I'm listening to a lot of Bob Rock era Metallica records (again). I'm in love with Load! James' vocal performance is at another level in that record. His voice is so much more mature and expressive as compared to Master of Puppets or AJFA.
Even sonically, these records sound far better as compared to their older records. The sound is heavier and more polished.
Anyway, coming back to vocals, the late 90s were Hetfield's peak as a vocalist in my opinion.Songs like Bleeding me, Outlaw Torn, King Nothing, Memory Remains, Low Man's Lyric, Turn the page and whiskey in the Jar are absolutely fucking phenomenal. There's so much depth in those vocals.. I'm blown away.
And even the live versions are incredible, S&M has captured the vocals beautifully. Cunning stunts is great too.
People like to talk a lot about this era of Metallica, but rarely they acknowledg the vocal performance of James Hetfield during these times.