So I was making apple pepper jelly with apple cider, lemon, sugar, pectin, peppers. I’ve made this before and it went smoothly. But I tried a new pectin this time. Up until now, I’d been using the original sure jell pectin in the yellow box. But I ran out and decided to try my new ball real fruit classic pectin. I did use a bit less than 6 tablespoons when scooping it in because I wanted to keep an eye on the texture, and I was gonna add more if I felt it wouldn’t set.
I’ve been using the spoon test with good results for many batches now. I stick a bunch of spoons in the freezer. When I want to test the texture, I dip a spoon in the cooking jelly, and let it sit in a dish for a minute or two. I come back to the spoon and check the texture. If it runs right off the spoon, I keep on cooking or maybe add more pectin if it keeps failing the spoon test.
What was super weird about this batch is that it passed the very first spoon test. Which never happens. I usually test it early. I expected it to fail the spoon test. But it was solid and didn’t run at all. It wasn’t hard or super thick, but it wasn’t soft or runny either. I thought it was odd at the time, so I spoon tested it again. It passed again. So I stopped cooking it and started canning it.
Did my usual water bath canning. I usually do 10 minutes, but I did 9 minutes because I was worried I’d already overcooked it.
And now….. both the next morning and now two days later, it’s not really set.
I mean…. It’s not straight up liquid. There’s some gel to it. But it’s really running. It does cling. But it should be firmer. I put my opened jar in the fridge, figuring that would make the texture what it should be. And it’s still really loose for a refrigerated jelly.
I just don’t get how it totally passed the spoon test but completely failed irl?
I really don’t want to have to recan it lol. But I think I have to. Is there anyway I can just…. Cook it for longer? Like re boil it with the current lids still on without opening them? Or do I have to dump it in a pot and add more pectin and re can it all like normal?
I’ll still wait another day or two to see if it magically firms up on its own.
Is it normal for different pectins to behave so differently?
I did notice this ball pectin was like light brown and textured , whereas the sure jell is pure white and fine.