r/BYUFootball • u/ObadiahDongleberry • 19h ago
BYU not a championship contender
BYU is not a championship contender until Kalani and the coaching staff stop making odd, goofy decisions midgame, and until they stop dropping punts.
The players are balling out of their minds right now. They are playing like vicious bloodthirsty warriors out there. During Iowa St., they play their guts out on a 7 minute drive and Kalani decides to not take 3 easy points, and they come away with nothing. Twice.
The defense plays their guts out and make a tough defensive stand. Then the punt returner is somehow not in position to field a punt and is sprinting over to catch a punt that is already trending out of bounds, and gives it right back.
We are neck and neck with Notre Dame coming down the stretch. Our defense is playing lights out. Fourth and long at our own 30. Fake punt?! What?? And it wasn't even close!! Its really pretty embarrassing.
We came very close to losing that game, and Iowa state had a shot of winning in the fourth quarter as well. Had we lost either of those games, it would have fully been on the heads of Kalani and whoever is making those decisions. We would not be number 2, we would be a laughing stock.
This team and talent this year is unparalleled in the history of BYU. The team absolutely dominated Iowa State, and dominated Notre Dame as well. We barely eeked out victories in both games because of Kalani's dum dum decisions and the punt fumbles.
Kalani kind of apologized after Iowa State, but then came right back and did it again with Notre Dame. I'm a bit perplexed and concerned. Thoughts?