r/JudgeMyAccent • • Mar 12 '26

PSA for if your posts keep getting removed

5 Upvotes

This is one of the most common things I get messaged about. If your posts keep getting removed, it's likely that it's an issue on Reddit's side. Usually this issue is that you are "shadowbanned", which you can read up more on here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ShadowBan/

I cannot do anything to fix this, and I'll keep this post pinned but will no longer be replying to messages about this issue. Thanks!


r/JudgeMyAccent • • Apr 05 '24

Post Guidelines - How to get meaningful feedback

20 Upvotes

Hello all,

This post is a general guide on what you can do as someone uploading clips of your speech to try and set yourself up for getting more and better feedback from the community. A lot of this comes from my personal opinions on the types of clips I like to give feedback to, as well as what I've seen people in the community say.

1. General information

Including general information in your post can help people give more tailored feedback. For example, what sort of accent are you trying to go for? What specific things do you struggle with? Why are you trying to improve your accent (for daily speech, a job, etc.)?

2. Audio quality

Not everyone has access to a good microphone or quiet environment. However, to the extent possible, try to limit background noise. One simple method is recording under a blanket or in a closet of some form. Also, I suggest testing out your volume before recording a full clip. I pass on reviewing many clips due to them being too quiet.

3. Clip length

As other users have suggested, please try to shoot for a clip ~30 seconds or more. I think the golden window is between 0:45 and 1:30, depending on the speaker. It's going to be hard to give meaningful feedback on a single sentence.

4. Transcriptions/texts

This is personally relevant for me when it comes to foreign languages that I am not as proficient in. Nevertheless, when reading from a text, please share the text you're reading from. It saves people from having to guess what you were trying to say, and just removes an extra layer of complications from giving feedback.

​

This is not a final list, and feel free to share your gripes/suggestions, and I can add them to the list above.


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 8h ago

English How's my English so far?

2 Upvotes

I always lack confidence of joining voice chat with some people because I get scared that people will make fun of my pronunciations. Please let me know if you have any feedback


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 11h ago

English How did I “lose” my American accent? How is it even possible?

0 Upvotes

I stayed in the US from 2007-2008 (10 months, at 17-18), then 2010-2013 (2.5 years, at 20-23) and finally 2017-2018 (1.5 years at 27-28). About 4 years and 10 months, scattered. I’ve been back in Korea ever since.

Reddit comments on my recording from 5 years ago (3 years out)

- Sounds 99% like an American accent to me, and about as neutral as it’s possible for an American accent to be.
There are a couple of bits where you sound like you have a slight Asian accent, but I’m not sure I would notice if I wasn’t specifically listening out for it.

- You honestly have very very little accent. You sound like 90-95% native to me (I’m American). If ylu didnt have that tiny bit of an accent Id guess you’re a native speaker.

- Hmm its hard to guess where youre from, I would guess you are from somewhere in Asia? You dont have a strong accent by any means and it reminds me of somebody else who posted here with barely any accent and they were from South Korea (unless you are the same person posting again lol) (note: I was that person)

Reddit comments from my recent post (today)

- SE Asia (based on your prosody).

- Hmm..The rhythm and tonality in some parts sound Cantonese to me.. Kinda close to my neighbour, Swedish - But all in all you’re definitely East Asian. Not Japanese nor Mandarin native speaker tho.

- South Asian!

I deleted a post I uploaded a few days ago so people can guess the accent from a blank slate. But one commenter went as far as to say something along the lines of:

“You sound non-native. And if it didn’t happen in the first 5 years [that you spent in America] it’s never going to happen.”

which I thought was a bit unfair because it actually went the OTHER direction.

I teach the SAT for a living (so I’m surrounded by bilinguals) and I never would’ve thought simply physically being in Korea make me LOSE the supposedly 90-99% American accent I used to have?

What do you think happened?
I consume enough American media. What do you think I can do to get the accent back?


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 15h ago

What does my accent sound like? Try telling me where I'm from.

1 Upvotes

I've been formally studying English for over 12 years, but in practice, even reading is a bit of a struggle for me. Nothing unusual, considering I didn't really need this language... But I wonder what my accent sounds. I'm not immersed in the Anglosphere, so I can't determine it myself


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 16h ago

How’s my progress on the American accent?

1 Upvotes

Sure, I don't sound native. But pls tell me how's my progress? Do you guys also think that this accent is good for me to like do a youtube channel in English or something like that? Let me your thoughts!


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 18h ago

English Can you guess where I’m from? Which words/sounds gave it away?

1 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

Can you guess where I’m from? I’m American and east of the Mississippi.

2 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

What is this accent?

4 Upvotes

Title


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

German Criticize my accent, thanks

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

Grew up in the States but I feel like I have a foreign accent

Thumbnail recorder.google.com
1 Upvotes

Hey all! It's my first time posting something like this online, so I am a little nervous about what yall will have to say. I moved to the US when I was 1.5 years old, and though I am fluent in English, I have been told by many of my peers (more so in the past) that I have a foreign accent. I definitely notice this when listening to old recordings of myself, and I find it a little embarrassing since I grew up in a pretty diverse community where everyone spoke English with an American accent. I suspect that speaking my ethnic mother tongue at home may have contributed to this. Either way, I have been working to correct this over the past year, and I am looking for some more feedback. I'd say that I am aiming for a Californian accent (maybe something like what James Hetfield has? IK he is from California, but I don't know if what he has is a Californian accent. Either way, something like that).

Edit: Just added the excerpts I read from in the recording
https://irp.cdn-website.com/d4bdb854/files/uploaded/Readings-for-Speech-Evaluations.pdf


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

Danish My attempt at pronouncing "rødgrød med fløde"

2 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right subreddit lol


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

English Wonder if anyone's gonna be able to guess where I'm from, usually people can't hehe

1 Upvotes

I need to charge my phone...


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

English Where do I sound like I’m from? (I.e. what kind of accent do I have?)

11 Upvotes

I’m curious because I’ve never heard feedback on my accent before


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

Japanese I feel like my pronunciation is the strongest attribute of my language skills next to recognizing patterns and making connections. What do you think?

4 Upvotes

I speak four other languages and I’m more fluent in others than Japanese simply because I don’t get the opportunity to practice it every day.


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

Is my accent obvious ?

Thumbnail voca.ro
1 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

Do I sound native?

12 Upvotes

Help me to improve my American accent. Anything off? Pls feel free to tell me in the comments. Thank you!


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 1d ago

Rate my roommates accent

0 Upvotes

My two roommates got in an argument lmao


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

Russian American speaking Russian (1 month later)

1 Upvotes

Hello,

I posted here 1 month ago and I was told that my voice sounded robotic and lacked tonal flow.

I have tried to adapt this and try to sound more natural.

Note: I am not a Russian person. I grew up in America and I am self taught (with the help of DuoLingo and a few books). I also utilize translators, so my apologies if the vocabulary is slightly off.

I am also aware that I likely have a strong American accent.

If you happen to speak Russian, please let me know what you think. If you have any pointers, please drop them here. Thank you so much!


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

German Jugde my German accent!

3 Upvotes

Was kann ich besser machen?
Ich habe den Text zum ersten Mal gelesen um das Ergebniss nicht zu verfälschen. Ich weiß, ich lisple ziemlich und habe manchmal, vor allem beim schnellen Sprechen Probleme das „o“ immer richtig auszusprechen. Fällt Euch sonst was auf?
Bonuspunkte, wenn jemand errät wo ich her komme und wo ich in DE wohne :)


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

English Do I have a weird accent?

0 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

Judge my pronunciation for the following words.

1 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 2d ago

Native speakers tend to guess a semi-specific group of accents (incorrectly), AI usually gets it right. Wonder how "strong" my native accent really is and what makes it so (no formal education)

Thumbnail voca.ro
0 Upvotes

r/JudgeMyAccent • • 3d ago

German Judge my accent in German.

2 Upvotes

I have posted here before, but I dont think my last recording was accurate to how I speak German anymore. I have worked on my German since then, but I also took a break from learning for a bit. So it could sound better or worse.


r/JudgeMyAccent • • 3d ago

Judge thanks!

1 Upvotes

Judge it thanks! if i have an accent is it hella severe or like slight?

edit:

for all the guys here that said Asian im a lil confused since my perception of the Asian accent comes from Steven He (basically the stereotypical HK accent), but I don't think I have that type of accent. Could you guys tell me what makes it sound Asian? I'm confused cuz ik hella Asians cant pronounce the sound "th" and add like uh's after or before words but ik I don't do that