I know The Enneagram is widely disregarded as a pseudoscience by psychology, but is it simply innefective or does it have the potential to be something harmful?
Most people only engage with The Enneagram on a surface level and get the usual "You are a 1 because you value morality" or "You are a 6 and are anxious" type of descriptions, and those are pretty harmless. But once you dive into the books and stuff, especially the descriptions by Claudio Naranjo, it tends to get far more personal. I have a read a few of those descriptions (Both mine and some friends's) and they tend to portray your "inner self" as some monstrous caricature of your worst traits. Of course i know about the Barum Forner effect but if you pinpoint your subtype, the descriptions are very poignant, and especially in the sense they wanna hit you where it hurts the most, more than one friend of mine cried (Or came close to) after reading their own
I know some of the basics of Enneagram Theory and also how it generally conflicts with modern psychology, such as saying how what we call "personality" is actually a mask or false identity, essentially a bunch of coping mechanisms born from childhood wounds, and that you must "kill" or "break free" from your ego in order to reach enlightement. If this sounds like some spiritual nonsense, thats cause it kinda is, i do believe the original author said that he learned of Enneagram Theory from an archangel. The cult-ish undertones kinda worry me but thats not what i am talking about here
Either way, i feel The Enneagram has done some serious damage to my psyche ever since i started engaging with it, but i never heard of anyone else having a similar experience, so i wonder if its a "me problem" or not. Self-awareness is not most humans's strong suit, but i would describe myself as a stable and happy person just a few months ago, but The Enneagram Model made me believe many parts of me that i was completely fine with are somehow flaws, that the mental strategies or coping mechanisms i use to navigate life are flawed and damage me, essentially convinced me that i am somehow internally broken despite never feeling like i was before
When i tried to bring up this issue in Enneagram communities, i was met with dismissive remarks like "The truth is ugly and it hurts at first, but once you accept it, you will feel better", but i have always been the type to question things and that answer doesnt sit right with me, so i kinda wanted to ask for a 2nd opinion based on actual psychological knowledge