r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Quiet_Classroom_7555 • 8m ago
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Connect_Cup5362 • 33m ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Newfound never joined Canada and gained Independence? Also it became Juche.
Newfoundland was a self governing British dominion until 1934, it joined Canada in confederation in 1949. What if instead Newfoundland refused to join and instead gained full independence. Then it became Juche. What happens with labrador, does it become a North Korea South Korea situation? How would this change the cold war? Newfoundland missile crisis? And what about the cod fisheries?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/ILikePizza_13 • 47m ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Bonnie and Clyde were given a second chance in the ambush?
What if they were given the chance to surrender?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/DealNo4347 • 52m ago
AlternateHistoryHub The Kapp Putsch was thwarted by a general strike, and they were forced to flee within four days. But what if, due to the changed circumstances, they were to return months later with an even bloodier coup?
As a result of the revolution that began in Germany in November 1918, Kaiser Wilhelm II was deposed and fled to the Netherlands. Friedrich Ebert's Social Democrats established a new republic.On November 11, they officially surrendered by signing an armistice with the Entente. In Bavaria, the departure of the king created a power vacuum, paving the way for a socialist republic.In the east, in the Poznan region, the Greater Poland uprising was launched by the Poles, and in January 1919 they succeeded in formally annexing the region to Poland.In the same year, the Bavarian Soviet Republic was suppressed by the Reichswehr and Freikorps, and the White Terror began in Munich. Deep inflation began in Germany.According to the Treaty of Versailles, signed in January, the army could not exceed 100,000 soldiers, the navy and air force were banned, Alsace-Lorraine was returned to France, and Poznan and Eastern Pomerania were given to Poland.Denmark took Holstein, the area west of the Rhine was demilitarized, and German troops were prohibited from entering the region.In March 1920, Freikorps troops staged a coup, the government fled to Stuttgart, and a government led by Kapp was formed. However, the coup collapsed four days later as a result of a four-day general strike in Berlin,The coup plotters fled the city, and the Reichswehr took control. While Germany was dealing with this, the Russian bear was approaching from the east.Tukhachevsky's Red's Pi in August Pilśudśki defeated the Polish army and entered Warsaw, effectively taking control of the country by the end of September, and the Polish Soviet Republic was proclaimed in October,The Red Army has reached the German border. The Weimar government's silence in the face of the approaching danger has paved the way for a new coup. If the Red's If they crossed the German border, there was no German force capable of stopping them like Rene, and furthermore, a coup by the already very powerful German communists was likely once the border was crossed.This possibility created immense fear among the Junkers and big capitalists who feared losing everything. France and the United Kingdom were not willing to remain silent in the face of this situation. The 100,000 limit imposed on the Reichswehr was lifted, and recruitment into the army began.At precisely this time, a clan within the Freikorps was in Jena,A group calling themselves the Black Shirts (Schwarze Hemden) raised the flag of rebellion And they began marching towards Berlin. The Entente, already facing the Red threat at their doorstep, did not oppose the coup; the coup leaders entered Berlin at the end of January.Coup leader Hermann Ehrhardt They formed a new provisional government, and the Weimar government fled to Denmark.Because the country was in such a difficult situation, the general strike that was planned for the Kapp coup did not happen, and they even managed to gain the support of the Junker class.The United Kingdom and France, however, did not see this government as a threat for the time being and supported it because of its strong stance against the communists.From then on, the next phase of events in the Russo-German War would be marked by the underground rebellions of the "Armia Bialego Orla" (White Eagle Army) founded by Pilśudśki in Poland.
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Achaemenid490 • 1h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Mojtaba Khamenei was straight?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/panjabiyat • 1h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Pakistan's Zia-ul-Haq was a Punjabi nationalist who conducted a special military operation in in Indian Punjab in 1984 to protect the ethnic kin of Pakistan's majority population, the Punjabis?
For context to people who think "Punjabi = Sikh", Punjabis are 60% Muslim, 20% Sikh and 20% Hindu and the vast majority of Punjabi Muslims live in Pakistan where we form the majority of the country's population.
Also, if this failed, Zia and the following governments would allow Khalistani militants to establish bases in Pakistan, create a government-in-exile, provide full diplomatic backing and recognise all Punjabi-speaking areas in India as Khalistan (including those areas outside Punjab state)? He will make supporting Khalistan a part of Pakistani Punjabi culture. Kashmir and Afghan mujahideen would become secondary to this.
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Friendly_Count_9529 • 2h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Tr8mp had the same (or largely the same) administration in 2024 as he did in 2016—would that significantly change his behavior? His first term wasn't as disastrous as the current situation, so perhaps the fault lies not just with him, but also with his administration?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Brilliant_Aspect7756 • 3h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Cuba started drone attacking Florida?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/OB1KENOB • 5h ago
Meme What if Chris Christie somersaulted right on top of Ben Carson here?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Minty-Boii • 5h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if radiation acted like how it does in Fallout?
Lasts an ungodly long amount of time, rapidly mutates creatures into giant versions of themselves, and turns people into ghouls with the right amount of exposure.
How would people react to these effects after Hiroshima & Nagasaki, and during the Cold War? How would this change the perception of nuclear energy and bombs?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/R_Arsx70 • 6h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if Attila the Hun didn’t die early?
This can lead to many things such as making peace and stopping invasions of the Roman Empire for various agreements or just doing even more conquest into the Roman Empire or moving north to the Scandinavian parts
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/honk222 • 7h ago
Meme What if San Marino joined the Axis?
What if the Most serene republic of San Marino joined the axis powers? This could happen at a couple diffrent points. One of these points could be in 1942 when the axis powers looked very powerful. This power could cause san marino to join the Axis in a bid to gain something (land, riches, ect). In a diffrent scenario the invasion of italy was stalled by the reincarnation of Napoleon or something and the germans would also have won in stalingrad. This would most likely result in the original Sammarinese fascist party staying in power for longer and still having ties with fascist italy. Later in mid 1944 the British empire would HEARTLESSLY bomb the glorious republic of San marino like they did OTL, this could then potentially cause the fascist government to join the axis for protection and as a protest against the bombing.
You can also make your own (probably more realistic) scenarios ofc.
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/darth_wallace • 8h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if North and South Vietnam became two different countries like what happened with Korea?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Living_Pay_8976 • 9h ago
AlternateHistoryHub How would it look different if Pangea never separated?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/MembershipProof8463 • 10h ago
AlternateHistoryHub Assuming that Christianity Never replaced it how do you think Norse paganism would have modernized?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Vivid-Minimum6925 • 11h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What would happen if all california territories was a country
When i say this i mean all california states/provinces.
so baja california, baja california sur, and republic of california all become one country.
California would carry most of the weight since in the us would still be one of the riches countries in the world and have a huge population, while having a giant film and tech industry.
but would they still inherit the problems that baja california has including the cartels and poverty , or with the social programs, huge budget for a potential milatery/police force,would fix it? or with its low population would it be hardly a problem ling term?
could this cause a chain of events where other states leave such as texas and hawaii?
I would say that this could be a potential world power with full access to the pacific and
Idk its just a hypothetical thats suck in my head and wanted to share it; i also want to hear what others got to say about it.
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/umok0 • 12h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if the Senussi order united the sahelian African states into a coalition during the 1890s?
What if, in 1890, Rabih az-Zubayr entered the service of the Kanem-Bornu Empire as a mercenary officer rather than setting out to establish his own state around Lake Chad? Around the same time, the Senussi Order decides that the growing European and mahidst presence in Africa posed a threat to the independence of the region’s traditional Muslim states and began working to build closer ties between them. Through diplomacy, trade agreements, religious influence, and mutual concerns over foreign expansion, the Senussi helps bring the Kanem-Bornu Empire, the Wadai Empire, the Darfur Sultanate, the Sultanate of Logone, The Dar Sila Sultanate and their tributary states into a loose defensive coalition, by 1895 the alliance has been ratified amongst said Muslim states.
what do you think would happen next? Could they maintain their independence?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/A_Soldier_Is_Born • 12h ago
Contest Submission What if every successful presidential assassination failed and every failed one succeeded
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Valarg • 12h ago
Meme What if the Republic Of Lemuria was real? How would their Government react to their ambassador to Chile being arrested for driving with an expired license?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Clear_Evening_5696 • 12h ago
KnowledgeHub What if dogs mewoed and cats barked?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/Finnark1510 • 13h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if one of NK test missiles hits Japan and as retribution, Japan manages to fully occupy North Korea before SK and US decides to react?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/ThatPatelGuy • 14h ago
AlternateHistoryHub What if we confiscated all of Elon Musk's wealth and gave it to his home country of South Africa?
Major political changes in the United States leads to the passage of extraordinary legislation targeting the concentration of private wealth. The American government successfully seizes the entirety of Elon Musk's personal fortune, including his shares in major companies, investments, and other assets. Rather than distributing the money domestically, the government reaches an international settlement that transfers the net proceeds of the confiscation to South Africa, Musk's country of birth.
The sudden influx of capital presents South Africa with an extraordinary opportunity. The country could use the money to modernize its electricity grid, expand railways and ports, improve water infrastructure, build housing, strengthen public education, and invest in domestic manufacturing.
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/MrsWolfgang • 14h ago
AlternateHistoryHub First Opium War (1839–1842) but China win war?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/MrsWolfgang • 14h ago
Contest Submission What if ronald Reagan went with Libya in 1986?
r/AlternateHistoryHub • u/No_Listen5962 • 15h ago
Video Idea What if The Chicxulub impactor Missed earth, leading to a Sapient Dinosaur race evolving?
shill for my alternate history project ahem: https://www.reddit.com/r/Multifandom/comments/1x50qmh/what_do_yall_think_of_my_silly_little_space/