In my experience, Yadakk is too strong on Small Lakes. Since there is no data about pick rates and win rates for tribes, I am asking this community whether you agree or I am somewhat biased.
First of all, I do not want Yadakk to get a nerf in the next few weeks. It is one of the most fun tribes in the game. Also, Ramdingler won Worlds with this tribe and this was not more than 2 weeks ago.Now everybody can try out Yadack and see for themselves why this tribe has the potential to win Worlds.
Right now, my experience is the following:
1) A lot of people play Yadakk on Small Lakes
2) Yadakk is winning A LOT.
Since Polytopia is a Rock-Paper-scissors game, I am asking what tribe AND tactic is good against Yadack? I mean on high skill level (1700+ elo).
Personally, I tried out Zebasi and Imperius, but these matchups are more on the losing side. Yadakk is simply too fast. My idea is to try out Hoodrick and Bardur next and play defense.
But the Yadakk playbook is good against defensive tribes as well. Especially, when there is a lake in the middle, then Yadakk wins over water control (fastest tribe). If the Yadakk player is good, then you already lost at this point.
So, are you experiencing the same?
Is there a reliable counter to Yadakk?
If there is no reliable counter to Yadakk, then I would suggest a nerf, like
a) less fruit
b) less starting stars
c) a different spawn pattern for all tribes. Like more spawns in NW, NE SE, SW direction.
This nerfs the Yadakk road opening, since now one road cannot connect both suburbs.
d) higher mountain ratio
e) higher water ratio in capital