r/DahmerNetflix • • Oct 30 '22

All inconsistencies in DAHMER (with the corrections) Spoiler

611 Upvotes

Since I see a lot of people on this sub are asking questions of “Is this or that true or not??” here’s a list to make things easier for ya’ll. (I also tagged it as a spoiler just in case)

  • Jeffrey did not meet Tracy Edwards at Club 219 (He met him and a few of Tracy’s friends at Grand Avenue Mall - he also said he was not gay during his testimony).

  • Jeffrey did not just ran lamely and willingly got hand cuffed during his arrest (Jeffrey fought with the officers with passion even screamed that echoed throughout the apartment that sounded “animal like” per the bass husband & wife and he even pinched one of the officers thigh during the floor wrestle. The officer even screamed OUCHHH). Yep.

  • Lionel and Jeffrey never bonded over road kill ever. (He just showed him how to dissolve the chicken bones that they ate during dinner).

  • Popular: Glenda Cleveland was not his neighbor and she was not that obsessed with Dahmer. (In the series Jeffrey could’ve just said “And I was like why are you so obsessed with me??) lol.

  • No one heard any sketchy shit from the apartment. Pamela Bass notated that she just often heard music all the time but had occasional thuds and maybe “diy projects” lol. (Bass also stated that sometimes he would hear Jeffrey cursing but thought he was just alone).

  • Glenda only called like 1 time because of the Konerak situation that her daughter and niece witnessed. (“I called for months and months” Okay Netflix Glenda. No, I highly believe this was added because if not it would be boring as fuck since Jeffrey was not suspected with anything and was in good terms with his neighbors- added it for extra “drama”).

  • No one did suspected Dahmer of anything other than just being a weirdo who kept to himself. (A weirdo who just worked all night did not make any eye contact that much but friendly when approached).

  • Dahmer did not meet Konerak randomly outside of a convenient store. (It wasn’t even night time when he met Konerak- it was at the Grand Ave Mall again around afternoon).

  • Korenak did not know who Jeffrey was at all nor Jeffrey did not know who he was. (Konerak was not there during his brothers trial with Jeffrey).

  • Jeffrey’s apartment did not smell like rotting flesh/dead bodies. (It smelled more like chemicals and urine per Pamela Bass & reporter Anne E. Schwartz).

  • Jeffrey was not evicted from the Oxford Apartments because of the numerous smell complaints. (He never got evicted ever he just got fired at the Ambrosia. He was also running out of money so he was planning on moving out disposing everything and check himself in a salvation army but got lazy and drunk as fuck and contemplated disposing the skulls- Jeffrey contemplating back and forth about the skulls prolonged his stay and decision which led to him fall apart). ALSO: His landlord even considered him to be a business partner lmao its on his statement at the trial at CourtTV.

  • Joyce begged him to come with her and David when she was about to leave their house. (Based on Joyce’s statement Jeffrey just stood there and was “frozen” so she just decided to leave without him paranoid that Lionel would catch them leave- based on Shrine).

  • Joyce tried to get Jeffrey to go to California but he did not want to. (He later regretted not going there and wished he did instead of working at the Ambrosia which was noted on a letter he sent to Joyce).

  • Jeffrey did not learn about Halcion in the military (He learned it through a newspaper ad which stated that Halcion is what Bush H. Bush used for his sleep tension during the Gulf War- that’s in the bookGrilling Dahmer).

  • He did not drugged anyone in the military. (He was reported to be completely drunk 4-6 times per week on and off duty sometimes could not even stand up due to being too intoxicated).

  • Jeffrey did not begged to come home to Lionel and Shari when he was in Miami. (He called them to ask for Money as he was out Lionel did not send him any and gave him a plane ticket instead to come home).

  • He did not dramatically drank blood while looking in the mirror (lol) he only did it once at the rooftop of his workplace and spitted it out immediately quoted that blood tasted “yuck yuck- not his thing”.

  • He did not worked at a meat shop at all. (I believe this was added as a narrative for people to think that he learned how to cut up bodies there- He was also jobless for 2 years before landing a job at the Ambrosia after being laid off as a Phlebotomist).

  • He did not really have a car (He only borrowed his dad’s car and its not color brown or tan its a blue ford based on Shrine by Brian Masters- same car he used to pick up Steven Hicks). He also had a taxi come to his Grandma’s house to lift the suitcase where Steven Tuomi’s body is at. (He was even assisted by the Taxi driver who was Arabic he said).

  • He did not just met Shari at their house in Ohio. (He had met her prior to that at the motel where Lionel was staying at- again this is from Shrine).

  • He did not have this dramatic scene where he wanted to confess to Lionel and Shari about his first murder. (Jeffrey stated that he did not want or let anyone know ever as he was embarrassed and afraid of what his family would say to him).

  • He never encountered “the jogger” in real life because he never came back.

  • Jeffrey’s apartment was not that dirty. (Landlord also mentioned that out of ALL the apartments he visited at the Oxford apts Jeffrey’s was the CLEANEST its on his CourtTv statement too).

  • He did not mixed his drink by accident during the killing of Steven Tuomi (That happened to someone else who ended up robbing him).

  • He first denied calling one of the victims families (Though he could’ve lied and some other news paper articles back then said he did admitted to it so who fucking knows really).

  • Popular and debatable: He never admitted to knowing Tony Hughes (Though there were a lot of people who have confirmed that they knew each-other prior to killing him).

  • Konerak’s family was not there during the family testimonies in court.

  • Milwaukee police officers Balcerzak and Gabrish did not receive 'Officer of the Year'. (Yeah why Nextflix? No).

  • Jeffrey was not stabbed in the neck prior to being baptized. (He was baptized May 10, 1994 and the attempted stabbing happened July 1994 - confirmed by NY times- and they thought it would just be an isolated case).

  • Joyce attempted suicide around March 1994 not during his trial/arrest. (She also did not knock on the families doors in person but she did try to reach out to them but no one responded).

  • Jeffrey did have a funeral (One of the victims sister even attended- Theresa Smith sister of Edward Smith and she even visited Dahmer in prison).

That’s all I can think of for now.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 4h ago

Are Jeffrey Dahmer Edits weird or normal?

0 Upvotes

So i recently watched the Dahmer Series on Netflix. And i loved the Series it was great acting! And with that i also got to see more clips videos abt Dahmer on Tik Tok. But I also saw an edit of the real jeffrey dahmer. And dont get me wrong. The edits abt the series are valid for me because its mostly about the actor. But these edits were abt the real living jeffrey dahmer. And in the comments they also say stuff like they love him and that he is such a nice man and stuff like that. And my question was: isnt that a bit disrespectful for the victims and the family of them. Like, do they now he was a serial killer? Do they just edit him because of his looks? I mean would they edit an old man too? I really dont wanna hate or be mean i just want to understand the background of these edits? Because maybe i just get it wrong.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 5d ago

When will profiting off suffering stop?

8 Upvotes

Has anyone heard of the "Jeffrey Dollmer" movie? I cant believe (actually i probably can) that they would STILL be making these kinds of movies.

Does no one think about the victims (surviving and deceased) and their families?

At what point do we say "ENOUGH"?

When do we realize that making profit off victims and their families pain is wrong? Will they ever get the respect and peace they deserve?

Let's not forget Jeffs family. His brother is still alive as well as other relatives that have never been mentioned.

Let's stop making money and entertainment from mental illness and struggle.

This is DISGUSTING and Mark Savage should be ASHAMED. He is disrespectful and has no morals.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 6d ago

Discussion When did you start watching Monsters? I started back in August.

8 Upvotes

r/DahmerNetflix • • 8d ago

Monster: Lizzie Borden Aileen Wuornos would’ve been a better choice for Monster S4, instead of Lizzie Borden. I miss what made the Jeffrey Dahmer season so compelling.

56 Upvotes

I genuinely think Aileen Wuornos would’ve been a much better choice for season 4. Her life story is disturbing and tragic enough on its own, from the abuse and exploitation she experienced growing up to her murders and how the media eventually portrayed her. There’s so much to explore about how she became the person she was and how she ended up being seen as a “monster” by society. And no, understanding her circumstances doesn’t mean excusing her crimes.

What bothers me is that the show seems to be moving further away from what made the Dahmer season so compelling. That season was uncomfortable to watch, and I thought that was the whole point. It explored not just the killer’s psychology but also the victims, the failures of the people around them, and how something so horrific was allowed to happen. I feel like people forget that the point of a show like Monster isn’t necessarily to make you sympathize with these people. It’s to make you question what makes someone a monster in the first place. Now it feels like the show is becoming historical fan fiction. I have nothing against artistic liberties, but there’s a difference between dramatizing actual events and inventing entire narratives that barely resemble reality.

Aileen’s story could’ve explored trauma, gender, violence, media sensationalism, and the way society treats female killers differently, all without needing to manufacture drama. That’s the kind of psychological and societal exploration I wish the show would return to. I just miss when the horror came from how disturbing the actual reality was, rather than what the writers decided to make up.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 8d ago

Unpopular opinion: Dahmer (S01) had by far the most unethical narrative fabrications in the Monsters anthology.

Thumbnail
6 Upvotes

r/DahmerNetflix • • 11d ago

I know its just a show

24 Upvotes

I know its just a show and they added more for suspense and drama, but the one scene of the Jeffrey dahmer series that I found incredibly sad was when Lionel brought sherry to meet Jeff and they went to the diner. And Jeff was trying to open up to his dad about the things he had already done and his dad shut him down by saying ill pay for your college tuition, and Jeff just held back his tears, smiled, and agreed to go to college idk if that conversation actually happened or not but IF it did thats really sad how his dad blew him off

I know what Jeffrey did was wrong but I put partial blame on his parents, his mother was crazy, and his dad was only around when needed


r/DahmerNetflix • • 12d ago

Question Dumbest Serial Killer ever?

11 Upvotes

For someone who went to military for good number of years he learned nothing about law and order and how easy it is for him to get caught? he is sloppy and leaves all the evidence behind quite literally, or part of him wanted to get caught?


r/DahmerNetflix • • 15d ago

Question Did netflix made menedez brother dirty???

Post image
51 Upvotes

Honestly? Yes, I think Netflix’s Monsters did the Menendez brothers dirty in some important ways. Not because they were innocent—they were convicted of murdering their parents—but because the show sometimes blurred the line between documented facts and dramatic invention.

The biggest issue for me is the implied incestuous relationship between Lyle and Erik. There’s no established evidence that they had a sexual relationship, and both Erik and Lyle rejected that portrayal.

Los Angeles Times +1

And Lyle especially was portrayed in a very exaggerated, almost caricature-like way. Erik publicly called the portrayals “blatant lies.”

Los Angeles Times

That said, the show didn't completely invent the abuse allegations. Their claims of long-term physical, emotional, and sexual abuse were central to their actual defense, and people close to the family provided supporting testimony. The problem is that the series mixes those real elements with speculation and fictionalized scenes without always making the distinction obvious.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 24d ago

Question Q opinan? Se merece una serie o no?

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/DahmerNetflix • • 25d ago

Monster: Dahmer How is Evan Peters doing?

Post image
154 Upvotes

Its been awhile but I’m rewatching the Dahmer series on Netflix & always wondered how could actors play certain roles like this & maintain their mental health. Anyone know how he’s doing today? Hope he’s fine after playing such a weird character and doing an astonishing job. Do actors ever lose their selves mentally or have to seek therapy after playing certain roles?


r/DahmerNetflix • • 24d ago

Monster: Lizzie Borden anyone else completely besotted by Ella Beatty? (and ryan murphy is a genius rant)

11 Upvotes

i don't get celebrity crushes often. I think I only ever had like, 1. Even in real life it's really hard for me to develop attraction to anyone around me, although I have many good friends. So, I don't mean to come across as parasocial, I know this is dumb lmao but I'm crushing hard on Ella Beatty right now. Her character in s4 comes across as so sensual with a kind of innocence about her. Am I the only one who thinks she is so pretty?

I also love the visual tones and themes in S4. I might be in the minority but I think Ryan Murphy is a genius or at least really talented. In all seasons he explores the same theme and direction: murderers but he's managed to make each season incredibly distinctive, and this time with the pastal colors and the emotionally lush undertones, it's just incredible work. I think all four seasons were amazing. My least favourite was Ed Gein. Felt too much like Dahmer in a way. Like a kind of different version of Dahmer. but Murphy has managed to make the other 3 seasons distinct from each other.

i understand a lot of people dislike the series and this season in particular because of how historically inaccurate it is not to mention how it kind of glorifies murderers to the wrong person BUT taking it as an art form in itself alone, i truly respect Ryan Murphy for this. I love writing as well so I understand how tough it is to have to come up with distinct identities for stories that explore pretty much the same avenues and themes, in this case murder. I really appreciate all 4 seasons. I hope they continue.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 24d ago

Possible next season ideas

1 Upvotes

I’m thinking it might keep going back in years.
Dahmer: 1990s
The Menendez Brothers: 1980s and 1990s
Ed Gein: 1950s
Lizzie Borden: 1890s
Possibly Jack The Ripper?


r/DahmerNetflix • • 25d ago

This one would be interesting

Post image
91 Upvotes

Am I the only one who would really want to see a dramatized series about Bundy? We’ve gotten tons of movies and short series about who he was. But never really a dramatized version of how Ted went on in his daily life. How he maybe fought these inner demons and couldn’t resist. Could be curious to see, and lots to choose from I’m sure.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 25d ago

Netflix will make Monster about Dahmer, Ed Gein and Lizzie Borden. I don't think they'll ever touch John Wayne Gacy.

8 Upvotes

Netflix has turned Dahmer, the Menendez brothers, Ed Gein and now Lizzie Borden into seasons of Monster, but I don't think they'll ever do John Wayne Gacy.

My argument is that the problem isn't Gacy's crimes or notoriety. It's how ordinary his public life was. He was a contractor, employer, political volunteer and community figure whose respectability helped give him access to young men and teenage boys. Even the infamous photograph of Gacy with First Lady Rosalynn Carter fits that pattern.

Unlike Lizzie Borden or Ed Gein, Gacy is difficult to turn into gothic folklore without confronting the ordinary institutions and social respectability surrounding him. That's why I think Monster can film the killer, but would have a much harder time filming the world that let him operate.

Breaking it down further:

https://youtu.be/JgdJBUAlU8M


r/DahmerNetflix • • 26d ago

Netflix will make Monster about Dahmer, Ed Gein and Lizzie Borden. I don't think they'll ever touch John Wayne Gacy

20 Upvotes

Netflix has turned Dahmer, the Menendez brothers, Ed Gein and now Lizzie Borden into seasons of Monster, but I don't think they'll ever do John Wayne Gacy.

My argument is that the problem isn't Gacy's crimes or notoriety. It's how ordinary his public life was. He was a contractor, employer, political volunteer and community figure whose respectability helped give him access to young men and teenage boys. Even the infamous photograph of Gacy with First Lady Rosalynn Carter fits that pattern.

Unlike Lizzie Borden or Ed Gein, Gacy is difficult to turn into gothic folklore without confronting the ordinary institutions and social respectability surrounding him. That's why I think Monster can film the killer, but would have a much harder time filming the world that let him operate.

Breaking it down further:

https://youtu.be/JgdJBUAlU8M


r/DahmerNetflix • • 27d ago

Discussion No one has suggested it but, if you research the case and the perpetrators, it would be one of the most interesting cases to explore

Post image
18 Upvotes

The Boston Marathon bombing already has the structure of a dark thriller. On April 15, 2013, two bombs exploded near the finish line of the marathon, killing three people and injuring hundreds. For several days, investigators searched through huge amounts of surveillance footage before the FBI released photographs of two suspects: brothers Tamerlan and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev. The case then escalated incredibly quickly. MIT police officer Sean Collier was killed, a man was carjacked and held by the brothers, and police eventually tracked them to Watertown. A chaotic nighttime firefight followed involving gunfire and homemade explosives. Tamerlan was fatally injured, while Dzhokhar escaped on foot, leading to a massive search and shelter-in-place order across much of the Boston area. He was finally discovered hours later, wounded and hiding inside a boat in a Watertown backyard.

Tamerlan and Dzhokhar were Chechen immigrants who had moved to the United States with their family, and the brothers themselves would give Monster an extremely strong psychological center because they appeared so different. Tamerlan was seven years older and had once been a talented amateur boxer who dreamed of progressing further in the sport, but his ambitions were damaged when citizenship requirements prevented him from competing at the national Golden Gloves level. In the years afterward he became increasingly isolated and religious, traveled to Dagestan, and consumed extremist material. Dzhokhar, meanwhile, seemed far more Americanized. Known as “Jahar” to his friends, he wrestled, worked as a lifeguard, listened to rap, partied, drank and smoked marijuana, and was remembered by many people as relaxed and sociable. That contrast creates one of the most interesting questions in the entire case: how could someone living such an apparently ordinary American teenage life become involved in terrorism? A season could deeply explore Tamerlan’s radicalization, Dzhokhar’s relationship with his older brother, sibling loyalty, ideological influence, identity, alienation and the question of how much of Dzhokhar’s worldview developed independently.

The story also becomes even more intense after Dzhokhar is captured. He survives his injuries and eventually goes on trial in federal court in 2015, where there is little dispute over whether he participated in the bombing; instead, much of the defense focuses on Tamerlan’s influence over him. Prosecutors argue that Dzhokhar willingly participated and should be held fully responsible for his own actions, while his lawyers portray Tamerlan as the dominant force in the relationship. Dzhokhar is ultimately found guilty on all 30 federal charges. The case then enters a separate penalty phase, where the jury has to confront those same psychological questions before recommending the death penalty. He is formally sentenced to death, giving a potential season a completely different final act: moving from terrorism and a citywide manhunt into a courtroom examination of radicalization, responsibility and the relationship between two brothers.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 27d ago

Discussion Monster: THE H. H. HOLMES STORY.

Post image
44 Upvotes

1 THE MURDER HOTEL. Come on.

2 Off the bat I'm already thinking CHRIS PINE for the lead role. There's a number of actors that can fit the look easy --


r/DahmerNetflix • • 28d ago

Monster:The Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold Story

Post image
88 Upvotes

Hear Me Out


r/DahmerNetflix • • 28d ago

Since we’re sharing what stories we’d like to see represented for Monster, I raise you Tobin Bell for the lead role for Albert Fish.

Post image
151 Upvotes

I literally can’t think of anyone who would play this role better. The resemblance is uncanny!


r/DahmerNetflix • • 28d ago

Discussion Monster:The Dennis Rader Story

Post image
66 Upvotes

Thoughts?! I mean Ryan Murphy says his motivation with these is to ask societal questions and the btk is the perfect person for this he was a “good member of the community”


r/DahmerNetflix • • 28d ago

Monster: The Henry Lucas Story

Post image
15 Upvotes

> Had one of the worst childhoods ever documented

> Suffered from extreme mommy issues

> Killed his abusive mother

> Received electroshock therapy in a psychiatric hospital

> Became friends with Adam Walsh's killer

> Both drifted through more than five states (allegedly killing countless people)

> Fell in love with his partner's niece and ran away with her

> Killed her during a violent argument (the only murder for which he ever felt remorse)

> His case became the biggest hoax in American criminal history, giving hundreds of false confessions in exchange for good treatment, allowing the police to close dozens of cold cases

And that's not even half of his story. They'd have juice for a hundred episodes.


r/DahmerNetflix • • 28d ago

Discussion Which serial killer do you want to see next in Monster: Season five?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/DahmerNetflix • • Sep 19 '26

Discussion Does anyone think that Ed Kemper should be the next season?

Post image
221 Upvotes

r/DahmerNetflix • • Sep 18 '26

What do you think of Monster season 4 right now?

Post image
72 Upvotes

Has it released in most places yet because it came out in Australia yesterday night