the core of the case. How does it happened, what time did it happened and when does it occur. It's basically part of our daily lives. We talk to other people how to solve these things. Imagine all that, played in a more dramatic way. Played by some of the finest actors. Notable from their brilliance of acting, from Henry Fonda, Lee J. Cobb, Joseph Sweeney etc.
One of its great aspects is, it is visually engaging without any visual effects or any impressive action scenes in front of you. Instead, you're attached to the script, the story telling from these people. One time they look joyful talking about lives, about their families, and the next minute, things are getting intense. You visualized by imagining, on how you looked at the crime scene. Which is really unique!
If you're a cinephile who loves dialogue focused films like the Before Trilogy. This is your cup of tea. I'm not even a fan of these kind of genre but I do appreciate it. Sidney Lumet is just brilliant, in fact, this is his directorial debut, like for a directorial debut this is just impressive! Aside from this brilliant film, and the other ones like Serpico, or Dog Day Afternoon (which also focused on one POV which is the bank robbery) are some my favorite movies of all time.