1st screenshot is the final version.
2nd one is the AI-Built first version.
I think AI is really bad in compacting information, everything is always stuffed with information and even Opus 5.5 has little sense of minimalism and building a proper visual hierarchy.
For context; It's an overview page for a Website management tool I am building (basically have editor, analytics and booking system in one place for multiple sites).
This site is the overview page, once you select a Website in your portfolio.
Most importantly, what AI never really get's right - what do I actually want to see and a web admin first?
- Image of the live hero instantly tells me, if the site generally looks good and also I instantly know which site it is, in case I have sites with similar names.
- Then I want to see if everything is running, so there's status indicators, is the site online, are all the different tools working properly?
- Next is open edit requests of customers. In case i set it so a client can't publish himself, I have to confirm a requested change. This one has some urgency, since the client probably wants the change to be confirmed asap. This is why it has a slightly coloured background.
- History of previous chnages is hidden behind the button, since it's not too relevant for usual operation.
- Next one is analytics, which has probably already been scanned by now - just a quick feedback, if the website is performing well or if it's breaking in
- Booking is last, since for one, a lot of sites might not have a booking system implemented and secondly, apart from being functional, I as a web admin don't really care too much about the booking performance, but it's still nice to see some stats here.
Also, as many can probably tell, the header is indeed inspired by Vercel.
Hope these insights give some value.
Would also love to get your feedback on the current state, does everything feel right to you?