Beyond Believers Episode 4 is out now! Allegra recaps season 2 episode 4. Featuring VHS tapes, prison, a sleazy wrestling manager, and plenty of ghosts.

Apple podcasts | Spotify | RSS feed

On February 6, 1998, Beyond Belief: Fact Or Fiction aired a segment called "The Wall," which was revealed at the end of the show to be true!

The segment featured a man accused of a crime he didn't commit without a fair trial. The accused man left a bloody handprint on the wall of the interrogation room, stating that it would remain there forever as proof of his innocence.

In a rare case of a "true" Beyond Belief story actually being substantiated, this story actually has kind of a cool real-life mystery behind it.

Background - the jail and the Molly Maguires

The Old Carbon County Jail was built in 1869-1870 and served as Carbon County Pennsylvania's prison until 1995. It contains 27 cells and basement dungeon cells, which were used for solitary confinement until as recently as 1980.

The Old Jail is best known for its connection to the Molly Maguires, a secret society of Irish coal miners who fought against the oppressive working conditions in Pennsylvania's anthracite coal fields during the 1870s.

The trials of the Molly Maguires were highly controversial, and many historians now believe that the trials were deeply unfair. As one Carbon County judge later noted: "The Molly Maguire trials were a surrender of state sovereignty. A private corporation initiated the investigation through a private detective agency. A private police force arrested the alleged defenders, and private attorneys for the coal companies prosecuted them. The state provided only the courtroom and the gallows."

Executions & the mysterious handprint

Between 1877-1879, six men were hanged at the Old Jail. Before his execution, one of the condemned men (believed to be Thomas Fisher) placed his hand on the dirty cell floor and then firmly pressed it against the wall of Cell #17, declaring: "This handprint will remain as proof of my innocence."

Remarkably, despite numerous attempts to remove it—including washing, painting, and even rebuilding parts of the wall—the handprint remains visible to this day!

Listen to Beyond Believers Episode 3 where we recap this segment and more!

Apple podcasts | Spotify | RSS feed

Additional links:

Read more about the Old Carbon County Jail

Watch the Beyond Belief episode

Mine by far is "Red Eyed Creature" from Season 2 episode 12. It features a villainous nanny named Maggie, who is revealed to have glowing red eyes, which means she is Evil? And then, get this, they claim the story is TRUE

What segments have stuck with you, either for their ridiculousness or their creepiness?

Beyond Believers episode 3 is out now! Listen on your pod app or at this link.

This episode features the following segments: The Wall; The Chalkboard; The Getaway; The Prescription; and Summer Camp.

Will Allegra correctly guess the facts versus fictions and pull ahead?! And how long will it take Jonathan to walk up to the camera in the opening shot? Listen to find out!

This is one of two things that are allowed in a Beyond Belief intro - it's this or an optical illusion.

The first two episodes of our podcast "Beyond Believers" are out now! Check them out wherever you get your podcasts or at this link.

We decided to start with Season 2 of the show, as that's when our beloved Jonathan Frakes comes into the fray(ke).

In podcast episode 1, Sofia recaps Beyond Belief Season 2 Episode 1! Segments include: The Plane, The Gun, The Portrait, The Pass, and The Caller.

Featuring memorable moments such as:

The word "psychic" floating around threateningly...

A deadbeat dad radio host...

...and a gun that "only shoots bad people"

In podcast episode 2, Allegra recaps Beyond Belief Season 2 Episode 2! Segments include: Fire Station 32, The Computer, The Girl Next Door, The Wallet, and The Woods.

This episode features gems like:

A little boy firefighter

...a girl-next-door-loving bald guy...

...and plenty of falling down and screaming.

What were your favorite segments??

S2 E1 - Full episode

Gun experts all agree, this is how guns work. What other outrageous claims have you seen from characters in various segments?? This to me is one of the wildest.