r/IrishAncestry • u/RutlandReformer • 1d ago
My Family Parent mystery: John James McDonnell
My late grandfather believed he was descended from the McDonnells of Antrim.
John James McDonnell, the oldest ancestor I can trace, was born about 1853 in Liverpool. I know nothing of his mother.
At the age of 17, in 1871, he was boarding at a house as a linen draper’s apprentice.
Over the years, he worked as a writing clerk, cashier, commercial clerk, and fire engineer’s accountant.
He married Myra Fox in 1874. Both witnesses were her relations. However, he named his father as “James McDonnell, surgeon” on his wedding certificate.
I’ve searched records of surgeons and can’t find any that really match up. One researcher suggested he could be the illegitimate son of the notable Irish doctor John McDonnell (whose middle name could have been James? son of James McDonnell), but he admitted it’s a long shot.