House Rules, Part 1
I woke the next morning to a knock on my door.
I always slept naked, so I made sure the sheets had me covered before I called out, “Who’s there?”
The door opened and Ethan came in.
“Oh, you're not up yet.”
He walked over and sat down on the edge of the bed.
“I was gonna ask if you wanted to get some breakfast.”
He slid one hand under the covers, and I smiled up at him.
“You want another round?” I asked, teasing him.
“Yesterday was quite nice. I don’t see why we can’t do that again.”
“I guess I could give it a try.”
He lifted away my duvet and had a peek at what he hadn't seen yesterday.
“You are beautiful, you know that?”
I smiled at him.
“I know it now.”
I spread my legs as he moved across my stomach, then stretched my arms over my head and yawned.
“You are lucky I'm horny in the morning, Ethan. Otherwise, I might have been harder to convince.”
“I am sure you're horny a lot more than just in the morning.”
I wasn't sure what he meant by that, but I smiled and moaned as he slipped two fingers inside me.
I fumbled with his pants, trying to get them off. He helped me, and soon I had his cock in my mouth.
He had a lot more control from where he was positioned this time. He was being a bit rougher, not letting me control the pace.
Well, I guess he couldn't control himself.
I let him have a few deep strokes in my mouth. I gagged, but I knew how to avoid throwing up, and Ethan seemed to really like the reaction.
I sat up on my knees, wiped my mouth, and turned around to show him my butt.
That should make it obvious what I wanted next.
“God, your ass really is the most beautiful thing,” he said as he held my hip with one hand.
It felt just as good hearing it today as it had yesterday.
He moved into me, and my toes tightened as warmth spread through me from the feeling of being wanted.
Then I felt his thumb against my asshole again.
This was going to be a thing with him, I guessed.
I leaned back and spread my cheeks.
He got the hint.
I loved his obsession with my ass.
“You like playing with my ass, Ethan?”
“I can feel my dick moving inside you with my thumb. It feels amazing.”
“Mmmm...”
I did a Kegel and felt Ethan's surprise.
“Feels good?”
“Your pussy is amazing, Lillian.”
My cheeks grew warm. I loved hearing him say these things.
I reached back between my legs and started playing with his balls, just like last night.
And just like last night, he started to speed up.
I had this guy down.
I felt him come, and I made sure to hold his balls tightly until he was all done.
I fell back onto my bed.
“Okay, I will need a shower before I go anywhere. You still want me for breakfast?”
Ethan looked at me splayed out on the bed.
“If you need a shower first, I won't have time. I got a lecture in thirty, and it's a fifteen-minute walk. Raincheck?”
I nodded.
“Of course. Lectures are important. Go. Don't let my sexy body distract you.”
He got dressed, gave me a quick kiss on the mouth, and left.
I grabbed a towel from one of my boxes and wrapped it around me. I opened the door and headed toward the showers.
I saw Mateo standing in the doorway to the kitchen area, and then felt a tug at my back.
My towel fell away.
I was standing naked in the hallway, with Mateo looking straight at me.
I froze.
I turned and tried to unhook my towel, but it was twisted around the door handle.
Damn.
I gave up on the project and retreated to my room.
I hid under the duvet again.
Shit. Mateo had seen me naked.
My first full day here, and two of the boys had already seen me naked.
This was unprofessional, Lin. We need to do better.
Find your bathrobe, for one.
There was a knock on my door.
“Yes?” I said from under my duvet.
Mateo poked his head through the door.
“You left your towel. Can I put it on your sink?”
My head was outside the duvet, and I gave him a nod.
He came into my room, folded the towel, and put it on the sink.
“I really didn't see much.”
“How much did you see?” I countered.
“Okay, maybe saying not much was wrong. But, like, what I saw was really good. Nothing to be embarrassed or ashamed of.”
He continued, now fully rambling.
“Like, your tits are great. Perfect size. And your ass is nice and firm. Your stomach is firm, with just that tiny bit of fat. That's the sexiest part.”
I looked down under the covers at my stomach, trying to find the sexy part.
“And your legs are nice and lean.”
“Okay, enough talking about my naked body, Mateo. You clearly saw a lot.”
It was getting really hot under this duvet.
“Yes, but it was all very impressive. It affected me.”
“It what?”
“Affected me. You know, stirred my loins.”
“Stirred your loins?”
“Yeah, got me all hot and heavy.”
I rolled my eyes at that.
“So, you and Ethan, then?”
I gave an unconvincing, “Mm.”
God, it was so hot.
“You his girlfriend now?”
“Working on that.”
Fuck it. He had already seen my boobs. I couldn't stand it anymore.
I flipped the duvet down to my stomach, feeling instant relief from the heat.
Mateo suddenly went quiet and still.
I looked at him, somewhat annoyed.
“What? You've already seen them.”
“Yeah, but it's like seeing a sunrise. You never get tired of it.”
I looked down at my tits. One was a bit bigger than the other. The areolas were a bit too big compared to the nipples, and the smaller one had a series of little freckles the other one didn't.
“Not exactly a sunrise,” I replied.
“I don't know what's the matter with your eyes, Lillian. They are beauty incarnate. They look so soft.”
I lifted one boob with my hand.
“Yes, they are soft.”
“Can I feel them?” Mateo asked.
It was just feeling boobs. What was the harm in that? He had already seen them. Copping a feel didn't matter, and it's not like I had a boyfriend. I could show my tits to whomever I liked.
“Sure,” I said.
He came and sat down on the bed next to me. I lifted my arms over my head, presenting him with my boobs.
He put a hand on each one, his hands cold against my warm, sweaty boobs. He squeezed them softly before running his thumbs over my nipples.
I drew a breath at that.
Okay, playing with my nipples was a bit more than just feeling them, but I did offer them up. It was only fair that he could play with them.
I leaned back on my bed as he fondled my breasts. I liked the feeling, and I liked how he thought they were like a sunrise.
I closed my eyes and enjoyed myself.
Suddenly, I felt a mouth on my left breast. I opened my eyes to see Mateo sucking on my nipple.
Okay, that was not feeling it...
But it did feel good.
I really should stop this.
But it wasn't hurting anyone. Mateo was enjoying it. I was enjoying it.
Closing my eyes again, I decided to just enjoy the attention.
I started to touch myself as Mateo played with me, thinking about how I had just had sex with Ethan. His cum was still inside me, and now I had another guy sucking on my boob.
It felt powerful being wanted by two guys at the same time. Being lusted after.
Mateo's hand joined mine between my legs.
I wondered if Mateo would go down on me, even though Ethan had just been there.
I lifted the rest of the duvet and let him see my whole body. He had already seen it, so that wasn't much of a reveal.
My boob slipped out of his mouth, and I gave his head a gentle push toward my stomach.
As he moved downward, I shifted sideways on the bed so he was between my legs.
He was fingering me, but I grabbed both sides of his head and pulled him toward me.
He was licking my clit with steady strokes, but I wanted him lower.
“Use your tongue inside me, Mateo. Nice and deep.”
He moved lower without protesting, his thumb taking over for his tongue on my clit.
I felt him licking Ethan's cum from inside me. It reminded me of Mia, but his tongue was much larger and rougher.
He must know what he's doing, right? Maybe Mateo was bi? He certainly seemed to be enjoying himself.
I felt the pressure rising. I wasn't going to hold out much longer.
I kept rocking steadily against Mateo's face until I came, making sure to squeeze as much of Ethan's cum into Mateo's mouth as possible.
He lifted his head and looked at me.
“You came?”
I nodded.
“You did good, Mateo. It was a good one.”
He looked around, a bit uncertain for once.
“You want me to return the favor?” I asked in a whisper.
“Would you?”
“Maybe... I need some promises from you.”
Mateo stood and dropped his pants and underwear.
His dick was much thicker than Ethan's, if a bit shorter. Nice, though. Uncut, with a bit of hair, but kept tidy.
“Anything you want, Lillian.”
I reached out and started to stroke Mateo, making the foreskin move back and forth over the head. I had only ever seen uncut men in porn, so I had to explore how this thing worked.
“I need some rules about you and me.”
I started to lick off the pre-cum that had begun to come out of him.
“Sure. Anything you say. Promise.”
“I don't want you to do anything with me if Ethan is in the apartment. I don't want him to know.”
“That makes sense.”
I moved up and down a few times on his dick, just to show I was holding to the agreement.
“And I always want to come first. Your dick gets no attention until I've had a release on your face.”
It had felt so good when Mateo went down on me after Ethan. I wanted to lock this down.
I pulled him in deep before he could answer, making him moan.
“So? That works for you?”
“Will I get to fuck you?”
“Depends on how good you get me off first.”
“Okay. Keep it a secret, and always go down on you until you come before I get anything.”
A feeling of power came over me. I got myself a side guy. Someone willing to do things for me, someone I had control over.
I could get to like this.
I put more effort into the blowjob after his agreement. One hand on his balls, the other playing with his asshole. All the motion came from my mouth.
I kept up a steady pace until he started to warn me that he was about to come.
Then he pulled out.
“What the...”
I felt warm liquid hit my face in pulses, and I let him finish before I spoke up.
“And an additional rule. No more facials. Cum belongs on the inside, not on my face or clothing. For this facial, next time you come over, I'll be sitting on your face.”
“Oh, sorry. Let me get you a towel.”
He ran over to the sink, grabbed my shower towel, and handed it to me.
I wiped myself clean as best I could. Crud, it had gotten in my hair.
“You got it in my hair, you freak. Just leave. Remember the rules. If you break them again, it will cost you.”
He backed out of the room, looking like a mixture of happy and ashamed.
I lay back down on the bed.
How are we gonna handle this?
Two guys, and one we're trying to tie down. Need to keep it on the down low and try to get more one-on-one time with Ethan.
And keeping it secret is definitely top of the pile right now.
I found my robe in one of my boxes and attempted the shower trip once more.
I still had a few hours before my one lecture of the day, and I was very certain that I was going to attend that, at least.
The water was warm, as promised, and I felt refreshed when I got back to my room and dressed.
I went into the kitchen to get some brunch and saw Noah sitting there.
“Hi, Noah. How's it going?”
He looked up from his laptop.
“Fine. Settling in okay?”
“Yeah. Everyone's been very welcoming.”
He looked at me for a second longer than necessary.
“Seems that way.”
I wasn't sure what that meant.
“Coffee?”
“Please.”
He got up and poured me a cup.
“Milk?”
“Just a little.”
He added some and handed it over. I took a sip.
“Thank you.”
“You heading to campus today?”
“Yeah. I have one lecture this afternoon.”
He nodded and sat back down in front of his laptop.
“What about you?”
“Working on a project. Got a deadline today.”
“That explains the laptop.”
He looked down at it.
“Does it?”
“You've been staring at it since I came in.”
“I was staring at you for a little while.”
I stopped with the coffee halfway to my mouth.
“What?”
“When you came in.”
“Oh.”
He smiled slightly.
“Relax, Lillian. I'm joking.”
“Are you?”
He shrugged.
I took another sip of coffee.
I wasn't quite sure what to make of Noah.
“So, how long have you lived here?”
“Two years.”
“And you've survived living with all these people?”
“Yeah. Once you get to know them, you kinda know where everyone is.”
“Oh, predictable, are they?”
“That's a creepy word, but perhaps?”
“So people like Mateo? Predictable?”
“Mateo loves to please. And I think he might have a thing for Ethan.”
I nearly choked on my coffee.
“Really?”
“Maybe. But he shows no signs of being gay. Bi, perhaps? He hasn't dated anyone since he moved in.”
That made me think.
“You'll figure him out.”
“Oh?”
“You've been here less than a day. Give it time.”
I drank some more coffee.
“So what am I?”
His fingers stopped on the keyboard.
“What?”
“Figured me out yet?”
He studied me for a moment.
“Too early. Best guess, you're likable. People seem to like you.”
“Nothing about being smart or funny?” I joked.
“No, but you're interesting.”
He went back to typing.
I wasn't sure if Noah hadn't understood my joke, or if he had and was trying to tell me something.
I decided it was time to leave.
“See you later, Noah. Who's cooking today?”
“Mateo. He loves to cook, so he usually does it several times a week.”
“He likes to please?”
“He sure does.”
My lecture was about Futurism, an art movement from the early twentieth century, with lots of experimentation, abstraction, and some rather unpleasant right-wing extremist ideas.
I enjoyed the art considerably more than the ideology.
Since I was already on campus, I decided to head to the library and get some reading done.
I headed home around seven after a particularly productive day.
This was going exactly as planned.
I could smell that dinner was on when I got back.
I stepped into the kitchen and discovered that I still had a few minutes to spare. Mateo was cooking, as expected. He gave me a quick look, smiled and nodded, then returned to the cooking.
Good. He was sticking to the rules.
I headed to the bathroom to clean up quickly before dinner.
When I returned to the kitchen, more people had gathered.
I sat down next to Sophie and across from Ethan.
“How was your day?”
“Excellent. Close to perfect, actually.”
I smiled at that.
“Good to hear.”
As the food arrived at the table, Mateo sat down next to me. It was the only open seat, but I still felt like he was a bit too close for comfort.
I looked over at him.
He was busy serving himself food and didn't even acknowledge me.
Good.
Ethan was here. Mateo knew the rules.
Still, I wished there had been another open seat.
“So, what's everyone doing tonight?” Sophie asked.
“Going out,” Ollie said.
Mateo looked across the table at him.
“That's very descriptive.”
“It was intended to be.”
“Date?”
“Drinks.”
“Date drinks?”
Ollie sighed.
“People from class.”
“Sexy people from class?”
“Mateo.”
“Okay, okay.”
Sophie laughed.
“Dev's coming back to mine.”
Dev nodded.
“I've been informed.”
“You were invited.”
“I was informed that I was invited.”
“What about you?” Sophie asked me.
“Nothing. I was planning on unpacking.”
Mateo looked disappointed.
“It's Friday.”
“I moved in yesterday.”
“Exactly. First Friday in the new place.”
“I've had a busy twenty-four hours.”
Mateo glanced at me.
I gave him a warning look.
He immediately became very interested in his food.
Good boy.
“What about you, Ethan?” I asked.
“Nothing planned.”
That was good to hear.
“And Noah?”
Noah didn't look up from his food.
“Project.”
“Still?”
“Deadline.”
“You're the one staying home too,” Sophie pointed out.
“If I get one month's rent refunded from my landlord and my deposit back, I'll take you out for drinks.”
“Just me?”
“Sure. Girls' night.”
“I'm remembering you said that.”
“The money isn't coming.”
“Still remembering.”
By the time dinner was finished, Ollie had disappeared into his room to get ready, and Sophie was already trying to convince Dev that they should leave.
I thanked Mateo for the food and headed to my room to continue unpacking.
The closet here was actually impressively big. I fit all my clothes into it and still had almost half of it empty.
I guess I could store other stuff in there.
Maybe get more stuff?
I was almost done unpacking the last box when my phone made a sound.
It was Ethan.
Movie?
I smiled at that. Yeah... movie.
When I entered the living room, I noticed that both Mateo and Noah were there with Ethan.
Ethan made room for me to sit next to him. I sat down, smiling at the other two, before unfolding a blanket over myself.
Tonight's movie was The Nice Guys. It was surprisingly fun, and we got to the point where the protest party in the Hollywood Hills started turning into a conspiracy when I felt Ethan's fingers stroking my leg.
I was wearing a dress, and my legs were bare.
One of the reasons I wanted a blanket.
I glanced around the room to see if anyone was paying attention.
Noah was still on his laptop, paying no attention to the movie. Mateo was very intently not looking at me.
Fine. Let's play this game then, Ethan.
I lifted my legs onto the couch and sat cross-legged, leaning a little closer to Ethan so he didn't have to reach.
Ethan understood the assignment, and I soon felt him stroking me through my underwear.
I decided I just wanted to enjoy the feeling. I leaned back and let Ethan continue, keeping an eye on the other two.
I caught Mateo looking down at the blanket once. Noah didn't seem to be paying us any attention.
It didn't take long before my underwear was pushed aside and I felt a finger start to push its way in.
Okay, light stroking and some fun in front of people I could handle, but this was going to make me moan if he continued.
I tried to shift away from Ethan, but his arm held me close.
What on earth was he doing?
I bit my lip to keep myself from moaning, but I couldn't stop the quick intake of breath.
Noah looked up, and our eyes met.
I glanced over at Mateo. He was keeping his eyes very firmly fixed on the TV.
I looked back at Ethan with a what are you doing? glare.
He just smiled at me. He seemed to be really enjoying this. As he looked me in the eye, I felt a second finger slip in and bend.
I let out a moan that I tried to disguise as a yawn, stretching my arms above my head.
“Okay, I'm beat. I think I'll head to bed.”
Mateo and Noah said, almost in chorus, “Night.”
Ethan finally let me go, smiling as I got up and walked away.
Once I was behind Noah and out of his line of sight, I looked back at Ethan and mouthed, You are crazy.
Then I headed into the bathroom.
As I brushed my teeth, I kept wondering what Ethan was trying to pull. Did he want me to come in front of his housemates? Did he know about Mateo?
I washed my face and headed back to my bedroom, where I found Ethan lying on my bed.
I stared at him and closed the door behind me.
“What are you doing?” I whispered loudly, but still quietly enough that nobody outside should have been able to hear me.
“I figured you were horny. Thought I could stop by and help.” He lowered his voice to mimic me, without actually whispering.
I straddled him, still fully clothed, and pinned his hands to the bed.
“No, Ethan. Why were you fingering me in front of Noah and Mateo? Did you want me coming in the living room while they watched me?”
“That would have been a funny scene,” he said, laughing.
“No, it would not.” I hit his chest in mock anger.
“I like it when you're a little embarrassed. Put under pressure. I like seeing that in a girl. That oh shit look when she realizes she's about to embarrass herself.”
“So you wanted them to notice? Is this some sort of guy ‘marking his territory’ thing? You gonna pee on me next?”
“You like that? If you want, I can offer that service as well.”
“No, you sicko. You want your housemates to know we're fucking? Some sort of power trip?”
“Maybe that's it. I don't really know why I like it. But I do, and you seem adventurous enough, so I thought I'd give it a try.”
Adventurous, was I? That was a positive, at least. Who didn't want an adventurous girlfriend?
“You've done this with other girls, then?”
“Variations. Some girls are really into it. But I like it more when they're hesitant, but still go along with it. Like getting sent a nude. It means more when you know she took it just to please you, rather than picking one from a folder of existing nudes.”
“So it's the hesitation that gets you off?”
“Yeah. I like it when they do it despite not really wanting to. I know it's messed up, but I like what I like.”
“So you'd like it more if they accidentally caught me naked than if I went streaking?”
“Yeah. You get it.”
“I think I can understand that... But I think you should talk to me before trying something like that again.”
“That would ruin all the fun. It needs to be spontaneous.”
I drew a deep breath.
“This is gonna be really difficult, Ethan.”
“I know. That's what makes it a turn-on.”
“Okay, how about this? I buy one of those remote-controlled vibrators.”
I narrowed my eyes at him.
“And?”
“We go get coffee.”
“Oh.”
“You wear it. I get the remote.”
I stared at him for a moment.
“And I don't know when you're going to use it?”
He smiled.
“And I want to film it. I won't share anything. But I want you to know that I can watch it over and over.”
Fuck... that was hot.
I wanted to ask for something in exchange. Set some condition. Make him earn it somehow.
But my mind went blank because I really wanted to do this.
“Okay. Coffee date tomorrow, then?”
“787 Coffee?”
“A bit crowded?”
“That's the point,” he said with a smile.
“What do I get in exchange?”
“A coffee?”
I punched him in the chest again.
“If I make it through the whole coffee date and get back home, I get to keep the vibrator.”
“Deal.”
He rolled me over, and suddenly he was on top of me, holding my hands down against the bed.
“And if you quit before we're done with coffee?”
I looked up at him. “You take it back?”
He smiled. “No. I pick what you wear next time.”
I swallowed and bit my lip before giving him a nod.
“Deal.”
I broke free from his grip and started unbuttoning my dress. Ethan got the idea and started undressing as well.
My underwear was soaked, and I threw them aside as he moved back between my legs.
He was already inside me when the words started coming out.
Not soft. Not careful. Just fucking, talking through the next day like it was part of the sex.
“They’re going to look at me,” I said, my voice catching when he thrust up hard. “Whoever’s behind the counter. I’ll be sitting there with that thing in me, and you’ll just... decide when.”
My thighs were shaking. God, this was hot.
He didn’t slow down. Just watched my face.
“You’ll try to hide it,” he said.
“Yeah. Cross my legs. Look at my phone. Pretend I’m reading something important while you’re making me...”
I had to stop and bite my lip. The angle was too good, and I was already close.
“While you’re making me come in public.”
He smiled. That same shitty smile from earlier.
I kept going. Gave him the version he wanted.
“I’ll be scared. Trying not to make a sound. Trying not to look like I’m about to fall apart in the coffee shop. And you’ll know. You’ll be watching me fail.”
I was getting wetter just describing how exposed I’d be.
“What if I can’t stay quiet?” I whispered. “What if someone notices and I have to stand up and walk out with it still going?”
“Then you walk out,” he said. “And I film that too.”
Fuck.
I arched under him. Couldn’t help it. I pictured myself leaving the café, legs unsteady, face flushed, trying to act normal while everyone was looking.
“I’ll try to hide it,” I said again, softer. Roleplaying the hesitant girl even while I was taking him like I needed it. “I’ll look down. Keep my legs together. Pretend nothing’s happening. Even though you’ll know exactly how close I am.”
He fucked me harder for that.
I kept talking.
“People will see me. I’ll be trying so hard not to come, and you’ll just... keep going until I can’t hide it anymore.”
My voice broke on the last word. The orgasm hit messy and sudden, my thighs locking around him, that stupid little sound escaping before I could swallow it.
He didn’t stop. Just kept moving through it, watching me shake.
“That’s the look,” he said. Quiet. Almost fond. “That’s the face everyone will see tomorrow.”
I was still trembling when he came.
Afterward, he stayed on top of me for a second longer, his hands still holding mine down.
I stared at the ceiling, breathing hard. Already thinking about tomorrow and wondering if I was gonna fail on purpose.
Or show Ethan how much control I had.
“Coffee date,” I muttered. “You’re on.”
He just laughed and kissed the side of my neck.
“I need a shower. Tomorrow at two?”
I nodded. “See you tomorrow.”
I waited a minute until I heard the shower start. Then I picked up my phone and sent Mateo a message.
Come here.
Ethan was in the shower. Close enough to not being in the apartment.
About thirty seconds later, my door opened and Mateo stepped inside.
I was on my back, naked, legs spread. I crooked a finger at him, then pointed to the bed.
He lay down, staring up at the ceiling.
I climbed over his face, keeping my eyes on his.
“You looked at us when Ethan was playing with me earlier.”
He couldn’t speak, but gave a small nod.
“I told you not to do that.”
Another nod.
“Bad boys don’t get any help finishing.”
His eyes went a little sad. Maybe ashamed.
“But if you clean me up properly, I’ll let you jerk off into my hand.”
The sad look disappeared. A second later, he attacked the task with considerably more enthusiasm.
I grabbed his hair as he continued, grinding against him, making sure to smear him with Ethan’s cum.
When I came, I squeezed my legs around his head, cutting off his air. When I finally relaxed, I could hear him gasping.
“Okay, get on your knees on the floor. Let's get this over with.”
I sat on the bed and watched Mateo stroke himself for me.
I really enjoyed this. I'd never had someone be so... submissive to me. It wasn't exactly a turn-on, but a comfort. A warm feeling of empowerment.
I decided Mateo was never going to fuck me.
But I really liked having him around.
“If you ever want to fuck me, Mateo, you're gonna have to do much better than that.”
He groaned when I said it.
“If you don't improve your behavior, you might not even be allowed to come next time.”
That pushed him over the edge, and I held my hand around his cock to catch his load.
When he was done, I opened my hand in front of his face.
“Eat this, please.”
He started licking my hand, getting every drop I'd caught.
When he was done, I put my foot against his face and pushed him away.
“Get out. I'll call you if I need you again.”
Mateo left in a hurry, barely getting his pants back on before closing the door behind him.
I crawled under my sheets.
This could work.
I could balance two guys. Easy.