r/fivethirtyeight • • 5d ago

Discussion Megathread Weekly Discussion Megathread

68 Upvotes

The 2026 midterms will soon be upon us, and there is much to discuss among the nerds here at r/FiveThirtyEight. Use this discussion thread to share, debate, and discuss whatever you wish. Unlike individual posts, comments in the discussion thread are not required to be related to political data or other 538 mainstays. Regardless, please remain civil and keep this subreddit's rules in mind. The discussion thread refreshes every Monday.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 5h ago

Polling Industry/Methodology [Lakshya Jain] Got our final poll of the cycle back @TheArgumentMag . I've just never seen the bottom fall out *this badly* for a party before. There is nothing — and I mean *nothing* — good for Republicans in this one. It might well be our ugliest one yet for them.

Thumbnail x.com
234 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 5h ago

Politics With Two Weeks to Go, House Republicans Are Facing A Blue Tsunami

Thumbnail
plusminus4.substack.com
90 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 16h ago

Politics USPS bins with elections ballots discovered in dumpsters at Seattle’s Golden Gardens

Thumbnail
kiro7.com
180 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 7h ago

Poll Results 2028 Democratic Presidential Primary Oct 12 - 19, 2026: Don’t know 45.35% (+33.2%), Kamala Harris 12.13%, Gavin Newsom 8.97%, Pete Buttigieg 6.54%, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 5.5%, Jon Ossoff 4.07%, Mark Kelly 2.51%. The New York Times/Siena University 1170 RV

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
34 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 16h ago

Politics Young Men Who Helped Get Trump Elected Are ‘Blackpilling’ Out of Politics

120 Upvotes

Bloomberg Article || archive version

The linked article talks about young men who voted for Trump but are now becoming disillusioned. While there might be other factors the primary cause appears to be economic. I'll also grant that this is an anecdote but there is lots of non-anecdotal evidence that this is a widespread feeling. The article starts with:

(Dallas Cruze earns) $85,000 as a health and safety coordinator for construction sites, he will still be around $350 shy of paying his bills this month.

Cruze works in Detroit and is a S Carolina resident. The point I want to make is one about personal, micro, economies and a bit of a prediction:

Cruze earns 85k. I am assuming he is single (no ring on the pictured left hand). He gets about 7k a month. I would assume that about 1k of that goes to the government for taxes.

On a global level a person working with a take home pay of 6,000 USD is not poor. Even for the US that isn't all that bad (I am well aware that there are much more wealthy people). Detroit is also just not a particularly expensive city.

That Cruze is 350 USD short on this month's bills is more an issue of budgeting than pay. Increasing his pay by a few hundred bucks a month isn't the solution. To get to where Cruze probably has: a car payment that is expensive, cc debt, and maybe student loans (or he has a house in S Carolina that should be sold).

The issue for Cruze isn't that he doesn't have income; he actually has quite a bit of income. The issue is that debt accumulation in the US has become exceptionally easy. Highly leveraged lifestyles have become much more normalized both by US peers and by the banking institutions that make the loans. CC debt (plus pay later debt that is basically the same) is super high (in to the 1.2 T range). Negative equity car trade-ins have become standard practice for dealerships (average negative equity on trade-ins has gotten to 7k).

Cruze probably doesn't care about the unemployment rate; lowering that to 3% (it is 4.2% now) isn't going to move the needle. Bringing inflation down to 2% would probably be good though 3.7% for CPI is far from terrible. These typically reported on economic indicators won't make much of a difference for Cruze. What does make a difference is if the dealership can get him to trade in the Chevy truck for a GMC that has 'only' 200 USD more a month in payments on a 96 month loan.

Cruze's economy is much more affected by trends in a finance system that seems to take a back seat in the current political discourse. It also seems to be outside of anything that a potential Democratic (or GOP for that matter) president + congress would actually do. Until these problems (an over leveraged lifestyle) are fixed on a societal level I don't really see anyone feeling positively about the economy in the long term.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 22h ago

Election Model The Cook Political Report is moving the Ohio Governor's race from Toss Up to Lean Democrat

Thumbnail cookpolitical.com
346 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 17h ago

Poll Results Polling trend: Democrats are now flooding possible pickup House districts with sponsored polls

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

In Republican leaning districts (such as pictured districts of CO-5, OH-10, FL-13, KY-6, OH-15, MT-1, NY-21, NV-2, PA-8) the vast majority of polls are Democrat sponsored and shows highly encouraging results for Democrats, usually their candidate winning or sometimes trailing narrowly in a closer than expected race. Is this evidence of intentional poll flooding strategy intended to increase voter turnout? They have very prominently targeted districts like these with political spending, after all, and it seems likely that these polls showing good results are just part of the strategy. In past elections there was a lot of talk of Republican poll flooding in key races, are Democrats doing the exact same thing Republicans were being accused of then?


r/fivethirtyeight • • 19h ago

Poll Results California 2028 Presidential Primaries poll (McLaughlin 10/20): AOC leads, followed by Buttigieg

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 17h ago

Politics Podcast Nate Silver breaks down how likely Democrats are to win the midterms

Thumbnail
youtu.be
54 Upvotes

Nate covers a lot of topics here. He discusses the Fox and Marist LV/RV differences around 6 minutes in. He discusses the Wedgwood Polls scandal. And talks about the likelihood of split ticket voting.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 23h ago

Poll Results Rasmussen Texas Poll: Talarico 45%, Paxton 45%

Thumbnail
rasmussenreports.com
153 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 20h ago

Poll Results Kansas-02 Poll; DCCC TaAD; R+3; 2024 vote: Trump+19.7

Post image
83 Upvotes

The internal also shows the district voting Hamilton 47-45 and Holscher 48-47.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 21h ago

Poll Results Nebraska Senate; GBAO (D aligned & Indie sponsored); 800LV; Osborn INDIE +1

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 22h ago

Discussion Is it possible that Gina Hinojosa can pull Katie Hobbs and unexpectedly win in Texas?

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results South Carolina US Senate Oct 15 - 21, 2026: Annie Andrews (D) 45% (+1.0%), Darline Graham (R) 44%, Don't know/Someone else 10%. Impact Research (B/C)800 LV. Sponsor: Fresh Start SC PAC (D)

Thumbnail freshstartpac.org
173 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results [Politico] Trump is motivating Dems more than Repubs

Thumbnail politico.com
113 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Politics Trump DOJ sues to block Alaska US Senate results if Republican incumbent loses

Thumbnail
edition.cnn.com
175 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 23h ago

Poll Results Mississippi US Senate Oct 21 - 22, 2026: Cindy Hyde-Smith (R) 43% (+3.0%), Scott Colom (D) 40%, Don't know 9%, Ty Pinkins (I) 6%, Would not vote 2%. Change Research (C+) 842 LV. Sponsor: Government that Works PAC (D)

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results Texas TPOR poll: Talarico 51-Paxton 47; Abbott 51-Hinojosa 48

220 Upvotes

Senate
🔵 Talarico: 51%
🔴 Paxton: 47%

Governor
🔴 Abbott: 51%
🔵 Hinojosa: 48%

Lt. Gov
🔴 Patrick: 50%
🔵 Goodwin: 47%

AG
🔴 Middleton: 50%
🔵 Johnson: 48%

Comptroller
🔴 Huffines: 50%
🔵 Eckhardt: 48%

Ag Commissioner
🔴 Sheets: 50%
🔵 Tucker: 48%

Land Commissioner
🔴 Buckingham: 49%
🔵 Flores: 48%

Railroad Commissioner
🔴 French: 50%
🔵 Rosenthal: 48%

Conducted 10/15-10/18, 969 LV

FULL RESULTS HERE: https://texaspublicopinionresearch.substack.com/p/october-poll-in-texas-general-election


r/fivethirtyeight • • 7m ago

Discussion Useful data on the Texas early vote

Post image
• Upvotes

https://theoelections.com/early-vote

Note that the D vote increases with each decrement in "primaries voted in", while it is flat for the GOP. It is therefore reasonable to assume that zero primaries would follow the same trend, particularly since this most likely youth vote. Allocating no primary with the same proportion of vote as 1 primary changes the pct to 54-47 D


r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results [G. Elliott Morris ~ Strength in Numbers]Low-information voters have turned hardest against Trump and the GOP

Thumbnail
gelliottmorris.com
150 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results [University of Houston] Poll of Latino and Rural Texas Voters: Among Latino Voters - James Talarico 52%, Ken Paxton 41% and Gina Hinojosa 53%, Greg Abbott 43% | Among Rural Voters: Ken Paxton 65%, James Talarico 27% and Greg Abbott 66%, Gina Hinojosa 29% among likely voters

Thumbnail houstonpublicmedia.org
92 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Politics Corruption is voters' top issue ahead of midterm election, CNBC survey shows

Thumbnail
cnbc.com
143 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Politics Cook Political Report changes the ratings of an additional 19 House seats, all in favor of the Democrats

Thumbnail cookpolitical.com
164 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Poll Results Iowa Senate; InsiderAdvantage (R aligned); 1200LV; Hinson R+2

Post image
64 Upvotes