r/changemyview • u/WolvoNeil • 15h ago
CMV: The UK economy requires nothing getting done in order to function
In the UK for some time there has been a pervasive feeling that we seem incapable of 'getting stuff done', especially when referring to major infrastructure.
- A third runway at Heathrow Airport has been under 'serious consideration' for at least 30 years, but is still in a 'will they, won't they' status.
- The Northern Leg of HS2 was originally approved in 2009, before being scrapped in 2023.
- Hinckley Point C, a major expansion to an existing Nuclear Power Plant was in development for 19 years, and has been under construction for 10 years.
- The last major water reservoir was built in 1992.
Some suggest this malaise is because of privatisation discouraging investment, some claim its because of lack of long term planning in politics, addiction to the 24-hour news cycle, some claim we no longer have the physical engineering and construction capacity to undertake these kinds of projects.
My view is that this lack of 'being able to get stuff done' is a conscious and essential component of the functioning of the British economy, because the economy relies on administration and bureaucracy.
When the average voter reads that anywhere between £3bn-£5bn was written off when HS2 northern leg was cancelled they see waste and loss, when the government considers that same number they see £3bn-£5bn of economic growth and investment. They see 10 years of land agents, surveyors, estimators, solicitors, consultants, ecologists, thinktanks, review bodies, planning officers, consultees and civil servants passing documents amongst themselves as productivity.
Around 60% of UK workers are employed in what could be described as White Collar roles and those roles do not thrive or even require 'stuff to get done' in order to be economically productive, in many cases the opposite is true. Anyone who has dealt with property lawyers will know that expediency is never a priority and in some cases it can feel as though issues are protracted precisely because they are incentivised if things take longer, and they still get paid if a matter does not successfully conclude.
The UK has become particularly effective at generating economic activity around the possibility of productive investment, rather than the delivery of productive investment itself, it may well be unique in the world in this regard.